Big disappointmen!! Friend made reservations for us 10 days ago. even called back to confirm. We all got there and were told there was NO reservation. After standing there for 15 minute, we all walked across the courtyard to Don Tequila, where we were seat immediately, had fabulous friendly service, and wonderful dinners! Good luck to you Pelagos in the off season. You've lost long time year round patrons. We certainly won't be back, and will pass the word about our experience with your restaurant.
Nick Michels
We come here a couple times per month. The food is fresh and excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela Calakos
Food was very good, although we felt a little rushed because we came without reservations. The menu online was very different from the actual prices at the restaurant. Our chicken dinners were $30 each which was a little pricey but that’s Naples!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Manny D.
Place from the outside is unassuming, but literally everything on the inside is amazing. We had the Greek salad, the chicken souvlaki, Kafta kebab and hummus. All ridiculous good. It's relatively healthy so you can't go wrong. The fries not healthy but still delicious. The owner and one waitress were more than helpful and zero complaints with the service. 5/5 stars.
Peter Tsaffaras
Great people. Great food. Nice atmosphere. Recommend it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank K.
My favourite Greek restaurant in Naples they have the best lamb shank in town. I think everything on the menu is great.
Tracey Burton Villalba
An awesome family-run restaurant with the most wonderful owners and staff. The food is fresh, authentic and fabulous. This is a regular stop for my husband and I, and their take-out is awesome when we want a quiet night at home. We love this place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roshmi Mishra
Awesome authentic Greek food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Falafel, Hummus, Chicken Gyro
Paul Van Wagner
Dinner was excellent. I had the moussaka and tiramiso. If I could give them 6 stars, I would.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stu B.
Really good Greek food. Family owned and operated and it feels that way in a good sense
If you go here for one thing go for the octopus. Call first. Make sure they have it. Cause if you go and they don't have it you're gonna be angry. I mean the rest of the food is great too but I love to just get the Greek salad and then the octopus and combine it into a dinner salad.
Kara Bueter
This place was great! Service was quick and attentive! The atmosphere was quaint and comfortable! The food was amazing and would highly recommend!
TVA99
Pelagis Cafe has exceptionally fresh Mediterranean food. We started out with a small portion tzatziki and fresh warm naan bread, which the server brought to us. If you love tzatziki & want a larger portion, order the appetizer size. Our entrees came with our choice of soup or salad. I chose the Greek salad. Yummy! I ordered the Salmon en croute, stuffed with spinach and feta cheese on a bed of rice. It was so good!! We finish our meal with a flan. Cooked to perfection.
Jake Walker
• Wait - 5/5• Customer Service - 5/5• Cleanliness - 5/5• Food - 5/5• Cost - 5/5Great authentic Greek food and very friendly staff. Will happily return.
We love Greek food and have tried many in Naples over 10 years. Pelagos NEVER disappoints. Food is fresh, hot, and delicious. Ribs are so good; fall off the bone tender with excellent rub. Salads are crisp and light. Gyros are just how we like “em with tasty tzatziki. My wife craves their excellent baklava. The staff is super friendly and the owner is awesome.
Big disappointmen!! Friend made reservations for us 10 days ago. even called back to confirm. We all got there and were told there was NO reservation. After standing there for 15 minute, we all walked across the courtyard to Don Tequila, where we were seat immediately, had fabulous friendly service, and wonderful dinners! Good luck to you Pelagos in the off season. You've lost long time year round patrons. We certainly won't be back, and will pass the word about our experience with your restaurant.
We come here a couple times per month. The food is fresh and excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was very good, although we felt a little rushed because we came without reservations. The menu online was very different from the actual prices at the restaurant. Our chicken dinners were $30 each which was a little pricey but that’s Naples!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Place from the outside is unassuming, but literally everything on the inside is amazing. We had the Greek salad, the chicken souvlaki, Kafta kebab and hummus. All ridiculous good. It's relatively healthy so you can't go wrong. The fries not healthy but still delicious. The owner and one waitress were more than helpful and zero complaints with the service. 5/5 stars.
Great people. Great food. Nice atmosphere. Recommend it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favourite Greek restaurant in Naples they have the best lamb shank in town. I think everything on the menu is great.
An awesome family-run restaurant with the most wonderful owners and staff. The food is fresh, authentic and fabulous. This is a regular stop for my husband and I, and their take-out is awesome when we want a quiet night at home. We love this place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome authentic Greek food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Falafel, Hummus, Chicken Gyro
Dinner was excellent. I had the moussaka and tiramiso. If I could give them 6 stars, I would.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good Greek food. Family owned and operated and it feels that way in a good sense
Restaurantji Recommends
If you go here for one thing go for the octopus. Call first. Make sure they have it. Cause if you go and they don't have it you're gonna be angry. I mean the rest of the food is great too but I love to just get the Greek salad and then the octopus and combine it into a dinner salad.
This place was great! Service was quick and attentive! The atmosphere was quaint and comfortable! The food was amazing and would highly recommend!
Pelagis Cafe has exceptionally fresh Mediterranean food. We started out with a small portion tzatziki and fresh warm naan bread, which the server brought to us. If you love tzatziki & want a larger portion, order the appetizer size. Our entrees came with our choice of soup or salad. I chose the Greek salad. Yummy! I ordered the Salmon en croute, stuffed with spinach and feta cheese on a bed of rice. It was so good!! We finish our meal with a flan. Cooked to perfection.
• Wait - 5/5• Customer Service - 5/5• Cleanliness - 5/5• Food - 5/5• Cost - 5/5Great authentic Greek food and very friendly staff. Will happily return.
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Chicken Souvlaki
We love Greek food and have tried many in Naples over 10 years. Pelagos NEVER disappoints. Food is fresh, hot, and delicious. Ribs are so good; fall off the bone tender with excellent rub. Salads are crisp and light. Gyros are just how we like “em with tasty tzatziki. My wife craves their excellent baklava. The staff is super friendly and the owner is awesome.