The options are amazing and so good. We will definitely be back.
Rebecca Pridemore
OMG! That's all I can say. The cakes, cookies, and pastries are phenomenal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Rahill
From the pizza and pasta at Amici to the steak and seafood at Chef’s Table—and then adding Michelle and the bakery—I couldn’t ask for more. Dave and his staff have truly mastered every aspect of the restaurant industry. My husband and I have been dining with them for years, but this December they went a step further by catering my husband’s birthday. The food was absolutely on point, and the cake deserves its own mention—Michelle went above and beyond. I was completely overwhelmed by how perfect everything turned out. I can’t thank this family and their team enough. No matter the day of the week, they always show up and show out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsay Richer
I ordered a variety of cupcakes and cookies for my mom’s 70th birthday and they were perfect. From ordering to pick up to being devoured by the guests, wonderful experience.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joel White
This used to be my favorite place, for the Italian Wedding Cookies. The past few times we have stopped in, the experience was subpar. One time not too long ago, they had no clue that anginetti are Italian Wedding Cookies. And today we walked in and waited for 3 minutes, nobody came to help us. The door has a bell to alert them, and finally, zero Italian Wedding Cookies @ 11AM on a Saturday.
Definitely has changed since I first went to this place 9 years ago.
Hopefully they get on the ball, the food is delicious, but not giving good customer service definitely taints the experience.
Leah Crites
Amici Family Bakery was the only place I could find who would do a full turtle cheesecake and I’m so glad they were because EVERYTHING we ordered was absolutely amazing. The service was so fast, SO friendly, and everything was “The best they ever tasted”, according to my family, and I agree!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Triolo
Amici’s bakery made my wedding cake on 10/10/25 and it was absolutely perfect!! The attention to detail with the design and flavors were incredible! We received a ton of compliments from our guests about how delicious the cake was. If you’re getting married I highly recommend getting your cake and desserts from here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe T
Just come get you some! Everything baked in house and taste's yummy! ❤️
Fantastic Italian desserts. Our first experience with Amici’s bakery was when Michelle provided the desserts for a work party. Now we’re pretty much weekly customers. Cookies, cupcakes, cakes, biscotti. All are wonderful
Great Bakery! Everything is made from scratch by the best Pastry Chef Michelle Franzen!
Marie
Such amazing selection and everything we tried is amazing! The pignoli cookies and carrot cake are our personal top two! Michelle is so kind, can’t wait to be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janel Hawley
I’m very impressed with this family bakery. Lovely desserts and lovely service! I walked in and told them I wanted cannolis for my husband’s birthday “cake” and they made it very special. I’m appreciative that they care so much to put the extra detail into it!
Michelle Marie
We've been going to Amici's for many years now. Their restaurant is incredible, but their bakery is top notch as well. Everything is always fresh and delicious. Their Pastry Chef, Michelle, really knows what she's doing. She is extremely skilled at her craft. We will continue to come here for years to come.
Sharon Murphy
I called to make our anniversary dinner reservation several weeks in advance. I informed them that it was our one year anniversary. We arrived for dinner ( a few minutes early) and were seated at the table behind the wall. There was a booth available out of the flow of traffic( unfortunately we were not given this). We eat here often and have found the food and service to be outstanding at each of our previous meals. This evening was very very disappointing. We had continuous problems getting service and had to ask repeatedly for bread, salad dressing and a drink correction( the wrong drink was brought to the table). At no time were we asked about our meals and if everything was satisfactory. As we left we spoke with the floor manager and his response was less than satisfactory. This was a one year anniversary dinner and we chose Amici’s to celebrate this occasion. We were also informed by the manager that tables were by reservation — which we made several weeks in advance. An anniversary is a special occasion which we entrusted Amici’s to make memorable however they failed miserably. We were made to feel unappreciated as customers. We have decided to no longer eat at this restaurant due to the bad experience and the managers lack of concern. I would recommend choosing another restaurant other than Amici’s for your special occasion. An anniversary comes only once per year and it should be a pleasurable and positive experience ( this was a very disappointing experience).
The options are amazing and so good. We will definitely be back.
OMG! That's all I can say. The cakes, cookies, and pastries are phenomenal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From the pizza and pasta at Amici to the steak and seafood at Chef’s Table—and then adding Michelle and the bakery—I couldn’t ask for more. Dave and his staff have truly mastered every aspect of the restaurant industry. My husband and I have been dining with them for years, but this December they went a step further by catering my husband’s birthday. The food was absolutely on point, and the cake deserves its own mention—Michelle went above and beyond. I was completely overwhelmed by how perfect everything turned out. I can’t thank this family and their team enough. No matter the day of the week, they always show up and show out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a variety of cupcakes and cookies for my mom’s 70th birthday and they were perfect.
From ordering to pick up to being devoured by the guests, wonderful experience.
Food: 5
Service: 5
This used to be my favorite place, for the Italian Wedding Cookies. The past few times we have stopped in, the experience was subpar. One time not too long ago, they had no clue that anginetti are Italian Wedding Cookies. And today we walked in and waited for 3 minutes, nobody came to help us. The door has a bell to alert them, and finally, zero Italian Wedding Cookies @ 11AM on a Saturday.
Definitely has changed since I first went to this place 9 years ago.
Hopefully they get on the ball, the food is delicious, but not giving good customer service definitely taints the experience.
Amici Family Bakery was the only place I could find who would do a full turtle cheesecake and I’m so glad they were because EVERYTHING we ordered was absolutely amazing. The service was so fast, SO friendly, and everything was “The best they ever tasted”, according to my family, and I agree!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amici’s bakery made my wedding cake on 10/10/25 and it was absolutely perfect!! The attention to detail with the design and flavors were incredible! We received a ton of compliments from our guests about how delicious the cake was. If you’re getting married I highly recommend getting your cake and desserts from here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just come get you some! Everything baked in house and taste's yummy! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious bakery. Always fresh. Highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic Italian desserts. Our first experience with Amici’s bakery was when Michelle provided the desserts for a work party. Now we’re pretty much weekly customers. Cookies, cupcakes, cakes, biscotti. All are wonderful
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Bakery! Everything is made from scratch by the best Pastry Chef Michelle Franzen!
Such amazing selection and everything we tried is amazing! The pignoli cookies and carrot cake are our personal top two! Michelle is so kind, can’t wait to be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m very impressed with this family bakery. Lovely desserts and lovely service! I walked in and told them I wanted cannolis for my husband’s birthday “cake” and they made it very special. I’m appreciative that they care so much to put the extra detail into it!
We've been going to Amici's for many years now. Their restaurant is incredible, but their bakery is top notch as well. Everything is always fresh and delicious. Their Pastry Chef, Michelle, really knows what she's doing. She is extremely skilled at her craft. We will continue to come here for years to come.
I called to make our anniversary dinner reservation several weeks in advance. I informed them that it was our one year anniversary. We arrived for dinner ( a few minutes early) and were seated at the table behind the wall. There was a booth available out of the flow of traffic( unfortunately we were not given this).
We eat here often and have found the food and service to be outstanding at each of our previous meals. This evening was very very disappointing.
We had continuous problems getting service and had to ask repeatedly for bread, salad dressing and a drink correction( the wrong drink was brought to the table).
At no time were we asked about our meals and if everything was satisfactory.
As we left we spoke with the floor manager
and his response was less than satisfactory.
This was a one year anniversary dinner and we chose Amici’s to celebrate this occasion.
We were also informed by the manager that tables were by reservation — which we made several weeks in advance. An anniversary is a special occasion which we entrusted Amici’s to make memorable however they failed miserably. We were made to feel unappreciated as customers. We have decided to no longer eat at this restaurant due to the bad experience and the managers lack of concern.
I would recommend choosing another restaurant other than Amici’s for your special occasion. An anniversary comes only once per year and it should be a pleasurable and positive experience ( this was a very disappointing experience).
Loading...