My wife and I stopped in for a quick bite to eat. We have not been to this location, but had been to others in the past and always loved their pizza. This location is a little different, you order at what appears to be a host/hostess stand, and then you take a seat. Your food is delivered to the table once it is ready. We ordered some boneless wings tossed in buffalo sauce and a pizza. The wings were delivered pretty quickly. We jumped in and gave them a try. I thought they were a little hard and not that good. After looking at them and how dark they were, I decided to take them to someone at the counter. They offered to re-make them. The new batch came out looking much better and tasted so much better. We appreciate how quickly they fixed the issue. For our pizza, we ordered the Brooklyn Buffalo Chicken Pie. We have has this pie so many times and will continue to get it. It is so good and just has the flavors we love. They made the pie exactly as we remember it and we were so happy. If we find ourselves in the area, we would for sure stop back in.
John-Paul C.
I love the fact that I can order slices of pizza here, unlike when I have to order full pies from the national/international chains. I'm also from NYC, so being able to consume pizza like back home is such an awesome experience. I've even went as far as bring back a slice from Ray's pizza in NYC and compare it to the NYPD slice and it was gang-busters! No difference! Everyone employed at this location is friendly, efficient, and on top of things; New Yorkers for sure! I like how their menu items are named after NYC places/references and the decor only complements such cool references. I have yet to compare the Junior's cheesecake slice to an actual Junior's cheesecake slice, but every time I fly back to Orlando from NYC LGA airport, I always bring back a chocolate mousse cheesecake, so a fair comparison has yet to take place. I'll follow up once I make another round trip from visiting family and friends.
April W.
I am a big fan of their location on International Drive but when visiting Disney we needed something closer south. We were craving NYPD Pizza and decided to try this location. Unfortunately it is nothing like the other location. For one it's a lot smaller. If you are a party larger than 4, you are gonna have a seating problem. There is only one table available for parties larger than 4. Secondly, unlike what I assume is their sister location (and probably the original) which offers full service, this location has an odd setup. You stand in line to order with the hostess. Then serve yourself your drinks while you wait for your order. If you are dining in, your pizza and any special condiments are brought to your table, but that would be the extent of your service. The pizza is delicious, although missing something compared to the International Drive location. I think I it might be the other location's pie is slightly crispier, and I prefer it. The biggest issue you may have to keep in mind when coming here is the size of your party. Not large party friendly. But other than that, it's ok overall. Just a subpar experience compared to their other location.
Jennifer Andrea Molero Silva
Yesterday we ate with my friends from church and it was a great experience, all the workers were very kind, especially Daniela, such an attentive and kind girl, she helped us choose our dishes and we were all pleased, thank you for your attention.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CRISALIDA BEATRIZ FUENTES
We arrived by chance and we had the best impressions, good service, excellent food and variety of exquisite dishes.
Jonathan Dejesus
Pizza n wings are the best in the state of FL period
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie, Chicken Wings
Chino S.
Good food and good atmosphere. Prices are fair and service is outstanding. Only thing they need to do is to expand their restaurant for more clientele. I think they would do a lot better for them but other than that it's a fantastic place to go.
Jonathan Sebastian
Best pizza in Hunters Creek!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Christopher Bydlik
Sisters Allie and Lauren have incredible customer service personalities and are always greeting you with a smile. Mary(family friend), is always hustling and providing over the top hospitality.Amazing pizza dough and crust. Fresh ingredients and delicious "gravy" selections onclusinf a to die for Pesto.Highly recommend you try this hidden gem.Vegetarian options: They have delicious vegetarian options including a veggie pasta.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak and Cheese Sub, Zeppoles, ANP 2 Garlic Knots, Penn Station Cheesesteak Hero, Astoria Greek Salad, Pie, Salad
Ronald Johnson
Pizza was excellent. I highly recommend the Hawaiian with your choice of extras. Crust was crispy.
Came for carry out..First time there..menu had a nice variety.Prices were reasonable.Got a pizza..salad and a steak sub and everything tasted great. Will definitely return.
Food: 5
Jose Serrano
The wings are simply amazing, pizza was great and the garlic knots are epic.We dined in, myself, wife and 2 daughters.Had 2 beers as well, bill was under $90.Can't beat that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings, Large Cheese Pizza
Priscila Hernandez
Love the zeppoles! Great pizza too!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Zeppoles
Ana Cardona cardona
Worst service ever!! Not only did they get my husbands order wrong but, he had brought in some açai from another nearby restaurant already had eaten it was just finishing it off and it was a huge problem for him to be inside the store even though he was ordering from them. My husband ordered a box of pizza for my 2year old and myself and did not let us eat at the establishment in which we had just bought food from? What kind of service is that? The lady working there was trying to be nice and explain but nothing they said was really valid btw. But the man who was the manager there was totally rude kept being secretive talking about us and kicked us out. So disrespectful. Never evlating there again. Neither recommend coming here ever. Ended up eating outside in the park late at night. Definitely not a family friendly or friendly in general place at all. It sucked!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lola Hernandez
Everything was great! Teriyaki chicken wings were ? and the pizza was so good. Even the crust was good and im not a crust person. The whole staff were also very friendly.
My wife and I stopped in for a quick bite to eat. We have not been to this location, but had been to others in the past and always loved their pizza. This location is a little different, you order at what appears to be a host/hostess stand, and then you take a seat. Your food is delivered to the table once it is ready. We ordered some boneless wings tossed in buffalo sauce and a pizza. The wings were delivered pretty quickly. We jumped in and gave them a try. I thought they were a little hard and not that good. After looking at them and how dark they were, I decided to take them to someone at the counter. They offered to re-make them. The new batch came out looking much better and tasted so much better. We appreciate how quickly they fixed the issue. For our pizza, we ordered the Brooklyn Buffalo Chicken Pie. We have has this pie so many times and will continue to get it. It is so good and just has the flavors we love. They made the pie exactly as we remember it and we were so happy. If we find ourselves in the area, we would for sure stop back in.
I love the fact that I can order slices of pizza here, unlike when I have to order full pies from the national/international chains. I'm also from NYC, so being able to consume pizza like back home is such an awesome experience. I've even went as far as bring back a slice from Ray's pizza in NYC and compare it to the NYPD slice and it was gang-busters! No difference! Everyone employed at this location is friendly, efficient, and on top of things; New Yorkers for sure! I like how their menu items are named after NYC places/references and the decor only complements such cool references. I have yet to compare the Junior's cheesecake slice to an actual Junior's cheesecake slice, but every time I fly back to Orlando from NYC LGA airport, I always bring back a chocolate mousse cheesecake, so a fair comparison has yet to take place. I'll follow up once I make another round trip from visiting family and friends.
I am a big fan of their location on International Drive but when visiting Disney we needed something closer south. We were craving NYPD Pizza and decided to try this location. Unfortunately it is nothing like the other location. For one it's a lot smaller. If you are a party larger than 4, you are gonna have a seating problem. There is only one table available for parties larger than 4. Secondly, unlike what I assume is their sister location (and probably the original) which offers full service, this location has an odd setup. You stand in line to order with the hostess. Then serve yourself your drinks while you wait for your order. If you are dining in, your pizza and any special condiments are brought to your table, but that would be the extent of your service. The pizza is delicious, although missing something compared to the International Drive location. I think I it might be the other location's pie is slightly crispier, and I prefer it. The biggest issue you may have to keep in mind when coming here is the size of your party. Not large party friendly. But other than that, it's ok overall. Just a subpar experience compared to their other location.
Yesterday we ate with my friends from church and it was a great experience, all the workers were very kind, especially Daniela, such an attentive and kind girl, she helped us choose our dishes and we were all pleased, thank you for your attention.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We arrived by chance and we had the best impressions, good service, excellent food and variety of exquisite dishes.
Pizza n wings are the best in the state of FL period
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie, Chicken Wings
Good food and good atmosphere. Prices are fair and service is outstanding. Only thing they need to do is to expand their restaurant for more clientele. I think they would do a lot better for them but other than that it's a fantastic place to go.
Best pizza in Hunters Creek!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Sisters Allie and Lauren have incredible customer service personalities and are always greeting you with a smile. Mary(family friend), is always hustling and providing over the top hospitality.Amazing pizza dough and crust. Fresh ingredients and delicious "gravy" selections onclusinf a to die for Pesto.Highly recommend you try this hidden gem.Vegetarian options: They have delicious vegetarian options including a veggie pasta.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak and Cheese Sub, Zeppoles, ANP 2 Garlic Knots, Penn Station Cheesesteak Hero, Astoria Greek Salad, Pie, Salad
Pizza was excellent. I highly recommend the Hawaiian with your choice of extras. Crust was crispy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Came for carry out..First time there..menu had a nice variety.Prices were reasonable.Got a pizza..salad and a steak sub and everything tasted great. Will definitely return.
Food: 5
The wings are simply amazing, pizza was great and the garlic knots are epic.We dined in, myself, wife and 2 daughters.Had 2 beers as well, bill was under $90.Can't beat that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings, Large Cheese Pizza
Love the zeppoles! Great pizza too!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Zeppoles
Worst service ever!! Not only did they get my husbands order wrong but, he had brought in some açai from another nearby restaurant already had eaten it was just finishing it off and it was a huge problem for him to be inside the store even though he was ordering from them. My husband ordered a box of pizza for my 2year old and myself and did not let us eat at the establishment in which we had just bought food from? What kind of service is that? The lady working there was trying to be nice and explain but nothing they said was really valid btw. But the man who was the manager there was totally rude kept being secretive talking about us and kicked us out. So disrespectful. Never evlating there again. Neither recommend coming here ever. Ended up eating outside in the park late at night. Definitely not a family friendly or friendly in general place at all. It sucked!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Everything was great! Teriyaki chicken wings were ? and the pizza was so good. Even the crust was good and im not a crust person. The whole staff were also very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pie, Pie, Chicken Wings