My Island Ice Cream
110 S Courtenay Pkwy, Merritt Island
(321) 848-0035
Customers' Favorites
Strawberry Black Raspberry Waffle Cone Plus Elephant Ear Fudge Sundae
Red Velvet and Peach Melba and Black Raspberry
CIS for Cookie Blue Cookie Monster Flavor
Rocky Road and Salted Carmel Ice Cream
Cherry Ice Cream Loaded With
Toasted Coconut Ice Cream
2 Scoop of Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream
Superman Ice Cream
Praline Ice Cream
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I chose this place because of the 5 star rating on Google and it deserved every one of those 5 star ratings. That was the best chocolate peanut butter ice cream I've ever had, and I'm a chocolate peanut butter ice cream snob?. I was just visiting the area for the week, but when I come back I'll be going to My Island Ice Cream again. And I will be looking for The Ice Cream Club brand ice cream at other ice cream shops?.
First off, the customer service was a 10/10, everyone we spoke to was so wonderful and friendly. The ice cream was good, though with 70 flavors we were surprised that my husband's favorite flavor coffee chip (forgot the correct name-but it's by the same brand they use) wasn't available. Would have been nice to add some chocolate flakes but it's ok, it still tastes good! They had my favorite flavors! Which is purple daze and chocolate and peanut butter. Though...
So many delicious flavors! You can sample first too. The shop is very decorated and fun, and the people working there are very friendly and helpful. Pleasant dessert experience! We will definitely be back. Oh and they have no sugar added options.
You May Also Like
Hokkaido Japanese Steakhouse - 125 E Merritt Island Cswy #115
![]()
Japanese, Vegetarian
Joy Luck - 125 E Merritt Island Cswy
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
Firehouse Subs Merritt Island - 125 E Merritt Island Cswy #129
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food