Old Cutler Inn
$$$ • Cocktail Bar
Hours:
16800 Old Cutler Rd, Palmetto Bay
(305) 419-0893
About Old Cutler Inn
Old Cutler Inn Reviews
Share your opinion about Old Cutler Inn
I live very close to this restaurant and wanted to try it since it opened. My husband and I went without a reservation, but showed up at 5 p.m. and secured a seat at the bar. Lets get to it...The food is overpriced and not that great. That is unfortunate but true. The menu is very small and has issues...for example why would you only offer Swordfish for a fish option. I have worked at restaurants for many years and am an avid cook...I know as most do that Swordfish is a very polarizing...read full review
Germany at the bar was awesome, no complaim with her service, but when we went to get our car at the Valet that we had to pay plus give him a tip, he told my husband that he had to get his car from the lot, WTF if I am paying for valet you bring me the car…….this happen on Sunday ag around 9:45 pm the guy said he was alone and could not bring my car but there were no cars waiting and all the time he was on his phone, mind you I am dissable and in in pain waiting for my car.
Extremely disappointing experience — I would strongly caution anyone thinking of coming here.
We made reservations a week in advance for 5:45 PM, only to have them cancelled. We then booked again online for 5:15 PM for four people and a baby. When we arrived, we were told they weren’t honoring any reservations until 6 PM. No one ever answers the phone, only a voicemail saying the restaurant is “opening soon.”
The staff unapologetically told us the reservation...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 7:30AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 7:30AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 7:30AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 7:30AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 7:30AM - 10PM |
People in Palmetto Bay Also Viewed
.jpg)
Old Cutler Inn offers a relaxing and highly enjoyable dining experience with a great, inviting atmosphere. The food is amazing and top notch, with specific praise for the snapper appetizer, the mahi soup, and the salmon. The brunch is $50 per person with an option for unlimited drinks. Service is frequently described as exceptional, outstanding, attentive, professional, and friendly, contributing to a smooth and wonderful experience. The staff works efficiently and makes guests feel welcome. Drinks are excellent and perfectly prepared. While the brunch buffet is noted as smaller with a desire for more variety, and service has room for improvement, the overall experience is frequently called the best and is highly recommended, with many guests planning to return.