I Love NY Pizza & Subs

6602 Old Winter Garden Rd, Orlando
(407) 293-7020

Recent Reviews

Nohemi Ramos

My boss loves this pizza place, and I see why. Service is great. The gentleman at the front taking orders and cooking are all super nice. The pizza is delicious and super fresh. I'm definitely not disappointed in that aspect. But.....what I didn't like was the number of teenagers allowed in the establishment that are not consuming anything and just sitting around taking up seats, being rude and disrespectful amongst themselves and with customers! The owners need to control that crowd in their establishment, or it's gonna run off their clientele.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Marinara Sauce, Garlic Knots

Wade

Amazing pizza, friendly staff, great

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Five Cheese Pizza

Jaylin Adorno

Great food. Quick

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, 10 Wings

Gregory S.

Great pizza!! True NY style pizza. Super quick and a great value too! We ordered Philly cheesesteak pizza

Alex Bryson

I have tried every pizza place in my area, and I do mean every place, not commercial, and hands down the best. Hot subs are good.The owner seems grumpy but I can work with that, since he does not come with the food.I myself am not a big pizza eater but I will get down on pizza from this place.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Steak and Cheese Sub, Five Cheese Pizza, Garlic Knots

john70024

Authentic style NY Pizza cooked to order while you wait or you can call and order it your choice foods excellent give them a try I guarantee you want regret it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Calzone, Steak and Cheese Sub, Buffalo Wings and Fries Lunch Special, Margarita Pizza, Lasagna Pizza, Five Cheese Pizza, Cheese Burger Deluxe with Fries, Marinara Sauce, Greek Gyro, One Slice of Cheese One Pepperoni Pizza, Roma Spinach Pizza, Steak, Beef, Veggi Stromboli, Garlic Knots, Salad, Garlic Bread, Greek Salad, 10 Wings, Large Cannoli

Brenda Vazquez

Place has great customer service . Food is excellent for the price..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calzone, Cheese Pizza, Steak

Andrew Kercher

Phenomenal pizza subs all of it pretty good eat there as much as I

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Reagan Stallbaum

Really good food and service. Great “hole in the wall”

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calzone

Jordan Parchment

Upon arrival, the cashier gives off a vibe that he'd rather be anywhere else but there. But, its also the first pizza place I've been to that actually brings you your pizza. The pizza was really good, but the wings were subpar. Wings are decent size but dry. Buffalo sauce tastes like flavored vinegar and not spicy at all. The service was redeemed by the rest of the staff I'll admit. I can't say I'll be happy to be a frequent customer, but I've had worse service and food from the well-known chain pizza restaurants.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Darlene M.

Stopped by this location while short on time and in the area. The shop is nothing fancy just a regular pizza shop. There is plenty of space to sit and eat. They have pretty big menu offering different items from pizza to fries to gyros. The slices were average on taste they were thin and crispy not too saucy or greasy. One thing I wouldn't do again is get the fountain drink there's no ice in the machine they give you ice upfront and then the soda is flat as can be. Also with the specials you have a choice of water or the fountain drink. Overall I would stop in again if I'm in the area but definitely wouldn't go out my way to come back.

Will G.

Love this lil pizza joint! The owner can be a little brash but I think it's just the authentic NY coming out! We ordered a cheesesteak Stromboli ($17.99 for large ) and a sausage and cheese Stromboli ($10.99 for small) The cheesesteak never disappoints!! The salads however leave some to be desired! They also make hot & cold subs, wings, beef patties , and Italian entrees.

Kathryn

The pizza is not cooked in a traditional oven. It’s cooked on a screen (you could see the screen pattern indentation on the bottom of the crust) which would NEVER happen in a real NY pizzeria. Not cooking the pizza in a pizza oven makes the crust soft and, let’s face it, NY pizza is all about the crust. NY pizza this is not.However, the sauce was very good and there was a generous amount cheese.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Melissa Squier

We love the pizza here. The best pizza in Orlando. Makes me feel like I'm in NYPrices are awesomeParking: Large lot in a strip centerKid-friendliness: TV for entertaining young children. Glass casing so children can see the food being made, flipping pizzas

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calzone, Steak & Cheese, And Meatballs, One Slice of Cheese One Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread

Toni Lewis

Their food has always been so good and I've never had a bad

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More