We always loved Two Fillets but when they closed it and changed it to Caiman Cantina we thought we would give it a chance. Well we did and we both agreed we will not do it again as it doesn't fit our taste buds and expectations for the price. The pros are the staff was very attentive. You could tell the waiter was somewhat new but he tried and was very attentive. The chip salsa had a very unique smoky taste and was good. We thought it would be a great experience but then it went downhill. The cons were the chips tasted somewhat stale. The $12 Queso Fundido barely covered the bottom of the dish in a very, very thin layer and was like stringy glue as it would not separate without a knife. The flour tortillas had a lot of either oil or butter on them that got all over your fingers as you could see the shine even in the dim lightening. For the price, it is not worth it. My husband's #31 Enmoladas enchiladas were burnt and very dry. He loves mole sauce, but not here. We both agreed the rice was horrible as they use maybe a broth that created a weird taste and it was very sticky and cool. Both meals were barely warm yet they claimed the plates were hot but they were not. We were the only people there at the time so we would have expected hot food. I replaced on #18 Burrito En-Diablado the chipotle fire sauce with a creamy cheese sauce. It reminded me of a southern thick gravy over southern biscuits. It was thick and heavy and overpowered the pork and supposed grilled pineapple that you could barely taste. The insides were lukewarm, if that. My husband had really horrible stomach gas for 9 hours that kept him up. This was our date night to get away from things and it was not a good experience and sadly we will not be back. We only ate about 1/4 of our meals. It was a waste of our gift card promotion dollars that we had bought when Two Fillets existed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Roddy S
Food came out luke-warm. Was tasty, but not hot. Our server was terrible, took him over 20 mins to figure out checks for a table of 6. Beware of the bottles they serve salsa in. It sprayed out all over two people at our table. I know the place is new, but definitely won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Robert Statile
Waitress was awful and seemed irritated when she finally showed up twenty minutes later.After we had been sitting with no drinks.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
MARIA PAULA LOMBANA CORTES
Food is really good, very flavorful, would definitely go back for the quesibirria, the fajitas were good.
Good Mexican music as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Rebecca Beutel
Don’t waste your time going to the new Mexican restaurant. They pained a few old walls red and displayed some fake flowers. Everything is worn and old. Food, drinks, margs, food, salsa, etc suck. It’s dog food. Taco Bell is better and this is no exaggeration. I give it 6 months. I remember when this place was Randy’s and fumigated for roaches.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Greg
My wife and I went there for our anniversary and were not disappointed. Everything was excellent. Would definitely return.
Tom
The food was excellent. Great selection and fresh fish. Our server was very attentive and knowledgeable. The chef was veery accommodating. I requested a slight modification to a menu item and the chef made the changes for me. We have eaten here many times and have never been disappointed. Always a "five" star rating!!!
Mary Lou
I had ordered the Mahi mahi and it was very dry. I didn't care for the mush that it was served with either. My husband had the fillet which he liked. We shared some apple dessert which was just ok. I wouldn't order it again.
Brent
We've been coming to Naples for about two years and have passed by Two Fillets several times and commented we should stop in. Now I regret waiting so long! The atmosphere was nice and quiet, the food was excellent, the portions were perfectly sized, and the prices were incredibly reasonable. This is a wonderful spot for a meal of any occasion.
The service and food was perfect. Recently, it was a couples/friends night out and we all enjoyed the summer celebration menu. We all had various first course choices but I enjoyed the Mussels Sorrento and the Tripletail Two Fillets entree. Others enjoyed the Parmesan crusted flounder and the Tropical Mahi dishes. We also enjoyed a bottle of wine, cocktails, and dessert. The key lime pie and carrot cake were wonderful. It was the perfect experience for us all. We will return to try other dishes throughout the year.
Jody
From the minute we walked in the door with our party of 5 the staff was 5* Our server James was a true professional as was the manager Greg. It is one of our favorite restaurants in Naples!
Lorraine Altamura
Ambiance was lovely! Instrumental Music was very relaxing. James, our waiter was excellent: professional, well informed, & friendly. The calamari was the best ever, although VERY DIFFERENT! Triple tail fish was delicious! Their FF are 5 star! Filet Mignon - perfect & flavorful! We also enjoyed a Caesar’s salad, clam chowder, & key lime pie… all good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
F S
Great food Great service Great price Can’t ask for more
Excellent customer service 👏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We always loved Two Fillets but when they closed it and changed it to Caiman Cantina we thought we would give it a chance. Well we did and we both agreed we will not do it again as it doesn't fit our taste buds and expectations for the price. The pros are the staff was very attentive. You could tell the waiter was somewhat new but he tried and was very attentive. The chip salsa had a very unique smoky taste and was good. We thought it would be a great experience but then it went downhill. The cons were the chips tasted somewhat stale. The $12 Queso Fundido barely covered the bottom of the dish in a very, very thin layer and was like stringy glue as it would not separate without a knife. The flour tortillas had a lot of either oil or butter on them that got all over your fingers as you could see the shine even in the dim lightening. For the price, it is not worth it. My husband's #31 Enmoladas enchiladas were burnt and very dry. He loves mole sauce, but not here. We both agreed the rice was horrible as they use maybe a broth that created a weird taste and it was very sticky and cool. Both meals were barely warm yet they claimed the plates were hot but they were not. We were the only people there at the time so we would have expected hot food. I replaced on #18 Burrito En-Diablado the chipotle fire sauce with a creamy cheese sauce. It reminded me of a southern thick gravy over southern biscuits. It was thick and heavy and overpowered the pork and supposed grilled pineapple that you could barely taste. The insides were lukewarm, if that. My husband had really horrible stomach gas for 9 hours that kept him up. This was our date night to get away from things and it was not a good experience and sadly we will not be back. We only ate about 1/4 of our meals. It was a waste of our gift card promotion dollars that we had bought when Two Fillets existed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Food came out luke-warm. Was tasty, but not hot. Our server was terrible, took him over 20 mins to figure out checks for a table of 6. Beware of the bottles they serve salsa in. It sprayed out all over two people at our table. I know the place is new, but definitely won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Waitress was awful and seemed irritated when she finally showed up twenty minutes later.After we had been sitting with no drinks.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Food is really good, very flavorful, would definitely go back for the quesibirria, the fajitas were good.
Good Mexican music as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Don’t waste your time going to the new Mexican restaurant. They pained a few old walls red and displayed some fake flowers. Everything is worn and old. Food, drinks, margs, food, salsa, etc suck. It’s dog food. Taco Bell is better and this is no exaggeration. I give it 6 months. I remember when this place was Randy’s and fumigated for roaches.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
My wife and I went there for our anniversary and were not disappointed. Everything was excellent. Would definitely return.
The food was excellent. Great selection and fresh fish. Our server was very attentive and knowledgeable. The chef was veery accommodating. I requested a slight modification to a menu item and the chef made the changes for me. We have eaten here many times and have never been disappointed. Always a "five" star rating!!!
I had ordered the Mahi mahi and it was very dry. I didn't care for the mush that it was served with either. My husband had the fillet which he liked. We shared some apple dessert which was just ok. I wouldn't order it again.
We've been coming to Naples for about two years and have passed by Two Fillets several times and commented we should stop in. Now I regret waiting so long! The atmosphere was nice and quiet, the food was excellent, the portions were perfectly sized, and the prices were incredibly reasonable. This is a wonderful spot for a meal of any occasion.
Restaurantji Recommends
The service and food was perfect. Recently, it was a couples/friends night out and we all enjoyed the summer celebration menu. We all had various first course choices but I enjoyed the Mussels Sorrento and the Tripletail Two Fillets entree. Others enjoyed the Parmesan crusted flounder and the Tropical Mahi dishes. We also enjoyed a bottle of wine, cocktails, and dessert. The key lime pie and carrot cake were wonderful. It was the perfect experience for us all. We will return to try other dishes throughout the year.
From the minute we walked in the door with our party of 5 the staff was 5* Our server James was a true professional as was the manager Greg. It is one of our favorite restaurants in Naples!
Ambiance was lovely! Instrumental Music was very relaxing. James, our waiter was excellent: professional, well informed, & friendly. The calamari was the best ever, although VERY DIFFERENT! Triple tail fish was delicious! Their FF are 5 star! Filet Mignon - perfect & flavorful! We also enjoyed a Caesar’s salad, clam chowder, & key lime pie… all good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food
Great service
Great price
Can’t ask for more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very tasty and pretty environment. Friendly staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...