Five Star Pizza
$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings, Pet Friendly Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Five Star Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Five Star Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Five Star Pizza
Pizza is solid depending on what toppings you get. It's definitely tastier than a lot of local pizza joints. If you ever get cheese pizza, I would say double up the cheese. Also, I appreciate the people that work there. I've only had one bad experience since ordering pizza there. Everybody is super cool and I love the vibes. If you're looking for a quick bite on a Friday or Saturday night this is the place to hit 🎯
Harvey greeted me while making a pizza great customer service truly an asset to your company.
We recently relocated to this area, and live in a remote rural area. My family wanted pizza so while I was in Orange Park, I asked around. Several people recommended Five Star Pizza. I stopped in and placed an order in person. Then I went and sat in my car to send a text message. Lo and behold, it was just a few minutes later that an employee stepped outside with my two pizzas! They're fast! The family loved their meat lovers pizza. I'm a vegetarian and got a custom pizza just...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 12AM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 12AM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 12AM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 12AM |
| Friday | 10AM - 1AM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 1AM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 12AM |
Five Star Pizza is a local pizza restaurant known for its hot, fresh, and authentic New York-style slices. The menu offers a variety of classic toppings, including the popular philly and bacon cheeseburger options. Customers appreciate that the restaurant is accommodating for large parties, often hosting orders of 12 or more pizzas on short notice without hassle. The food is consistent, and the employees are friendly and personable. The restaurant is especially loved for its excellent sauce, delicious Deluxe Pizza, and great dipping sauces like Marina and Garlic Butter made in store. Many customers find the service helpful and honest when ordering, with no pressure to upsell. The pizza is cooked to perfection, with a crispy crust and well-balanced sauce and toppings. However, some recent changes, such as a new website that doesn't allow half-and-half pizzas and concerns about reduced cheese and quality, have disappointed some longtime customers. Despite these issues, the restaurant remains a favorite for many who enjoy its delicious and satisfying pizza experience.