The undercarriage was a bit burnt and if it wasn’t, the pepperoni pizza may have tasted better. The ingredients were fresh and hopefully it was just an overcooked pizza. I have to say the garlic knots lacked garlic. If there was more garlic the taste would have been much better. The person who made the pizza also took my order and gave me a free sample of the bruschetta which is definitely worth a try.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Dana Weeks
The place to go for Italian style pizza in this area!!! Delicious, everytime 😋 Highly Recommended!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlotte Ashford
Nice folks, felt at home and enjoyed the homemade pizza sauce.
Jeannine Weekes
I walked into Tony's last night needing a pizza quickly. The restaurant has the feel of the pizza places of my youth in New York and the northeast. We had the Margherita that was delicious. Their marinara sauce is one of the best that any of us have ever had. I strongly recommend Tony's!!
Brian Tipton
Amazing pizza. Great price. A must go! I am very picky about pizza as well.
Fishy
Best pizza I've ever had.
Brad Jackson
These pizzas are huge. Nice little mom and pop pizza shop.
Lori Anderson
Their eggplant Parmesan is out of this world. The portions are generous. Their pizza crust is thin stale and their sauce is perfect. Nice people work there. Pete set the tone Gid rest his soul!! Love you guys!!
Suzy Bennett
Really delicious white pie!! Service was perfect!!
They don't deliver and were very rude on the phone
Atmosphere: 1
Lisa Mathers
I’ve tried this pizza multiple times over the years. The pizza is soggy at the tip area, heavy ingredients concentrated to the first third of the pizza, which contributes to the heaviness, soggy and watery until you get halfway through the slice. Crust Has a cardboard texture to it. They used to be really good about seven years ago, but I keep trying about once a year and it’s the same. I think I’m done.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
H H
If you want thick dough UNLIKE N.Y. pizza... This is your place, thick dough-y, sloppy, wet cheese
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Johnny N.
Came here looking for some good pizza. This place has good pizza very close to NY. But the service is questionable first I placed the order via phone told would be 45 mins for a pizza and some knots. Ok it was a Friday I get it fine. Waited 45 mins arrived onsite to be told that the order hasn’t even been cooked yet. To come back 10-15 mins seriously? What? So after 12 mins went back in and it was ready. So they put it together and I also ordered 6 garlic knots when suddenly 12 emerged. I explained to her that I said 1/2 dozen. Which she begrudgingly stated I heard 12. Well that was an easy fix and I apologized. All and all the food is good compared to most pizza joints around here and can’t complain about that. The person answering the phone is a little rough around the edges and could use some extra help onsite to get those orders done otherwise give them a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Elizabeth Hartman Ferris
I am from NY and have finally found a place that is real NY pizza and when you walk in the atmosphere is totally NY. Love.Love. Love it. Excellent pizza.
The undercarriage was a bit burnt and if it wasn’t, the pepperoni pizza may have tasted better. The ingredients were fresh and hopefully it was just an overcooked pizza. I have to say the garlic knots lacked garlic. If there was more garlic the taste would have been much better. The person who made the pizza also took my order and gave me a free sample of the bruschetta which is definitely worth a try.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
The place to go for Italian style pizza in this area!!! Delicious, everytime 😋 Highly Recommended!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice folks, felt at home and enjoyed the homemade pizza sauce.
I walked into Tony's last night needing a pizza quickly. The restaurant has the feel of the pizza places of my youth in New York and the northeast. We had the Margherita that was delicious. Their marinara sauce is one of the best that any of us have ever had. I strongly recommend Tony's!!
Amazing pizza. Great price. A must go! I am very picky about pizza as well.
Best pizza I've ever had.
These pizzas are huge. Nice little mom and pop pizza shop.
Their eggplant Parmesan is out of this world. The portions are generous. Their pizza crust is thin stale and their sauce is perfect. Nice people work there. Pete set the tone Gid rest his soul!! Love you guys!!
Really delicious white pie!! Service was perfect!!
EAT!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
They don't deliver and were very rude on the phone
Atmosphere: 1
I’ve tried this pizza multiple times over the years. The pizza is soggy at the tip area, heavy ingredients concentrated to the first third of the pizza, which contributes to the heaviness, soggy and watery until you get halfway through the slice. Crust Has a cardboard texture to it. They used to be really good about seven years ago, but I keep trying about once a year and it’s the same. I think I’m done.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
If you want thick dough UNLIKE N.Y. pizza... This is your place, thick dough-y, sloppy, wet cheese
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Came here looking for some good pizza. This place has good pizza very close to NY. But the service is questionable first I placed the order via phone told would be 45 mins for a pizza and some knots. Ok it was a Friday I get it fine. Waited 45 mins arrived onsite to be told that the order hasn’t even been cooked yet. To come back 10-15 mins seriously? What? So after 12 mins went back in and it was ready. So they put it together and I also ordered 6 garlic knots when suddenly 12 emerged. I explained to her that I said 1/2 dozen. Which she begrudgingly stated I heard 12. Well that was an easy fix and I apologized. All and all the food is good compared to most pizza joints around here and can’t complain about that. The person answering the phone is a little rough around the edges and could use some extra help onsite to get those orders done otherwise give them a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
I am from NY and have finally found a place that is real NY pizza and when you walk in the atmosphere is totally NY. Love.Love. Love it. Excellent pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...