11 Best Italian Restaurants near Polk City

“Hungry Howies in Polk City CANNOT BE BEAT! I always order from this location due to the nature of the location being close to home but also because of their excellent customer service, delicious food (made correctly might I add), and friendly staff. Tonight when ordering on the app I accidentally ordered at a wrong location and when I got here they offered to make it right then and was very kind about my mistake. The manager was super understanding and offered a free drink. Something so small for my mistake was very appreciated! Thank you Polk city for being great!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We usually order sandwiches and pizza for take out, which is always delicious. Last night my husband and I decided to have our date night there and finally try the pasta. This place never fails. The food was amazing, especially the caprese burrata and panna cotta . I wish I could remember our servers name. She was the best server we've had anywhere in a long time. We will definitely be back!!!“

“I love finding new favorite places to eat in Lakeland. Chef T's did not disappoint. It's off the beaten path, a beautiful, charming early 1900s home. It's been open since 2008, how did I not know about it before! Loved the ambience, our server, Sam, the wine, the food, the tiramisu!“

“First time going today August 16,2022,Pizza is great,it made my husband think that he was back in New York,the sauce,the dough and cheese is great,we will coming back soon and we are going to tell our Family and friends,customer service is great ,the owner make you feel like Family.“

“absolutely delicious, authentic Italian food!“

“The team there is very friendly and welcoming. My favorite pie slice is the Rustica it has pepperoni and ricotta cheese over a crispy dough. Tastes amazing, try it.“

“Bay Street Bistro is one of the best kept secrets in Lakeland FL. The food and service is top notch. We have been a few times and every time we go we are more than 100% satisfied.“

“The staff were welcoming. My husband is from Brooklyn, NY and he rated their Ny style pizza an 8.5 out of 10. The cheese pull was insane. We ordered the large pie half pepperoni and half sausage. He does prefer the pepperoni over the sausage.“

“Love this pizza. A little disappointed because I didn’t check my pizza before leaving. Got all the way home and one was burnt. You had to scrape the toppings off without eating the burnt crust. LESSON LEARNED. Guess with the new over- some of the temps are off a bit. Still a favorite plate to eat and enjoy!!!! TIP- Check your pizza before it walks out the door! I need a new one! lol“

“I order from this location quite often. Each time I’ve ordered, my order shows up correct, hot, and fresh. The delivery drivers have always been extremely nice as well. This location, by far, is my favorite location. I appreciate that this team takes their time to make sure the orders are correct. Thank you Hungry Howies N Socrum Loop Rd!“

“I've been to Hungry Howie's just once. This review is almost a year late. This was one of the few if not only place open the day after hurricane Milton passed (2024). Stopped here while returning to Tampa. The workers here provided fast and courteous service. The pizza and cheese bread were good. Many thanks to those workers who came in the day after the hurricane 🌀“