Terrible dinner salads. Ordered a small lunch salad like I had before even showed the waitress a picture of it, she said no problem I’ll have it right out. Instead she brought something completely different, Giant salad and told me, AFTER she brought it to my table, that they aren’t allowed to give you anything from the lunch menu it was dinner only. When I expressed my disappointment the waitress just said that’s the rules we have to follow. Didn’t offer any alternative or to reorder. Not a good dinning experience for me at all. This was 9/28/24
Joan Marshall
DELISH! I will be getting my pizzas from Times Square from now on. I've tried pizza from many places. Times Square outshines all of them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim W
First visit - came with family and friends a little after noon on Sunday. Definitely a busy time for them, but we were seated immediately and they put a couple of tables together since we had more than 4 in the group. Menu had good variety of choices, and I liked being able to have breakfast items after noon.
I had spotted the Sunday Special (Spinach Pie) and the Galaktoboureko dessert on the menu online and was really looking forward to trying them, but neither was available when we were there. Not deducting anything from the score for that - both are very labor intensive dishes and if you go at Sunday lunch rush, there’s going to be a good chance that they just don’t have them. Would still be interested in trying them, so might see if that’s something you can call ahead and reserve…
But the food I did end up ordering was the Greek omelette. (See photo). This is a massive dish of food! The eggs maintained a very nice fluffy consistency, and was moist and evenly cooked. Potatoes were also cooked to perfection, with good portion size and subtle seasoning. There was enough to get a take home box for breakfast next day.
I did see several other things that looked interesting for future visits, look forward to exploring other dishes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Omelette Home Fries
Michelle Ouellette
Food was great. They brought out my boyfriends food 15 minutes before my food. Service is terrible.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ron Harrison
Checked out this Diner by ordering a turkey club sandwich. I was served highly processed turkey slices that would be purchased at any supermarket, prepackaged for $6 per pound, not even close to real turkey. Very unexpected for a Diner. If you are looking for something better than "off the shelf" prepackaged meat, try Coasters in Indialantic (between Walmart and Texas Road House). Very good sandwiches and reasonably priced.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
The Champ
Hands down the best breakfast place I have been to. From the charming decor and the welcoming garden in front to the attentive server ensuring I was utterly satisfied, every detail was perfect. The breakfast itself was absolutely delicious. It’s clear that both the owner and the employees take immense pride in their work. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Noah Stutzman
I had fish and chips and they were very good. Just a heads up the Portions are big which isn't a problem. The only reason why this isn't 5 stars is because my order was slightly messed up. But overall this place is very good and I would recommend
Brought a friend for an enjoyable and delicious breakfast. We both ordered the New York toasted bagel with fresh lox, cream cheese, capers, juicy tomatoes, and crispy lettuce along with good coffee. Nice presentation. Our waitress, Lana provided excellent service, very attentive to her customers. It was a very pleasant experience and highly recommend Times Square diner for all occasions. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joel Dodds
First visit for us. Excellent, large portions. Had the monte cristo. Just the bread lightly battered, not completely deep fried like the old Bennigan’s version, which made for a wonderful mix of texture and flavors. Better half had the turkey BLT, which was very large and fresh according to her.
Lana was our attentive and very friendly server. Perfect blend of service and smiles.
Already looking forward to another visit for breakfast.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
PJ S
The best grits in town! The whole dish was absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Hoffmann
Let me start by saying our server was very nice and accommodating. The reason for the 1 star had to do with my husbands meal. He ordered the Gyro platter which was very disappointing. The meat which should be very juicy was very thin and dry, more like lamb jerky. The pita was heated to the point of being more like a crispy cracker and the fries were cooked to the point of being more like potato chips then fries. I would not recommend this diner to my friends, but again we were very pleased with our server.
Magi Kyle
Everything here that I had which was the eggs Benedict was great and the tomatoes were awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Benedict and Deli Benedict
Terrible dinner salads. Ordered a small lunch salad like I had before even showed the waitress a picture of it, she said no problem I’ll have it right out. Instead she brought something completely different, Giant salad and told me, AFTER she brought it to my table, that they aren’t allowed to give you anything from the lunch menu it was dinner only. When I expressed my disappointment the waitress just said that’s the rules we have to follow. Didn’t offer any alternative or to reorder. Not a good dinning experience for me at all. This was 9/28/24
DELISH! I will be getting my pizzas from Times Square from now on. I've tried pizza from many places. Times Square outshines all of them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First visit - came with family and friends a little after noon on Sunday. Definitely a busy time for them, but we were seated immediately and they put a couple of tables together since we had more than 4 in the group. Menu had good variety of choices, and I liked being able to have breakfast items after noon.
I had spotted the Sunday Special (Spinach Pie) and the Galaktoboureko dessert on the menu online and was really looking forward to trying them, but neither was available when we were there. Not deducting anything from the score for that - both are very labor intensive dishes and if you go at Sunday lunch rush, there’s going to be a good chance that they just don’t have them. Would still be interested in trying them, so might see if that’s something you can call ahead and reserve…
But the food I did end up ordering was the Greek omelette. (See photo). This is a massive dish of food! The eggs maintained a very nice fluffy consistency, and was moist and evenly cooked. Potatoes were also cooked to perfection, with good portion size and subtle seasoning. There was enough to get a take home box for breakfast next day.
I did see several other things that looked interesting for future visits, look forward to exploring other dishes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Omelette Home Fries
Food was great. They brought out my boyfriends food 15 minutes before my food. Service is terrible.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Checked out this Diner by ordering a turkey club sandwich. I was served highly processed turkey slices that would be purchased at any supermarket, prepackaged for $6 per pound, not even close to real turkey. Very unexpected for a Diner. If you are looking for something better than "off the shelf" prepackaged meat, try Coasters in Indialantic (between Walmart and Texas Road House). Very good sandwiches and reasonably priced.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Hands down the best breakfast place I have been to. From the charming decor and the welcoming garden in front to the attentive server ensuring I was utterly satisfied, every detail was perfect. The breakfast itself was absolutely delicious. It’s clear that both the owner and the employees take immense pride in their work. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had fish and chips and they were very good. Just a heads up the Portions are big which isn't a problem. The only reason why this isn't 5 stars is because my order was slightly messed up. But overall this place is very good and I would recommend
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Omelette Home Fries
The food was fantastic and plentiful!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Marinated Chicken Gyro
Definitely above average, reasonable prices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Brought a friend for an enjoyable and delicious breakfast. We both ordered the New York toasted bagel with fresh lox, cream cheese, capers, juicy tomatoes, and crispy lettuce along with good coffee. Nice presentation. Our waitress, Lana provided excellent service, very attentive to her customers. It was a very pleasant experience and highly recommend Times Square diner for all occasions. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First visit for us. Excellent, large portions. Had the monte cristo. Just the bread lightly battered, not completely deep fried like the old Bennigan’s version, which made for a wonderful mix of texture and flavors. Better half had the turkey BLT, which was very large and fresh according to her.
Lana was our attentive and very friendly server. Perfect blend of service and smiles.
Already looking forward to another visit for breakfast.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best grits in town! The whole dish was absolutely delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Let me start by saying our server was very nice and accommodating. The reason for the 1 star had to do with my husbands meal. He ordered the Gyro platter which was very disappointing. The meat which should be very juicy was very thin and dry, more like lamb jerky. The pita was heated to the point of being more like a crispy cracker and the fries were cooked to the point of being more like potato chips then fries.
I would not recommend this diner to my friends, but again we were very pleased with our server.
Everything here that I had which was the eggs Benedict was great and the tomatoes were awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Benedict and Deli Benedict
Loading...