Jeremiah's Italian Ice

I had a long day and morning. Walking home from my job because of a no show to come get me. And to not stay in Juno beach, these young lady (Sidney & Adriane) brought me out of a small depression and sad day. They are the best the smoke they give you when walking in is amazing and also to be a stranger drenched in sweat they came with open arms and treated me as such and not a stranger I love them… thank you because they’re really the best lord thank you for them

Yummy!!!!!

What a treat! Taylor took really good care of us today, and we were pleasantly surprised by our first visit. Variety of delicious flavor offerings(free samples!) at a good price. Highly recommend!

My daughter WITH BRACES found this metal piece in her cookie dough Italian ice! This is absolutely ridiculous thank God, she didn’t break a bracket or worse a tooth! How in the hell could this happen?

Good ice Friendly staff very good

The best flavors and great service! Love it here!

Nice portions and flavor, and reasonable prices. Young lady was very sweet A+

Place is fantastic but ordered on Uber eats twice in past week at 8:40 to have a staff member cancel the order. Seems to be luck of the draw if they decide they want to make it or not before they close. Certainly if I was the owner i wouldn’t want my staff rejecting sales before closing.

The Italian ice is really good, I just feel bad for the employees because it gets busy really quick and I haven’t seen a manager on the floor not once, and I’ve been going here since I moved to the area a few months ago.

Excellent Gelato and even better customer service.

I’m from Philly, where we pretty much brought Italian Ice up to an art form. Jeremiah’s is not your average water ice. They are very inventive and nail a lot of flavors you wouldn’t believe possible. My faves are black cherry and lemon in the classic vein, but they have a mint chocolate chip that is off the hook and brownie batter that really tastes like brownie batter. How they pull this off is beyond me but it’s worth the trip. They have custard in chocolate or vanilla, but I wouldn’t give their custard a 10. It’s not as creamy as I expected it to be. It doesn’t have the texture or richness of Rita’s or Kohrs, but I am used to Philly and Rehoboth Beach. I go for the ice anyway. Give yourself a treat and give these folks a try. I love the Gardens location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Italian Ice

Amazing ice cream had the pumpkin pie. Must go back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sooooo good! We had the pumpkin pie flavorite. Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious, and you can try any flavors before making your selection! Great prices for the tadpole mini size. The staff is friendly too. It actually makes going out for a treat a completely affordable and enjoyable experience again! Love that they are open until 10:00 as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was our first trip to Jeremiah’s and the ice cream sundaes were as fun and tasty as we expected.

However, the service and ambience in this particular store left a lot to be desired. Despite arriving almost an hour before closing, the two girls working did their best to make us feel uncomfortable by sweeping up, packing away chairs, bringing in all the outside equipment etc despite us trying to sit and enjoy our ice cream.

They also tried to ignore us when we stood at the counter waiting to order. Must do better.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2