Great food. Really sorry to see them leave the area.
Marty H.
This place is definitely a good find in the area so many pizzas around here have crust that taste like cardboard this Krusteaz light buttery and Good. I wanted pizza but I didn't want to much so I got a baby pizza with onions ham and pineapple I was delicious highly recommended the crust is outstanding.
Susan Sullivan
Excellent and you must try the lasagna pizza! We love all the food and wide diverse menu they offer the Italian food is great here or order the burger or wings still great but a must really is the lasagna pizza.
Daniel Yingling
A real cracker crumb pizza which tastes, folds and is similar to New York and Philly but the crust is not the same. If you eat the crust only, it tastes like a dry cracker without salt. With sauce, cheese and topings, it's good Pizza combined and crispy crust.
Cesar Mora
Love this place, delicious food!!! Pasta and subs are great, large portions at a reasonable price. The staff is very friendly.
Charlie Nicinski
Great place to eat. Everything was great
Drega Dezorla
Very friendly people and great pizza you can not beat.
Brittney Azbell
Amazing food and friendly service!
Amy Crusoe
I had the chicken with rice and pigeon peas, my boyfriend and son had the gyro and sausage roll, everything was excellent! Will be back, nice friendly staff too. Thanks for some really tasty food!
Sue M.
It's definitely not #1 and it's far from being NY style. It is a very small space in a non-descript old small shopping strip that can be a bit sketchy. The small shopping strip is only about 1/3 occupied. The pizzeria has maybe 6 plastic back tables and is mostly used by customers that want to eat their slice sitting down. There is a server that works BOH who periodically comes out to see if anyone want to place an order. On this occasion I had several questions but she couldn't answer one of them. So I ordered a plain calzone and an ice water and then the problems began. I was brought a bottled water and told they had no glasses for water. My calzone was the smallest I had ever seen and the mozzarella and ricotta was not blended. The manager had briefly come out from the register to talk to patrons but he ignored me even though I waved him over. Halfway through my meal I decide to take a quick break so I covered my food with a napkin, left my cell on the table and took my purse. I stood in front on the business in front on their window for a couple minutes. Returning I started eating the calzone but then noticed my cell was gone. I looked on the booth, double checked my purse and t was gone!!! I looked up and getting ready to shout out my phone was stolen when I hear the manager yell "I have your phone" and holds it up. He then yelled "I thought you left"! What? I said if I had left he would of cleared the table and he knew I stepped out in front of his business for a minute. Does he think I'm going to dine & dash with 1/2 my food there, my phone and not yet even receive the bill? This was done intentionally to take a phone! I had to get up and grab it from him and I couldn't finish quick enough to get out of there! Did I mention my calzone was served on a paper plate with plastic utensils? So was other people's. It's clear they're only set up for take out pizza and that's it. I never did receive a bill and had to go to the register where the manager rang up my bill but only gave me the total. He debited my card but after signing it had to ask for an itemized receipt b/c as an after thought it seemed too high. Sure enough I was not only charged for the free water but was over charged for the calzone. I was charged $5.95 but the large light up menu board said $5.25. I pointed out the $5.25 price but he said it was based on the menu price which was $5.95 and refused to credit me the difference!! I didn't even get to the charge for the water and just walked right out and told everyone! It's obvious with the unethical business practices the manager displayed it's not the first time he's done this and it will continue to happen so this pizza joint is not going to last long. Theft of any kind (my phone & my $) is a crime! Current health inspection - 3 Basic & 1 High Priority violation.
I love this place! The food is delicious the service is top notch, and reasonably priced. The employees are friendly and very helpful.
Walter Shuler
Prompt, friendly service and excellent pizza.
Jared B.
We placed a $70 pizza order (6 pies) for delivery at 7pm and they said it would be 45 minutes to an hour. It finally arrived 2 hours and 2 calls back to restaurant later at 9pm!!! The owner actually delivered the pizza and readily admits they don't have delivery scheduling figured out. He was offering many excuses for why our order was intentionally back-burnered and he was unapologetic and not at all caring about our inconvenience and his establishment's poor service. We have been regular customers since they've opened but this extremely poor service and their unwillingness to make it right (discount or refund) definitely hurts their reputation to me. It's clear that customer satisfaction is not their main priority, especially if it's a delivery customer.
Naida Roman
Ordered Greek salad, deluxe cheeseburger, sausage peppers & cheese roll & small pizza with sweet sausage. All the above items were excellent, delivery time was quick delivery person was very professional I asked he step in and place my items on the kitchen table because their were several items. He did so very politically my food was nice & hot food was delivered in a heat storage bag. I would confidently order any food items from #1 New York Pizza. Signed Native New Yorker
Jamie Armstrong
This has been one of the best places uve had for pizza in Florida. Fresh ingredients. Super friendly staff, super big portions. We had the two slice lunch special and a stromboli. Was enough for 3 people and we were FULL.
Great food. Really sorry to see them leave the area.
This place is definitely a good find in the area so many pizzas around here have crust that taste like cardboard this Krusteaz light buttery and Good. I wanted pizza but I didn't want to much so I got a baby pizza with onions ham and pineapple I was delicious highly recommended the crust is outstanding.
Excellent and you must try the lasagna pizza! We love all the food and wide diverse menu they offer the Italian food is great here or order the burger or wings still great but a must really is the lasagna pizza.
A real cracker crumb pizza which tastes, folds and is similar to New York and Philly but the crust is not the same. If you eat the crust only, it tastes like a dry cracker without salt. With sauce, cheese and topings, it's good Pizza combined and crispy crust.
Love this place, delicious food!!! Pasta and subs are great, large portions at a reasonable price. The staff is very friendly.
Great place to eat. Everything was great
Very friendly people and great pizza you can not beat.
Amazing food and friendly service!
I had the chicken with rice and pigeon peas, my boyfriend and son had the gyro and sausage roll, everything was excellent! Will be back, nice friendly staff too. Thanks for some really tasty food!
It's definitely not #1 and it's far from being NY style. It is a very small space in a non-descript old small shopping strip that can be a bit sketchy. The small shopping strip is only about 1/3 occupied. The pizzeria has maybe 6 plastic back tables and is mostly used by customers that want to eat their slice sitting down. There is a server that works BOH who periodically comes out to see if anyone want to place an order. On this occasion I had several questions but she couldn't answer one of them. So I ordered a plain calzone and an ice water and then the problems began. I was brought a bottled water and told they had no glasses for water. My calzone was the smallest I had ever seen and the mozzarella and ricotta was not blended. The manager had briefly come out from the register to talk to patrons but he ignored me even though I waved him over. Halfway through my meal I decide to take a quick break so I covered my food with a napkin, left my cell on the table and took my purse. I stood in front on the business in front on their window for a couple minutes. Returning I started eating the calzone but then noticed my cell was gone. I looked on the booth, double checked my purse and t was gone!!! I looked up and getting ready to shout out my phone was stolen when I hear the manager yell "I have your phone" and holds it up. He then yelled "I thought you left"! What? I said if I had left he would of cleared the table and he knew I stepped out in front of his business for a minute. Does he think I'm going to dine & dash with 1/2 my food there, my phone and not yet even receive the bill? This was done intentionally to take a phone! I had to get up and grab it from him and I couldn't finish quick enough to get out of there! Did I mention my calzone was served on a paper plate with plastic utensils? So was other people's. It's clear they're only set up for take out pizza and that's it. I never did receive a bill and had to go to the register where the manager rang up my bill but only gave me the total. He debited my card but after signing it had to ask for an itemized receipt b/c as an after thought it seemed too high. Sure enough I was not only charged for the free water but was over charged for the calzone. I was charged $5.95 but the large light up menu board said $5.25. I pointed out the $5.25 price but he said it was based on the menu price which was $5.95 and refused to credit me the difference!! I didn't even get to the charge for the water and just walked right out and told everyone! It's obvious with the unethical business practices the manager displayed it's not the first time he's done this and it will continue to happen so this pizza joint is not going to last long. Theft of any kind (my phone & my $) is a crime! Current health inspection - 3 Basic & 1 High Priority violation.
Restaurantji Recommends
I love this place! The food is delicious the service is top notch, and reasonably priced. The employees are friendly and very helpful.
Prompt, friendly service and excellent pizza.
We placed a $70 pizza order (6 pies) for delivery at 7pm and they said it would be 45 minutes to an hour. It finally arrived 2 hours and 2 calls back to restaurant later at 9pm!!! The owner actually delivered the pizza and readily admits they don't have delivery scheduling figured out. He was offering many excuses for why our order was intentionally back-burnered and he was unapologetic and not at all caring about our inconvenience and his establishment's poor service. We have been regular customers since they've opened but this extremely poor service and their unwillingness to make it right (discount or refund) definitely hurts their reputation to me. It's clear that customer satisfaction is not their main priority, especially if it's a delivery customer.
Ordered Greek salad, deluxe cheeseburger, sausage peppers & cheese roll & small pizza with sweet sausage. All the above items were excellent, delivery time was quick delivery person was very professional I asked he step in and place my items on the kitchen table because their were several items. He did so very politically my food was nice & hot food was delivered in a heat storage bag. I would confidently order any food items from #1 New York Pizza. Signed Native New Yorker
This has been one of the best places uve had for pizza in Florida. Fresh ingredients. Super friendly staff, super big portions. We had the two slice lunch special and a stromboli. Was enough for 3 people and we were FULL.