Hogfish Harry's Restaurant + Bar

Worst hospitality experience I’ve ever had.
The problem started immediately with the host, who was extremely rude, dismissive, and made us feel flat-out unwelcome. Honestly, the way we were treated felt borderline racist, and that is not something I say lightly.
We came in with a party of 9 adults and a small baby. There were at least 8 EMPTY tables inside, clearly visible, yet we were refused indoor seating without any valid explanation. Instead, we were told to sit outside in 48-degree weather — with a baby. Completely unacceptable.
No attempt to accommodate us. No courtesy. No respect. Just an attitude that made it very clear we were not wanted there.
We were so disgusted and disappointed that we stood up and left immediately. Not a single person in our group wanted to stay after that treatment.
Hogfish Harry's does not deserve anyone’s business. If you value basic human decency, hospitality, or respect — go somewhere else.
Never again. Ever.

Service: 1

The food was excellent. We had coconut shrimp and lobster and shrimp Mac n cheese. Both dishes were delicious. Our server, Micheal was high energy, fun, friendly and ready to tell us about the menu and specials. He made great recommendations. And the key lime pie was the best ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely outstanding! Lenny, the owner was incredibly friendly, ensuring everyone was well taken care of. Service was attentive! I got the brussel and kale salad, their signature hogfish sandwich (the remoulade is outstanding I recommend getting an extra side) and the carrot cake which was DELECTABLE! The walk over to the restaurant felt like an oasis retreat. Overall wonderful experience; I will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My lady is from Maryland and when it comes to crab cakes she is hard to please 😆 but this place did it! I came here a few times and the food was amazing. Great drinks and I love the service. Keep up the great work and I will be back soon

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A fun place to meet up with friends and enjoy good food. We had a wonderful time with our server - and our food was delicious.

Hogfish Harry's never disappoints. Hogfish is a real fish and this restaurant knows how to prepare it and all their fish offerings perfectly. Leave room for dessert. We always get the sharable carrot cake. Some day I'm going to try their Sticky Toffee Pudding. Our server, Milan, was wonderful - Charming, knowledgable, attentive, but not in your face. Great restaurant for pre-theatre dinner if you're going to an Artis performance, only a mile away.

It was a lovely evening, had a table outside, but under a heat lamp which was key. The food was delicious and well prepared. Excellent service as well from Sam!

Went for dinner and pleasantly surprised. Great food choices and outside seating had heaters. Would recommend for couples and smaller groups. Service was great and the food was amazing!

We were seated promptly with a reservation. The restaurant filled up quickly and it was bustling. We ordered the hogfish and chips and the special. The hog fish was a bit overcooked, but the special was delicious. It was a medley of grouper over risotto with a citrus buerre blanc sauce. The prices were high. We had three drinks and 2 dinners and our bill was $190 plus tip. Service was excellent. We would go back because it was a fun atmosphere.

We went on recommendation from friend. It was absolutely fantastic food and service. One of our best meals of the trip!

Excellent food and service by Summer, a delightful, knowledgeable, and kind young woman. Highly recommend this jewel of a restaurant situated over a little bridge and pond overlooking a pool. A must restaurant to enjoy and cherish!

Great service from Michael. Great meal. Sit outdoors if possible. Restaurant indoors can get loud

Another cold night on the porch but under the heat lamp. and we tried the Nueben and Grouper sandwiches for the first time. Fires were great but the sandwiches were average. Service was very average and we never could get the salt.

We were visiting Naples on Christmas Day and Hogfish was open and so happy it was - our lunch was excellent! This place has such a fun vibe and look forward to returning.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Towering Carrot Cake Table Shareable

Our server was a jerk, acted like he couldn't care less about us or his job. Not a friendly guy.