Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies

$ • Pizza, Italian, Sports Bars

Hours:
850 North Jefferson Street Unit 910, Monticello
(850) 997-4000

About Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies

Mafia Pizza, now known as Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria, is a restaurant located in a house-like building with a spacious interior in a small area of northern Florida. They offer a delicious Baked Ziti and hand-tossed pizza, with a beautiful salad bar. The large cheese pizza was good, although some wished for more sauce. The prices are fair, the staff is friendly, and it's a place worth revisiting.

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

4.4
176 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
80%
4
9%
3
2%
1
9%
Food
4.4
Atmosphere
4.5
Service
4.3

Share your opinion about Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies

Restaurantji Rating

I come from New York and I had 4 Italian restaurants within walking distance of my house. I went to a different one for what I wanted. They were all well known and people would come from miles away. I tried to find that quality here and never did until I found Mafia now known Papa & Nonna's. I HIT GOLD. I travel 40 minutes to get there and honestly I would would travel as far as I have too. I finally have equally as good or better than I did in New York and all in one place. I...read full review

Highly Recommend C.R. Pie C.R. Pies Pizzeria. Happy to have a local pizza joint back inside Monticello! Great food and Great Service.

COME ON OVER TO C.R. PIZZA.

THEY ARE TINY BUT MIGHTY!!!

ARE YOU LOOKING FOR FAST FOOD AND FRIENDLY SERVICE?
THIS IS THE PLACE TO COME.

THEY HAVE A VARIETY OF THE BEST PIZZA, WINGS, SALAD BAR, AND APPETIZERS AND SOME ITALIAN DISHES.

COME AS A FRIEND LEAVE AS FAMILY.

Read All Reviews(176)

Menu

Add a Menu
Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies Menu
Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies
Mafia Pizza / now as C.R. Pies
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 11AM - 8:30PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 11AM - 8:30PM
Friday 11AM - 8:30PM
Saturday 11AM - 8:30PM
Sunday 11AM - 8:30PM
Updated on: