Fantastic Italian desserts. Our first experience with Amici’s bakery was when Michelle provided the desserts for a work party. Now we’re pretty much weekly customers. Cookies, cupcakes, cakes, biscotti. All are wonderful
Marie
Such amazing selection and everything we tried is amazing! The pignoli cookies and carrot cake are our personal top two! Michelle is so kind, can’t wait to be back!
Janel Hawley
I’m very impressed with this family bakery. Lovely desserts and lovely service! I walked in and told them I wanted cannolis for my husband’s birthday “cake” and they made it very special. I’m appreciative that they care so much to put the extra detail into it!
Michelle Marie
We've been going to Amici's for many years now. Their restaurant is incredible, but their bakery is top notch as well. Everything is always fresh and delicious. Their Pastry Chef, Michelle, really knows what she's doing. She is extremely skilled at her craft. We will continue to come here for years to come.
Sharon Murphy
I called to make our anniversary dinner reservation several weeks in advance. I informed them that it was our one year anniversary. We arrived for dinner ( a few minutes early) and were seated at the table behind the wall. There was a booth available out of the flow of traffic( unfortunately we were not given this). We eat here often and have found the food and service to be outstanding at each of our previous meals. This evening was very very disappointing. We had continuous problems getting service and had to ask repeatedly for bread, salad dressing and a drink correction( the wrong drink was brought to the table). At no time were we asked about our meals and if everything was satisfactory. As we left we spoke with the floor manager and his response was less than satisfactory. This was a one year anniversary dinner and we chose Amici’s to celebrate this occasion. We were also informed by the manager that tables were by reservation — which we made several weeks in advance. An anniversary is a special occasion which we entrusted Amici’s to make memorable however they failed miserably. We were made to feel unappreciated as customers. We have decided to no longer eat at this restaurant due to the bad experience and the managers lack of concern. I would recommend choosing another restaurant other than Amici’s for your special occasion. An anniversary comes only once per year and it should be a pleasurable and positive experience ( this was a very disappointing experience).
Yolanda B.
This bakery is a must go to. Each time I visit the area, I’m greeted warmly by the baker which is everything. I tried the cannolis, peanut butter cookies (geez), the coconut macaroons ( none fresher nor tastier), and today.. the incredible pignoli cookies that I must say, top any cookie I’ve ever had. A gem of a place. I’ll be back soon :>)
Chrissie Ruscitelli Lynn
Always the best Italian pastries
Donna Kowalchuk
The almond ricotta was delicious. Prepared as a sheet cake for a wedding. Michelle was helpful in determining the size of sheet cake for amount of people in attendance. Also ordered a red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. Both cakes were a big hit. Highly recommend. Stopped back following week for slice of ricotta cake.
Angela Brader Swartley
I ordered two custom cakes for a birthday party for my husband’s 70th and his best friend’s 66th. The cakes were both beautiful, exactly as I requested and they were delicious. The Miami Dolphins was a cheesecake and this bakery makes the very best cheesecake I’ve ever had. The whiskey cake was chocolate peanut butter and it was amazing. The frosting tasted like fudge! I was a little nervous a few times because the baker is very busy so there was lag time in communication and I didn’t get the cost until I picked up the cakes. However, now that I’ve worked with her, I trust her to carry out my vision and the prices were actually very reasonable.
Angela Brader Swartley
I ordered two custom cakes, a cheesecake and a chocolate peanut butter cake. Both were beautiful and delicious!
The bakery is FANTASTIC!! The staff friendly and very pleasant. A great assortment of cookies , cakes and a GREAT NY cheesecake!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Viviana Luna
Definitely worth it. Amazing options and the owner is super sweet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah kemble
Amici’s is so lucky to have Michelle as their pastry chef. Michelle is a pastry genius and a true artist. She baked the treats for our rehearsal dinner and wedding in October and everyone could not stop talking about A) how beautiful it all was and B) how great it all tasted. She made us 2 types of shooters (key lime pie and chocolate peanut butter) for the rehearsal dinner (to show our FL and OH heritage). We told her our idea for that and trusted her creativity and expertise and were blown away by how cute they were and how amazing they tasted. For our wedding, we got a cake, pastry tray, and a bunch of mini cupcakes. All beautiful, all amazing. She even packed me and my (now) husband a personal box that we got to eat and munch on that night, the next morning and for days after. The few desserts that were leftover lasted us over a week in the fridge and were still awesome. Aside from the talent, Michelle is just so sweet, personable, and really cared about giving us a product we were happy with. When our wedding was delayed a week due to the hurricane, she worked with us and adjusted our order to accommodate the smaller guest count, and was so helpful throughout the whole process. Every time we went into Amici’s over our 18 month engagement, we left with a box of treats to share with family (sometimes mini cookies, sometimes the large cookies, sometimes cupcakes, and always a cannoli). Everything we would get was great. I couldn’t recommend Amici’s Bakery (Michelle) enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Christensen
I’ve heard about this bakery for so long and finally went to try it. It is amazing! The pastry chef there is so talented and gave us great recommendations based on our taste. We tried: cannolis, a lobster tail, a carrot cake cupcake, and a chocolate cupcake with cannoli filling. Everything was beautiful and tasty, but the cupcakes were especially delicious! The carrot cake one had cream cheese frosting, and the chocolate one had ganache frosting. Very reasonable prices. Highly recommend this place and I already want to return to try the seasonal pumpkin cheesecake. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sheri Palmer
This bakery is SO GOOD!! When you walk in, you will be blown away by the amount of choices! Italian cookies, cupcakes, pastries and cheesecake....and of course, cannoli, filled when you order them! Their cannoli cream is to die for! And you absolutely must try the cannoli lobster claw. It's a very flaky pastry filled AND topped with delicious cannoli cream. And the ricotta cookies.... OMG! Soft and fluffy with a hint of lemon! Absolutely delicious! Every cookie and pastry we bought was delicious! And the lady who helped us, possibly the owner, was amazing! So friendly and helpful, we really enjoyed talking with her. This place is a must try if you love Italian desserts!
Fantastic Italian desserts. Our first experience with Amici’s bakery was when Michelle provided the desserts for a work party. Now we’re pretty much weekly customers. Cookies, cupcakes, cakes, biscotti. All are wonderful
Such amazing selection and everything we tried is amazing! The pignoli cookies and carrot cake are our personal top two! Michelle is so kind, can’t wait to be back!
I’m very impressed with this family bakery. Lovely desserts and lovely service! I walked in and told them I wanted cannolis for my husband’s birthday “cake” and they made it very special. I’m appreciative that they care so much to put the extra detail into it!
We've been going to Amici's for many years now. Their restaurant is incredible, but their bakery is top notch as well. Everything is always fresh and delicious. Their Pastry Chef, Michelle, really knows what she's doing. She is extremely skilled at her craft. We will continue to come here for years to come.
I called to make our anniversary dinner reservation several weeks in advance. I informed them that it was our one year anniversary. We arrived for dinner ( a few minutes early) and were seated at the table behind the wall. There was a booth available out of the flow of traffic( unfortunately we were not given this).
We eat here often and have found the food and service to be outstanding at each of our previous meals. This evening was very very disappointing.
We had continuous problems getting service and had to ask repeatedly for bread, salad dressing and a drink correction( the wrong drink was brought to the table).
At no time were we asked about our meals and if everything was satisfactory.
As we left we spoke with the floor manager
and his response was less than satisfactory.
This was a one year anniversary dinner and we chose Amici’s to celebrate this occasion.
We were also informed by the manager that tables were by reservation — which we made several weeks in advance. An anniversary is a special occasion which we entrusted Amici’s to make memorable however they failed miserably. We were made to feel unappreciated as customers. We have decided to no longer eat at this restaurant due to the bad experience and the managers lack of concern.
I would recommend choosing another restaurant other than Amici’s for your special occasion. An anniversary comes only once per year and it should be a pleasurable and positive experience ( this was a very disappointing experience).
This bakery is a must go to. Each time I visit the area, I’m greeted warmly by the baker which is everything. I tried the cannolis, peanut butter cookies (geez), the coconut macaroons ( none fresher nor tastier), and today.. the incredible pignoli cookies that I must say, top any cookie I’ve ever had.
A gem of a place. I’ll be back soon :>)
Always the best Italian pastries
The almond ricotta was delicious. Prepared as a sheet cake for a wedding. Michelle was helpful in determining the size of sheet cake for amount of people in attendance. Also ordered a red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. Both cakes were a big hit. Highly recommend. Stopped back following week for slice of ricotta cake.
I ordered two custom cakes for a birthday party for my husband’s 70th and his best friend’s 66th. The cakes were both beautiful, exactly as I requested and they were delicious. The Miami Dolphins was a cheesecake and this bakery makes the very best cheesecake I’ve ever had. The whiskey cake was chocolate peanut butter and it was amazing. The frosting tasted like fudge! I was a little nervous a few times because the baker is very busy so there was lag time in communication and I didn’t get the cost until I picked up the cakes. However, now that I’ve worked with her, I trust her to carry out my vision and the prices were actually very reasonable.
I ordered two custom cakes, a cheesecake and a chocolate peanut butter cake. Both were beautiful and delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
The bakery is FANTASTIC!! The staff friendly and very pleasant. A great assortment of cookies , cakes and a GREAT NY cheesecake!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely worth it. Amazing options and the owner is super sweet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amici’s is so lucky to have Michelle as their pastry chef. Michelle is a pastry genius and a true artist. She baked the treats for our rehearsal dinner and wedding in October and everyone could not stop talking about A) how beautiful it all was and B) how great it all tasted. She made us 2 types of shooters (key lime pie and chocolate peanut butter) for the rehearsal dinner (to show our FL and OH heritage). We told her our idea for that and trusted her creativity and expertise and were blown away by how cute they were and how amazing they tasted.
For our wedding, we got a cake, pastry tray, and a bunch of mini cupcakes. All beautiful, all amazing. She even packed me and my (now) husband a personal box that we got to eat and munch on that night, the next morning and for days after. The few desserts that were leftover lasted us over a week in the fridge and were still awesome.
Aside from the talent, Michelle is just so sweet, personable, and really cared about giving us a product we were happy with. When our wedding was delayed a week due to the hurricane, she worked with us and adjusted our order to accommodate the smaller guest count, and was so helpful throughout the whole process. Every time we went into Amici’s over our 18 month engagement, we left with a box of treats to share with family (sometimes mini cookies, sometimes the large cookies, sometimes cupcakes, and always a cannoli). Everything we would get was great. I couldn’t recommend Amici’s Bakery (Michelle) enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve heard about this bakery for so long and finally went to try it. It is amazing! The pastry chef there is so talented and gave us great recommendations based on our taste. We tried: cannolis, a lobster tail, a carrot cake cupcake, and a chocolate cupcake with cannoli filling. Everything was beautiful and tasty, but the cupcakes were especially delicious! The carrot cake one had cream cheese frosting, and the chocolate one had ganache frosting. Very reasonable prices. Highly recommend this place and I already want to return to try the seasonal pumpkin cheesecake. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This bakery is SO GOOD!! When you walk in, you will be blown away by the amount of choices! Italian cookies, cupcakes, pastries and cheesecake....and of course, cannoli, filled when you order them! Their cannoli cream is to die for! And you absolutely must try the cannoli lobster claw. It's a very flaky pastry filled AND topped with delicious cannoli cream. And the ricotta cookies.... OMG! Soft and fluffy with a hint of lemon! Absolutely delicious! Every cookie and pastry we bought was delicious! And the lady who helped us, possibly the owner, was amazing! So friendly and helpful, we really enjoyed talking with her. This place is a must try if you love Italian desserts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...