Cry Baby Creamery

17389 S Dixie Hwy, Palmetto Bay
(305) 563-6814

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Waffle Cone Crumbles
Oreo Crumbles M&M's
Crushed Peppermint
Honey Nut Pralines
Brewster Lychees
Slice of Pie
Meat Pizza
Hot Fudge
Pastelito
Cookies

Featured items
Milk & Cookies
Salted vanilla ice cream with homemade chocolate chip cookies & Oreo cookies.
Box Car
Oreo ice cream sandwiched in between two home-made chocolate chip cookies.
Hazelnut Crunch
Nutella Ice cream, nutella fudge swirls, hazelnut crunch
Cookies & Caramel
Cookie Butter Ice cream, vanilla caramel, biscoff cookie chunks
Ooey Gooey
Cream Cheese Ice cream, ooey gooey butter cake, mixed berry swirl
Split Decision
Our signature fudge brownie and chocolate chip cookie combined.
Exquisito Chocolate Brownie
Exquisito (located in Little Havana) chocolate brownie...it's creamy and delicious.
Bean to Cone
Exquisito Chocolate's milk chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate shavings.
Viva Pastelito
Cream cheese & mascarpone ice cream with guava swirls & caramelized puff pastry.
Sticky Fingers
Our House Vanilla ice cream sandwiched in-between two of our home-made Exquisito chocolate brownies.
Party Animal
BRIGHT GREEN vanilla ice cream with swirls of homemade vanilla frosting, rainbow sprinkles & frosted animal crackers.
House Vanilla
Our creamy, classic vanilla ice cream.
Espumita Boss
Per'la coffee cold brew ice cream.

Pints
Milk & Cookies
Salted vanilla ice cream with homemade chocolate chip cookies & Oreo cookies.
Viva Pastelito
Cream cheese & mascarpone ice cream with guava swirls & caramelized puff pastry.
Bean to Cone
Exquisito Chocolate's milk chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate shavings.
Party Animal
BRIGHT GREEN vanilla ice cream with swirls of homemade vanilla frosting, rainbow sprinkles & frosted animal crackers.
Espumita Boss
Per'la coffee cold brew ice cream.
House Vanilla
Our creamy, classic vanilla ice cream.
Insulated Bag + Ice Packs
Cry Baby branded reusable insulated bag with 2 ice packs.
Hazelnut Crunch
Nutella Ice cream, nutella fudge swirls, hazelnut crunch
Cookies & Caramel
Cookie Butter Ice cream, vanilla caramel, biscoff cookie chunks
Flan Brulee
Flan Ice cream with crunchy caramel shards
Ooey Gooey
Cream Cheese Ice cream, ooey gooey butter cake, mixed berry swirl

Novelties
Box Car
Oreo ice cream sandwiched in between two home-made chocolate chip cookies.
Sticky Fingers
Our House Vanilla ice cream sandwiched in-between two of our home-made Exquisito chocolate brownies.

Baked Goods
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Dark chocolate, milk chocolate & sea salt.
Birthday Cake Cookie
Yellow cake & rainbow sprinkles.
Exquisito Chocolate Brownie
Exquisito (located in Little Havana) chocolate brownie...it's creamy and delicious.
Guava Cookie
Caramelized guava & Maria crackers.
Triple Chocolate Cookie
Chocolate cookie, milk chocolate, dark chocolate & sea salt.
Split Decision
Our signature fudge brownie and chocolate chip cookie combined.
S'more Cookie
Graham crackers, mini marshmallow, milk chocolate
Ooey Gooey Cookie
All time favorite! Cream Cheese and Butter cookie

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
+29 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+28 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

I’m visiting from out of town and just stopped by for some ice cream. The flavor and texture is perfect! They have a guava ice cream that’s insane. Definitely would be a favorite spot if I still lived here.
May 2026
Really great ice cream! Has great flavor and their cookies are amazing! Really big cookies and unique flavors! I got the cookie butter and caramel ice cream and the cream cheese cookie! So good! Glad they opened one closer to me
February 2026
First time trying their icecream and wow I’m blown away, I got cookies and caramel and oh boy is it incredible generous caramel and biscoff cookies in a cookie butter flavored ice cream I also got ooey gooey and if you love cream cheese like I do it’s a must try!!! Thank you!!
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Maxwell Bros Clothing Store - 17395 S Dixie Hwy
Pizza, Brewery, Beer Bar, Vegan
Aromas Del Peru - 17225 S Dixie Hwy Unit 100
Peruvian, Sushi Bar, Seafood
Walter's Coffee Shop by Sergio - 17009 S Dixie Hwy
Cafe, Sports Bar, Pet Friendly, Breakfast, Vegan

Cry Baby Creamery

17389 S Dixie Hwy, Palmetto Bay, FL 33157
(305) 563-6814