NYC Meatballs and Pizzeria
1075 Oakleaf Plantation Pkwy STE 104, Orange Park
(904) 375-0289
Customers' Favorites
12 - Medium Chicken Bacon Ranch
12 - Medium Buffalo Chicken
16 - Large Chicken Alfredo
16 - Large Buffalo Chicken
16 - Large Cheese Pizza
Famous NYC Garlic Knots
16 - Large Meatlovers
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Spicy Garlic Wings
12 - Medium Supreme
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I ordered from there yesterday for the first time ever. I placed an order for pickup. The food was ready before the given time and i was greeted and taken care of within seconds of walking into a full restaurant. They insisted on holding the door open for me as i left as well. 10/10 service. As well as the best pizza i’ve had here. 10/10 food
Tonight we came in and got three 12 inch pizzas cheese sticks and a rich ball
The rich ball was fried in dirty oil and covered in sauce and cheese ( not that great )
One Philly
One cheese
One white and arugula
The pizza wasn’t bad the dough was a little thick but it was still ok ,
The rich ball was fried in dirty oil and covered in sauce and cheese ( not that great )
One Philly
One cheese
One white and arugula
The pizza wasn’t bad the dough was a little thick but it was still ok ,
Meatball sub was good, for our taste could have used either extra sauce or a side of extra sauce. Sweet tea was fine. Service friendly. The sub took a while to be served even though it was not peak lunch or dinner and only a few tables. Seemed to be a decent selection of on tap beers.
You May Also Like
Akaya Grill & Sushi Restaurant - 1075 Oakleaf Plantation Pkwy
![]()
Sushi, Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegetarian
McDonald's - 821 Canaveral Trce
![]()
Fast Food, Coffee & Tea, Burgers
Tough Guys Cookies and Sweets - 518 Hollyberry Ln Suite 104
![]()
Caterers, Bakery