Liberty Tree Tavern

everything here was incredible. they have a fully vegan menu and all staff members are super helpful. the impossible meatloaf with mashed potatos was delicious Updated from previous review on 2026-02-15

Love this place! Excellent food. It feels like Thanksgiving dinner when you eat here. They have my favorite dessert in all the parks. Oh and it's all you care to eat family style.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

On Dec 30th, 2025 we had dinner at the Liberty Tree Tavern. I have a plethora of eating restrictions and was embarrassed that they were going to send the chef out to discuss my dining options. Chef Andrew did an amazing job! He took the time to create a meal that was not only delicious, but also made me feel included. Thank you Chef Andrew!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

good if you want thanksgiving food

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Oooey Gooey Toffee Cake, Macaroni and Cheese, Bread Roll, Seasonal Sorbet with Berries, Ooey Gooey Cake

We checked in over an hour and a half ago and we still havent even been served the main course. Disney costs a fortune, and this restaurant costs a lot on top of that. It should not end up also taking up half of your day. This is ridiculous.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

We made a reservation here without knowing it was a set menu with only one appetizer, entre, and desert option for everyone. The price seemed crazy for food I couldn’t even pick and I was super disappointed… but when the food came ???? It’s all you can eat so it PLENTY, and the food was SO GOOD ??? So yea I completely change my mind, best food in the park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very delicious but heavy food. Great service. This place is better for winter trips is my take. It’s hard bc this restaurant deserves a lot of time and praise but being in the middle of magic kingdom I’m sure it gets overshadowed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We loved this place!! They only serve Thanksgiving food. Family style. Basically all you can eat. The salad was amazing.

We were a party of 6 and were seated within 10 mins.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place has delicious food. We enjoyed everything very much. It is pricy but includes salad, bread, several meats and sides (all you can eat) plus dessert and soft drinks. We got a late lunch and it held us over for the rest of the day. The bathrooms outside are better than the one in the restaurant. Also our server wasn’t super enthusiastic or attentive as you may expect at a sit down Disney restaurant. I would definitely go back though.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Bruce was a great server, very helpful and attentive. Other than that the food was amazing definitely recommend. Ericka and Marilyn were really nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very disappointing experience compounded by inept customer service- this is how businesses fail and lose long term customers.

We had a confirmed reservation at Liberty Tree Tavern that was made months in advance for Christmas Day. This was not a casual walk-up or a last-minute plan. This was a holiday reservation at one of Disney’s signature dining locations, planned well ahead of time and treated seriously on our end.

When we arrived, the main entrance area was completely blocked by a parade route. There was no alternate access provided, no cast member directing guests to another entrance, and no communication from the restaurant or the park about how reservation holders were supposed to enter. We stood there, along with other confused guests, for more than 20 minutes. It was physically impossible to reach the host stand.

By the time we were finally able to get through, we were told our reservation had been canceled and that the restaurant was no longer willing to seat us. No grace period. No acknowledgment that Disney’s own parade logistics caused the delay. Just a flat denial of service.

We escalated immediately. First to the on-site manager. Then to Guest Services. Every single person involved gave the same hollow response: “Sorry, there’s nothing we can do.” On Christmas Day. After Disney itself prevented us from accessing the restaurant. After months of planning.

What makes this worse is not just the mistake, but the complete absence of accountability or problem solving. Disney is famous for service recovery. Or at least it used to be. This experience showed the opposite. No attempt to honor the reservation. No alternative seating. No compensation. No proactive solution. Just a shrug and a script.
This was not a weather issue. This was not guest error. This was an internal coordination failure between entertainment operations and dining, followed by a management failure to correct it.

Liberty Tree Tavern may have a good menu, but none of that matters when operational incompetence and rigid policy override basic common sense and customer care. Dropping a Christmas Day reservation because guests were blocked by a Disney parade is unacceptable at any level, but especially for a company that prides itself on “magic.”

Disney needs to see this and respond. Not with another apology, but with an explanation of how a paid, confirmed reservation can be invalidated due to Disney-created access issues, and why managers are empowered to do nothing when that happens. If this is now the standard, guests deserve to know before trusting Disney with important family moments and holidays.

This experience damaged our trust in Disney dining and, frankly, in Disney guest services as a whole. One star, and that is being generous.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

This used to be my favorite restaurant in Magic Kingdom, times are changing and so is the quality of food here. Turkey and stuffing all year even in hot humid Florida still good flavors , but the beef is just shredded watery mush , and the house made Mac and cheese is water logged too. I like the Colonial style setting but servers are out numbered by guests and don't even get orders right even though it is pre fixed

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Delicious family style grub when you are tired of fried, baked, sugar treats.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

All you ca eat buffet, how about you can eat forever

Having spent 3 days at Disney, this has to be the worse resturant experience we've had. We are a party of 6 who had reserved a table and when we arrived, were promptly taken to a table and introduced to our server, Antonio. This is where the good experience ground to a halt. Antonio took our drinks order and left us with ONE menu to look over. On his return he asked if we had made our choice, which to be honest wasn't difficult given there was only one item to chose from, and an extremely limited menu to say the least. Our appetiser arrived consisting of lettuce scattered with grated cheese and covered with a vinegarette, plus a basket of bread rolls. 6 plates were left stacked on our table along with cutlery, which we (supposedly) had to distribute. Eventually our soft and coffee drinks arrived. Later our main course arrived consisting of turkey and ham (6 pieces of each), beans, mash potato, stuffing and shredded beef, plus a jug of gravy. The portion control is very strict and was ridiculously small for a party of 6, who are not exactly big eaters. Our appetiser plates were not cleared, but instead used for our main course as was the cutlery, no clean having been offered by Antonio our server. The food itself was tepid and, at no time were our drinks refreshed. Our desert was ordered and of the 6 only 4 arrived and we had to remind Antonio of the other 2, which then took a while to arrive. For us this was a get them in and quickly out resturant. An 18% surcharge was added to our final bill due to being a party of 6, this being a tip. Antonio surprisingly expected a further tip eventhough his service was poor, out of sync, plus the food was mediocre. I would definitely not recommend this resrurant. Spend your hard earned cash elsewhere and get better professional service and quality food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1