Anthony’s has been a long time favorite of our family and we probably eat here takeout at least twice a month. If you’re looking for a great pizza at a good price, this is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fred Cunningham
Came to the restaurant at 7:32 and was told they couple only accommodate to go orders because they closed in “20 minutes.” I recommend them changing their hours if they are that concerned about closing the dining room prior to 8PM. We were excited to bring our family of five for dinner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Karen A
⛔️ warning. Check pizza before leaving. Drove 20 miles home after picking up pizza and the pizza was BURNT!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Hank Squat
If you like pizza sauce from a can you’ll love this place for pizza
Jennifer T.
Is one of my fav restaurants in this area.. Just a plain pepperoni pizza, best I've ever had. Want a calzone, awesome. I also really like their shells and cheese, their manicotti, and the chicken parm. Comes with an awesome little salad, and a garlic knot, also awesome. They deliver to my hard to find home, prompt, and great service. Highly recommend.
Abigail Kane
Love this place so much! The food is so good and everyone is super nice. There is usually no wait and the service is quick! Perfect place to eat after a workout!Kid-friendliness: Just super nice in general!
The BEST pizza place in Mt Dora. Their pizzas are big and loaded with toppings. Pick up orders are usually ready in 20 minutes. Service is professional a d friendly. HIGHLY recommend ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jay B
The food was beautiful made and delicious! I ordered my pizza well done, and they executed to perfection!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dominic Santopietro
I have been there twice, once for lunch and once for dinner. Mybl lunch experience was really good. I ordered the stromboli. The service and food was awesome. I came 2nd time and it was around 830 at night I did not realize they closed at 9 I ordered a pizza for dine-in. Once I was seated I was told dining was not an option anymore and had to take it to go. The pizza was good but not amazing. To be clear my parents owned 3 Italian restaurants growing up and I am Italian on both sides of my family so I am a little picky about Italian food.
Tried to call them at least 15 times. Nobody ever picked up. One time it went to fax.
Jennifer Townsend (Jeny Gonzalez)
I should have reviewed these guys the first time I tried their NY pepperoni pizza, best I've ever had! Anyway, I eat there almost every week, it is ALWAYS FIRST RATE. Anyway, I love all their other stuff too, and today I wanted a calzone delivered. And I live in a crazy complicated complex, DJ delivered it within 4 min of it being expected,and called for clarification when things weren't clear.Great job, consistently wonderful food no matter what you order, for a really reasonable price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Matt S.
My daughter and I each had, by far, the WORST chicken parmesan subs that I have ever tasted. I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY, wish I would have just stayed home, saved my money, and cooked my own lunch. Wow! Barely any chicken at all on these subs, and the chicken that was there was tough, dry, and chewy. There was also barely any cheese. The sauce had zero flavor. We basically paid for two plain sub rolls. Massive disappointment, and on Father's Day no less. I can't imagine we will ever return.
Dennis Brewer
Soggy slices - asked the kid to re-cook it twice and then he gave me lip the second time I tried to give it back. All the toppings fell off the slice and was wet with cold cheese. This place used to be better but this guy is apparently too busy hanging out at the smoke shop next door to learn how to fire a simple pie.
Robert P.
Ordered an XL pizza for take out, slow afternoon so the pie was ready in 15 minutes. The pizza was good but the mozzarella cheese definitely was not the best quality such as Grande Mozzarella. Aside from the pizza, this was my first time at the Eustis location and from my personal/professional observation being in the pizza business up north, this particular establishment is in bad need of a cleaning and make over. The lighting was extremely dim and dirty, especially in the kitchen area. Of course, low lighting will make dirt/soot/grease less conspicuous, and, harder to see dirt when cleaning, hopefully this isn't on purpose. My first impression was not a good one but unfortunately may be my last. I will go the extra miles to the Apopka location, much better, for my next pick up. Hopefully the owner will read this and make the necessary changes. As I understand food cost, Grande Mozzarella is not going to happen but a thorough cleaning with better lighting, should. Just a suggestion.
Great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Chef's Salad, Stromboli, Meat Lovers Stromboli, Extravaganza Pizza
Anthony’s has been a long time favorite of our family and we probably eat here takeout at least twice a month. If you’re looking for a great pizza at a good price, this is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came to the restaurant at 7:32 and was told they couple only accommodate to go orders because they closed in “20 minutes.” I recommend them changing their hours if they are that concerned about closing the dining room prior to 8PM. We were excited to bring our family of five for dinner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
⛔️ warning. Check pizza before leaving. Drove 20 miles home after picking up pizza and the pizza was BURNT!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
If you like pizza sauce from a can you’ll love this place for pizza
Is one of my fav restaurants in this area.. Just a plain pepperoni pizza, best I've ever had. Want a calzone, awesome. I also really like their shells and cheese, their manicotti, and the chicken parm. Comes with an awesome little salad, and a garlic knot, also awesome. They deliver to my hard to find home, prompt, and great service. Highly recommend.
Love this place so much! The food is so good and everyone is super nice. There is usually no wait and the service is quick! Perfect place to eat after a workout!Kid-friendliness: Just super nice in general!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knot, Caeser Salad, Salad
The BEST pizza place in Mt Dora. Their pizzas are big and loaded with toppings. Pick up orders are usually ready in 20 minutes. Service is professional a d friendly. HIGHLY recommend ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was beautiful made and delicious! I ordered my pizza well done, and they executed to perfection!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been there twice, once for lunch and once for dinner. Mybl lunch experience was really good. I ordered the stromboli. The service and food was awesome. I came 2nd time and it was around 830 at night I did not realize they closed at 9 I ordered a pizza for dine-in. Once I was seated I was told dining was not an option anymore and had to take it to go. The pizza was good but not amazing. To be clear my parents owned 3 Italian restaurants growing up and I am Italian on both sides of my family so I am a little picky about Italian food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stromboli
Restaurantji Recommends
Tried to call them at least 15 times. Nobody ever picked up. One time it went to fax.
I should have reviewed these guys the first time I tried their NY pepperoni pizza, best I've ever had! Anyway, I eat there almost every week, it is ALWAYS FIRST RATE. Anyway, I love all their other stuff too, and today I wanted a calzone delivered. And I live in a crazy complicated complex, DJ delivered it within 4 min of it being expected,and called for clarification when things weren't clear.Great job, consistently wonderful food no matter what you order, for a really reasonable price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My daughter and I each had, by far, the WORST chicken parmesan subs that I have ever tasted. I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY, wish I would have just stayed home, saved my money, and cooked my own lunch. Wow! Barely any chicken at all on these subs, and the chicken that was there was tough, dry, and chewy. There was also barely any cheese. The sauce had zero flavor. We basically paid for two plain sub rolls. Massive disappointment, and on Father's Day no less. I can't imagine we will ever return.
Soggy slices - asked the kid to re-cook it twice and then he gave me lip the second time I tried to give it back. All the toppings fell off the slice and was wet with cold cheese. This place used to be better but this guy is apparently too busy hanging out at the smoke shop next door to learn how to fire a simple pie.
Ordered an XL pizza for take out, slow afternoon so the pie was ready in 15 minutes. The pizza was good but the mozzarella cheese definitely was not the best quality such as Grande Mozzarella. Aside from the pizza, this was my first time at the Eustis location and from my personal/professional observation being in the pizza business up north, this particular establishment is in bad need of a cleaning and make over. The lighting was extremely dim and dirty, especially in the kitchen area. Of course, low lighting will make dirt/soot/grease less conspicuous, and, harder to see dirt when cleaning, hopefully this isn't on purpose. My first impression was not a good one but unfortunately may be my last. I will go the extra miles to the Apopka location, much better, for my next pick up. Hopefully the owner will read this and make the necessary changes. As I understand food cost, Grande Mozzarella is not going to happen but a thorough cleaning with better lighting, should. Just a suggestion.