Best pizza and dessert we've ever had. Not to mention a nice wine list. Can't wait to try the pasta, homemade!!!
Randi S.
After reading all the bad reviews I was nervous to go there but I was tired and it was literally at the end of the street from my Airbnb; I'm so glad I did the wait staff was friendly and attentive there's a beautiful outdoor area and you can play putt putt while you're waiting if you want to, I got pizza it was delicious great crust nice sauce and they forgot the arugula but then gave me a huge bowl to make up for it. I also had a pretty good tiramisu . I would definitely go back
Manny1950
Very good Italian food on Bayshore. Owner , Massimo Miceli, very friendly and welcoming. Arugula salad nice. Pizza margherita terrific and I am a pizza snob from NYC. Cannot wait to go again! Manny
Greg F.
Just don't go! I have driven by this place so many times and finally decided to give it a whirl last night. I thought when I walked in that it looked really cool and that it might just be an awesome little place. Sadly, I was highly disappointed! Of course it was short-handed like all places in Naples due to the extreme and obscene rent increases for workers, but I decided to overlook that and stay focused on the anticipated pizza and breadsticks I ordered. THAT is where the disappointment began and ended. I won't be back! Below find photos of the finger thin complete waste of money breadsticks with the campbells soup tasting runny (VERY RUNNY) marinara. And then was the pizza. Slimy uncooked dough, with square cut Dominoes quality "Italian sausage". Cheese wasn't cooked fully, and honestly it was a LUKEWARM pizza. SERIOUSLY LUKEWARM! I actually got it to go but wanted to do my usual taste test (ala the one bite dude) right there in the restaurant before I left. I was horribly disgusted... in myself... for wasting $46 bucks on crappy thin chewy breadsticks, soupy bland marina, 2 beers, and a lukewarm/cold pizza I ended up choking down a slice and disposing the remainder in my trash can. And trust me, anyone who knows me knows that I don't throw away pizza! I should have returned it but I didn't want to be an inconvenience to the server/owner's Son who was truly busting his butt. Besides, it wouldn't have made any difference and I'll chalk it up to a poor choice on my behalf. Bottom line is that they have a sign outside that says "NOW HIRING... ALL POSITIONS"! I highly suggest that they start with the position of a CHEF with a sense of what quality food is! I only gave it one star because there isn't an option of a half a star. Again... just don't go!
Jesse B.
Excellent little spot. Pasta was great and seemed homemade but we didnt ask. Pizza was really good. Nice big outdoor area. Make sure to call for reservations during "the season".
Nick T.
Authentic, fresh food, great friendly atmosphere and service. Menu has all you need and priced right. Fabio is the real deal! Heading back asap!
Marion M.
Ordered a simple meal tonight. One cheese pizza and a salad at 6:30pm. Was told 35 minutes for pick up. Arrived at 7:05. Spoke with bartender,he said just one minute. He proceeded to go about other tasks, completely ignoring me. After 25 minutes I advised a waitress I'm going to leave without my food. Presto, there was my food. Guess how cold it was when I got home. Food is delicious, wait staff needs improvement
John M.
We went to this restaurant based on the Yelp rating of 4.5 stars. Service was subpar due to the fact that they only had one server for the entire restaurant. Probably due to Covid so I will give them a break. We did not order pizza but instead we all (4) ordered a pasta dish. Sauces were runny and the pasta was simply not good. It was certainly not homemade. I am Italian and I have traveled to Italy many times. I know good Italian food and this was NOT. Maybe our mistake was ordering pasta at a pizza and pasta place. I can't speak for the pizza but the pasta is sub par. I can only assume that the 4.5 rating either related to the pizza or was posted by folks who never had real Italian pasta dishes.
Kristin Z.
Great authentic Sicilian style pizza. The crust was cooked perfectly on both pizzas. Service and location were great. Will definitely be back in the future!
LollysLook
We met friends for dinner before attending the Botanical Gardens Light show. Sicilia has a great menu with pizza, pasta and Italian entrees. Everything was very good. We will be back
Ok, so I love the vibe of this place. The people are the stars of this place. So friendly and the Italian music with the scenes behind the bar set the ambiance of the experience. The food is good! Had the pizza, the meatball sub, the lasagna and the bread is great. Yes, I am a return customer. Eat inside out outside! It's all great!Spaghetti and MeatballsSpeck PizzaLasagnaBruschetta
Ari M.
We were a very large group and they were able to accommodate all 30 of us. Pizza was amazing, all the dishes came out very hot and delicious, and the coffees at the end were a perfect touch. The outdoor area was perfect for the kids to play soccer and mini golf.
Eric H
Service was a bit spotty, two waitpersons arguing about which one was going to serve us. But the food was very enjoyable.
Andreina F.
A wonderful restaurant with delicious food and extremely friendly staff! Had the delicious Norma pizza and tiramisu. Will be back!!
Tabitha C.
ProbBly one of the best authentic Italian restaurants in town! Can't wait to come back.
Best pizza and dessert we've ever had. Not to mention a nice wine list. Can't wait to try the pasta, homemade!!!
After reading all the bad reviews I was nervous to go there but I was tired and it was literally at the end of the street from my Airbnb; I'm so glad I did the wait staff was friendly and attentive there's a beautiful outdoor area and you can play putt putt while you're waiting if you want to, I got pizza it was delicious great crust nice sauce and they forgot the arugula but then gave me a huge bowl to make up for it. I also had a pretty good tiramisu . I would definitely go back
Very good Italian food on Bayshore. Owner , Massimo Miceli, very friendly and welcoming. Arugula salad nice. Pizza margherita terrific and I am a pizza snob from NYC. Cannot wait to go again! Manny
Just don't go! I have driven by this place so many times and finally decided to give it a whirl last night. I thought when I walked in that it looked really cool and that it might just be an awesome little place. Sadly, I was highly disappointed! Of course it was short-handed like all places in Naples due to the extreme and obscene rent increases for workers, but I decided to overlook that and stay focused on the anticipated pizza and breadsticks I ordered. THAT is where the disappointment began and ended. I won't be back! Below find photos of the finger thin complete waste of money breadsticks with the campbells soup tasting runny (VERY RUNNY) marinara. And then was the pizza. Slimy uncooked dough, with square cut Dominoes quality "Italian sausage". Cheese wasn't cooked fully, and honestly it was a LUKEWARM pizza. SERIOUSLY LUKEWARM! I actually got it to go but wanted to do my usual taste test (ala the one bite dude) right there in the restaurant before I left. I was horribly disgusted... in myself... for wasting $46 bucks on crappy thin chewy breadsticks, soupy bland marina, 2 beers, and a lukewarm/cold pizza I ended up choking down a slice and disposing the remainder in my trash can. And trust me, anyone who knows me knows that I don't throw away pizza! I should have returned it but I didn't want to be an inconvenience to the server/owner's Son who was truly busting his butt. Besides, it wouldn't have made any difference and I'll chalk it up to a poor choice on my behalf. Bottom line is that they have a sign outside that says "NOW HIRING... ALL POSITIONS"! I highly suggest that they start with the position of a CHEF with a sense of what quality food is! I only gave it one star because there isn't an option of a half a star. Again... just don't go!
Excellent little spot. Pasta was great and seemed homemade but we didnt ask. Pizza was really good. Nice big outdoor area. Make sure to call for reservations during "the season".
Authentic, fresh food, great friendly atmosphere and service. Menu has all you need and priced right. Fabio is the real deal! Heading back asap!
Ordered a simple meal tonight. One cheese pizza and a salad at 6:30pm. Was told 35 minutes for pick up. Arrived at 7:05. Spoke with bartender,he said just one minute. He proceeded to go about other tasks, completely ignoring me. After 25 minutes I advised a waitress I'm going to leave without my food. Presto, there was my food. Guess how cold it was when I got home. Food is delicious, wait staff needs improvement
We went to this restaurant based on the Yelp rating of 4.5 stars. Service was subpar due to the fact that they only had one server for the entire restaurant. Probably due to Covid so I will give them a break. We did not order pizza but instead we all (4) ordered a pasta dish. Sauces were runny and the pasta was simply not good. It was certainly not homemade. I am Italian and I have traveled to Italy many times. I know good Italian food and this was NOT. Maybe our mistake was ordering pasta at a pizza and pasta place. I can't speak for the pizza but the pasta is sub par. I can only assume that the 4.5 rating either related to the pizza or was posted by folks who never had real Italian pasta dishes.
Great authentic Sicilian style pizza. The crust was cooked perfectly on both pizzas. Service and location were great. Will definitely be back in the future!
We met friends for dinner before attending the Botanical Gardens Light show. Sicilia has a great menu with pizza, pasta and Italian entrees. Everything was very good. We will be back
Restaurantji Recommends
Ok, so I love the vibe of this place. The people are the stars of this place. So friendly and the Italian music with the scenes behind the bar set the ambiance of the experience. The food is good! Had the pizza, the meatball sub, the lasagna and the bread is great. Yes, I am a return customer. Eat inside out outside! It's all great!Spaghetti and MeatballsSpeck PizzaLasagnaBruschetta
We were a very large group and they were able to accommodate all 30 of us. Pizza was amazing, all the dishes came out very hot and delicious, and the coffees at the end were a perfect touch. The outdoor area was perfect for the kids to play soccer and mini golf.
Service was a bit spotty, two waitpersons arguing about which one was going to serve us. But the food was very enjoyable.
A wonderful restaurant with delicious food and extremely friendly staff! Had the delicious Norma pizza and tiramisu. Will be back!!
ProbBly one of the best authentic Italian restaurants in town! Can't wait to come back.