Oof. Not a good experience. I ordered over-easy eggs and the whites were pure liquid (had the consistency of snot. The whites, mind you, NOT just the yolk) and my server *OF COURSE* had to try and argue that this was normal despite me being very polite about it. The Culinary Institute of America defines over-easy as having the whites cooked through. My father also ordered over-easy and his were perfect. Easy to spot the difference between the two. Restaurants don’t need to get all defensive and victim-blame when they’re blatantly wrong - just own it like a mature adult and fix your mistake.It took 10 minutes for my fiancé to get a straw for her drink. Our waiter was deep in conversation with another table and we had to flag down another employee for help with that.The rest of the food ranged from mediocre to good. Will not be returning due to the high prices for fairly average food, lackluster service and being haggled over a freaking egg.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast
Jennifer Trepanier
I had actually never heard of this restaurant before one of my friends brought me here for dinner one night! It’s at Disney’s Old Key West Resort and if you know Disney, everything has a back story. Rhe theming of this restaurant is all about being in Old Key West, from the mismatched furniture and silverware, to the colors and food style. The prime rib is wonderful and the cost isn’t insanely high compared to other Disney dining experiences. This is a great, underrated restaurant for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Amy Chionchio
I had banana bread French toast... it was fantastic!Our server, Ryan, was outstanding! So friendly and accommodating. He made us coffee and tea to go. He definitely made our day. Thank you so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast
Lynn Hicks
We had great food except the banana foster. They have changed it. The banana bread is now deep fried. Waitress was fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pull Apart Bread, Soup
Jamison Williams
I had a great breakfast here and service was awesome. They even gave my wife and I a surprise for our anniversary!Update: Went back again and had Lisa again. She is awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sweet Person
The service was undeniable great but the food is overpriced, just thrown on the plate and tasted horrible. A separate biscuit $5.50, just
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Juli W.
This is a great stop for breakfast or brunch. Today I got the mahi mahi fish tacos for brunch and they were delicious. It said tropical slaw on them which I wasn't sure if it meant there'd be like mango and other yucky shizz in there but it wasn't. Just regular slaw. The chips were soggy, I couldn't eat those. And the Mickey waffles could have done some serious damage if chucked at a pedestrian. HARD. But to be expected Service was a little slow and the patio wasn't open, but still had a fun experience with friends This is a family friendly vibe, I wouldn't necessarily come for a drink in the evening. But fine for the day Still licking the mahi mahi off my phat lips. Yum yum in the belly drum
Kristen W.
Great cozy restaurant offering no frills kind of food. Everything here is always solid & priced very reasonably. Service can be hit or miss & if you come on a weekend prepare to park a little far. They didn't have the outdoor patio available for seating which is a huge miss for brunch on a beautiful day like today. I love that they offer brunch everyday until 2:00 pm. Awesome to be able to grab breakfast later!
John P.
Earlier this month we took a trip to Disney World and we returned to one of our former favorite restaurants at Old Key West called Olivia's. I am truly sorry to report that this restaurant has deteriorated quite badly. The once bright, cheerful atmosphere is now dismal and covered with dirt and dust. We had a large party and were assigned a single waitress, who seemed quite incapable of performing her duties. My wife met with the chef, and after agreeing to prepare something without seasoning, it was promptly ignored, and they never prepared her dinner. When they redid the meal, it was covered in seasoning she is allergic to. When it was brought to her redone a second time, it was a dreadful, inedible, oily mess. Her dinner was too disgusting to photograph. My Meal (see photograph) was equally inedible. Mashed potatoes, prepared too far in advance were gummy and reminded me of Elmer's glue. A breaded cutlet of chicken that had clearly been frozen and reheated was awful. Appetizers arrived after dinners, Bread and drinks all arrived late and to the wrong people. Frankly, we skipped dessert because we could not wait to leave. It's saddens me that this once excellent restaurant has crumbled from ineptitude and indifference. We will never return to Olivia's. I strongly urge you to avoid this establishment as it has devolved into a greasy spoon.
Samantha Stillwell
The prime rib and bacon cheeseburger were delicious. The mussels were a little spicy which some in our party didn’t like as well as the ketchup (which we all thought was weird).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slow-Cooked Prime Rib, Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken, Burger
Went for a birthday meal. Servers saying they were overstuffed. Waited to be seated, then the waitress ignored us at the table. No food for over an hour. No source for the delays No apologies. Worst experience at a disney restaurant EVER.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Mark Morris
We ate outside. The servers were awesome. I highly recommend the Cajun seasoned Mahi Mahi. It was cooked to perfection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish
Jade M.
A hidden gem! We were looking for a place to have breakfast on our Disney Springs day and I remembered that there is a boat between Old Key West and Disney Springs, so we decided to try Olivia's Cafe. Olivia's feels very homey and is decorated with family photos of DVC members and laid back beach memorabilia. We were seated right away in a cozy booth and our server brought us everything we needed and more. My parents enjoyed the crab cake eggs benedict and Olivia's breakfast. My husband liked the sombrero beach omelet and I thought the signature bacon cheeseburger was very good! If you are staying at Old Key West or are in the area, check it out for an easy going brunch!
katie Bannasch
Came here with friends and they were able to accommodate very complicated allergy menu for one of our party. Grateful for that.Breakfast food is very good. Banana bread French toast very good.Server was so so kind and attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating with complicated allergy order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast, Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict
katie B
Came here with friends and they were able to accommodate very complicated allergy menu for one of our party. Grateful for that.Breakfast food is very good. Banana bread French toast very good.Server was so so kind and attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating with complicated allergy order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast, Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict
Oof. Not a good experience. I ordered over-easy eggs and the whites were pure liquid (had the consistency of snot. The whites, mind you, NOT just the yolk) and my server *OF COURSE* had to try and argue that this was normal despite me being very polite about it. The Culinary Institute of America defines over-easy as having the whites cooked through. My father also ordered over-easy and his were perfect. Easy to spot the difference between the two. Restaurants don’t need to get all defensive and victim-blame when they’re blatantly wrong - just own it like a mature adult and fix your mistake.It took 10 minutes for my fiancé to get a straw for her drink. Our waiter was deep in conversation with another table and we had to flag down another employee for help with that.The rest of the food ranged from mediocre to good. Will not be returning due to the high prices for fairly average food, lackluster service and being haggled over a freaking egg.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast
I had actually never heard of this restaurant before one of my friends brought me here for dinner one night! It’s at Disney’s Old Key West Resort and if you know Disney, everything has a back story. Rhe theming of this restaurant is all about being in Old Key West, from the mismatched furniture and silverware, to the colors and food style. The prime rib is wonderful and the cost isn’t insanely high compared to other Disney dining experiences. This is a great, underrated restaurant for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
I had banana bread French toast... it was fantastic!Our server, Ryan, was outstanding! So friendly and accommodating. He made us coffee and tea to go. He definitely made our day. Thank you so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast
We had great food except the banana foster. They have changed it. The banana bread is now deep fried. Waitress was fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pull Apart Bread, Soup
I had a great breakfast here and service was awesome. They even gave my wife and I a surprise for our anniversary!Update: Went back again and had Lisa again. She is awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
The service was undeniable great but the food is overpriced, just thrown on the plate and tasted horrible. A separate biscuit $5.50, just
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
This is a great stop for breakfast or brunch. Today I got the mahi mahi fish tacos for brunch and they were delicious. It said tropical slaw on them which I wasn't sure if it meant there'd be like mango and other yucky shizz in there but it wasn't. Just regular slaw. The chips were soggy, I couldn't eat those. And the Mickey waffles could have done some serious damage if chucked at a pedestrian. HARD. But to be expected Service was a little slow and the patio wasn't open, but still had a fun experience with friends This is a family friendly vibe, I wouldn't necessarily come for a drink in the evening. But fine for the day Still licking the mahi mahi off my phat lips. Yum yum in the belly drum
Great cozy restaurant offering no frills kind of food. Everything here is always solid & priced very reasonably. Service can be hit or miss & if you come on a weekend prepare to park a little far. They didn't have the outdoor patio available for seating which is a huge miss for brunch on a beautiful day like today. I love that they offer brunch everyday until 2:00 pm. Awesome to be able to grab breakfast later!
Earlier this month we took a trip to Disney World and we returned to one of our former favorite restaurants at Old Key West called Olivia's. I am truly sorry to report that this restaurant has deteriorated quite badly. The once bright, cheerful atmosphere is now dismal and covered with dirt and dust. We had a large party and were assigned a single waitress, who seemed quite incapable of performing her duties. My wife met with the chef, and after agreeing to prepare something without seasoning, it was promptly ignored, and they never prepared her dinner. When they redid the meal, it was covered in seasoning she is allergic to. When it was brought to her redone a second time, it was a dreadful, inedible, oily mess. Her dinner was too disgusting to photograph. My Meal (see photograph) was equally inedible. Mashed potatoes, prepared too far in advance were gummy and reminded me of Elmer's glue. A breaded cutlet of chicken that had clearly been frozen and reheated was awful. Appetizers arrived after dinners, Bread and drinks all arrived late and to the wrong people. Frankly, we skipped dessert because we could not wait to leave. It's saddens me that this once excellent restaurant has crumbled from ineptitude and indifference. We will never return to Olivia's. I strongly urge you to avoid this establishment as it has devolved into a greasy spoon.
The prime rib and bacon cheeseburger were delicious. The mussels were a little spicy which some in our party didn’t like as well as the ketchup (which we all thought was weird).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slow-Cooked Prime Rib, Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken, Burger
Restaurantji Recommends
Went for a birthday meal. Servers saying they were overstuffed. Waited to be seated, then the waitress ignored us at the table. No food for over an hour. No source for the delays No apologies. Worst experience at a disney restaurant EVER.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
We ate outside. The servers were awesome. I highly recommend the Cajun seasoned Mahi Mahi. It was cooked to perfection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish
A hidden gem! We were looking for a place to have breakfast on our Disney Springs day and I remembered that there is a boat between Old Key West and Disney Springs, so we decided to try Olivia's Cafe. Olivia's feels very homey and is decorated with family photos of DVC members and laid back beach memorabilia. We were seated right away in a cozy booth and our server brought us everything we needed and more. My parents enjoyed the crab cake eggs benedict and Olivia's breakfast. My husband liked the sombrero beach omelet and I thought the signature bacon cheeseburger was very good! If you are staying at Old Key West or are in the area, check it out for an easy going brunch!
Came here with friends and they were able to accommodate very complicated allergy menu for one of our party. Grateful for that.Breakfast food is very good. Banana bread French toast very good.Server was so so kind and attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating with complicated allergy order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast, Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict
Came here with friends and they were able to accommodate very complicated allergy menu for one of our party. Grateful for that.Breakfast food is very good. Banana bread French toast very good.Server was so so kind and attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating with complicated allergy order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Bread French Toast, Crab Cake-Eggs Benedict