When in town I love stopping here. There slices of pizza are amazing. The chicken parmigiana sandwich as well. I’m fact this is my go to place when I’m this part of town. Nice place to eat as well. Love the Ninja Turtle theme :)
I ordered for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was great. I’m pretty sure it was the cheese that made it. Delicious ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arnie Greenberg
Great thin crust NY style cheese pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New York Style Cheese Pizza
Kevin Jose H.
Just giving another shout out to this wonderful place. Loved the restaurant aesthetics which is ninja turtle themed. As I waited for the food, I was able to play turtle in time ninja turtle arcade game. I ordered take out and they were quick. The food is amazing. I mean look at that 18' at $23. It's already almost gone and it's a couple minutes haha.
Dianne G.
I have ordered pizza from this establishment several times; each time saying never again. Let me explain. Pizza is a personal preference. Some people do not like a lot of sauce. I do, but Coley's pizza seems like crust and cheese. Little flavor. Little oil. Perhaps I should ask for extra sauce and that would improve their pizza for me. The employees are friendly, the restaurant looks very clean, and I've never gotten sick from eating there. But as a New Jersey transplant, it's just not favorite pizza.
Ross H.
Great pizza close to the house. God crust, not too thick. Delicious toppings. Must for the area.
Marco Straziota
First time there, ordered to go! Excellent pizza, nice texture, awesome taste, friendly staff, fair price! I'll definitely go back... loved the arcade
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Style Cheese Pizza
Jules M.
Not a good pizza. Sauce tasted flat and pasty. Dough was tough and harsh. Great customer service though. The staff is awesome. I just wish they would improve their pizza recipe.
Patrice P.
Super thin pizza and almost zero grease. On Wednesdays large Pizzas are $14.99 so I ordered a pizza and a small order of garlic Parm fries. I ordered ny style crust and it was much thinner than I anticipated because they also give you a thin crust option. Pizza was good but the fries were a complete rip off. $8.75 and had no extra flavor. You can see the parm but there was no flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samuel Morhaim
Amazing NY style pizza. 90’s style, brick walls, ninja turtles everywhere and also an industrial style. C R A Z Y G O O D!!!Kid-friendliness: Arcade machines!!
Not good at all . No flavor , don't know what else to say . Taste like a cheap frozen pizza. Don't understand the no flavor with the veggies I got . I did not get any meat on mine. .
Shelly T.
My experience was okay, I did not like the chicken Philly I got. They chop it all up together into the tiniest pieces and the texture wasn't appealing. I like tasting the different elements of the food and the way they do it is like eating mush. The pizza is okay, not mind blowing, but the wings were pretty good. I might go back and try other menu items. The staff on the phone was pleasant. And my daughter said the decor is really cool for kids. They have Nina Turtles mural on the wall.
Coleys is already known for its pizza but don’t shy away from their sandwiches and wing menu! The extended menu choices are outstanding and I highly recommend the BBQ chicken sandwich with fries; which has become my “I don’t want pizza today” pick.Kid-friendliness: You’ll love the dine in area and so will your kids. Plenty to keep them busy with vintage games and artwork by local artists while you wait for your delicious food.
When in town I love stopping here. There slices of pizza are amazing. The chicken parmigiana sandwich as well. I’m fact this is my go to place when I’m this part of town. Nice place to eat as well. Love the Ninja Turtle theme :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Curly Fries, Chicken Wings, Cheese Pizza, Signature Pizza, Chicken Parmesan Sub, Garlic Rolls, Mozzarella Sticks, Wings, New York Style Cheese Pizza
I ordered for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was great. I’m pretty sure it was the cheese that made it. Delicious ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great thin crust NY style cheese pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New York Style Cheese Pizza
Just giving another shout out to this wonderful place. Loved the restaurant aesthetics which is ninja turtle themed. As I waited for the food, I was able to play turtle in time ninja turtle arcade game. I ordered take out and they were quick. The food is amazing. I mean look at that 18' at $23. It's already almost gone and it's a couple minutes haha.
I have ordered pizza from this establishment several times; each time saying never again. Let me explain. Pizza is a personal preference. Some people do not like a lot of sauce. I do, but Coley's pizza seems like crust and cheese. Little flavor. Little oil. Perhaps I should ask for extra sauce and that would improve their pizza for me. The employees are friendly, the restaurant looks very clean, and I've never gotten sick from eating there. But as a New Jersey transplant, it's just not favorite pizza.
Great pizza close to the house. God crust, not too thick. Delicious toppings. Must for the area.
First time there, ordered to go! Excellent pizza, nice texture, awesome taste, friendly staff, fair price! I'll definitely go back... loved the arcade
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Style Cheese Pizza
Not a good pizza. Sauce tasted flat and pasty. Dough was tough and harsh. Great customer service though. The staff is awesome. I just wish they would improve their pizza recipe.
Super thin pizza and almost zero grease. On Wednesdays large Pizzas are $14.99 so I ordered a pizza and a small order of garlic Parm fries. I ordered ny style crust and it was much thinner than I anticipated because they also give you a thin crust option. Pizza was good but the fries were a complete rip off. $8.75 and had no extra flavor. You can see the parm but there was no flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing NY style pizza. 90’s style, brick walls, ninja turtles everywhere and also an industrial style. C R A Z Y G O O D!!!Kid-friendliness: Arcade machines!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Signature Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Not good at all . No flavor , don't know what else to say . Taste like a cheap frozen pizza. Don't understand the no flavor with the veggies I got . I did not get any meat on mine. .
My experience was okay, I did not like the chicken Philly I got. They chop it all up together into the tiniest pieces and the texture wasn't appealing. I like tasting the different elements of the food and the way they do it is like eating mush. The pizza is okay, not mind blowing, but the wings were pretty good. I might go back and try other menu items. The staff on the phone was pleasant. And my daughter said the decor is really cool for kids. They have Nina Turtles mural on the wall.
Cute little pizza place. Pizza was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A fun space and great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan Sub, Garlic Rolls, Cheese Pizza
Coleys is already known for its pizza but don’t shy away from their sandwiches and wing menu! The extended menu choices are outstanding and I highly recommend the BBQ chicken sandwich with fries; which has become my “I don’t want pizza today” pick.Kid-friendliness: You’ll love the dine in area and so will your kids. Plenty to keep them busy with vintage games and artwork by local artists while you wait for your delicious food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: My Favorite Pizza Place, BBQ Chicken, Wings, Cheese Pizza