Tony's N.Y. Pizza

145 S Barfield Dr, Marco Island
(239) 970-0027

Recent Reviews

C. Frank

Amazing pizza best ever in Marco. Grandma's Pizza is #1!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Froy

Fire pizza?

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris H.

Shopping center pizzeria with several Italian and Sicilian dishes.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cannoli

Cj Young

Tony's is the best place around here to grab yourself a pizza. Besides pizza they have a bunch of other items on the menu that are absolutely delicious like the calzones omg so much yum. Pizza by the slice or pie there's no wrong way as long as it comes from Tony's. I religiously eat this food after every workout guilt free and when the food is made from scratch and tastes so amazing who could blame me.Will keep coming back and won't stray either.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy Caruso

Ordered baked ziti and instead got manicotti. Antipasto was more akin to a salad. Obvious change in ownership. ?

victoria williams

Worst wings ever! Slimy and under cooked. Don't order! Pizza is great.

Food: 1

Robin Thieme

We got sick for 24 hours after eating their Athens salad. The manager was rude and not apologetic when notified. Can sadly not recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Angie C.

While the pizza is great, the time they tell you for pick up is WAY off. First time, my son waited 30 extra min. Gave them the benefit of the doubt and tried again. Same thing this time except it was an HOUR after they told us it would be ready (which was already a 50 min wait). This is unacceptable. If I knew the time was 2 hours I wouldn't have ordered and done something else. And no one wants to come and sit in the little restaurant for an hour when they could be waiting at home with family instead. Lost our business. Very disappointing since the pizza is great.

Carla T.

Ordered 3 pizzas online and paid online Thanksgiving Eve. Time for pick-up was 7:05. at store at 7 and they had not even started the first of 3 pizzas.. I was told come back in 20mins. Cane back - still not 1 pizza has been started.I understand being busy, but don't promise a time, ask me Tom one back in 20mins and still not have started on my pizzas.what in the heck??

Cadi T.

Placed an online order after being on hold for over 30 minutes. Go to pick up the order at the estimated time their website provided and the restaurant wasn't even busy. Once we asked to pick up the order, the kitchen just started making the pizzas so we were waiting with everyone else in the same situation. This could've been avoided by updating their ordering system or making the food in the order received? The frozen pizzas from the Publix next door sounded pretty good..

Donna Biamonte

I'm from Jersey and this pizza is amazing! Can't wait to go back! Owner was nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice

Abraham Rivera

Best pizza I had in a while and I’m a pizza houndEat there every day or every other daySuper friendly staffFast and very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice

Nancy Keeter

Went in tonight as they advertised pizza by the slice . We go in , sit and read the menu and go up to counter to order pizza by the slice and they told us no cheese or no pepperoni by the slice. My grandson will not eat what we all eat so that is why we choose this place as their menu states pizza by the slice. What the heck??? Saturday night and no cheese by the slice pizza or pepperoni? Rude as no one acknowledged us when we came in. We decided to leave and go next door to subway and had great customer service and great subs. (they make pizza cheese for kids as well).

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Keith R.

I placed and order at 4:45 on a Thursday and delivery was supposed to be in 75 minutes. I called after 2 hours and they said they would check on it and get back to me. They called 20 minutes later to say that the driver didn't show up so they would cancel my order. I will never use them again.

Rick L.

The margarita pizza was ok , lacking flavor 3 starsThe meat balls were very good 4.5 starsThe chicken parm was ok 2 stars , looked like precooked frozen chicken topped with sauce and cheese and put in the oven.

Load More