Joey's Italian Bakery

Name: Joey's Italian Bakery
Address: 9721 US-19, Port Richey, Florida, 34668, US
Telephone: (727) 848-2434
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Bakery, Pizza, Pet Friendly

Hours:
9721 US-19, Port Richey
(727) 848-2434

About Joey's Italian Bakery

Joey’s Italian Bakery is a highly praised spot known for its outstanding pastries, pizza, and cakes. Visitors love the variety of baked goods, including the flaky, almond-y bear claw, fruit-filled turnovers, and addictive sesame seed cookies that are crispy, buttery, and just the right amount of sweet. The bakery offers authentic Italian treats, such as the fresh sfogliatella enjoyed with espresso, which many find to be very authentic and welcoming.

Their pizza is a standout feature, especially the New York style pizza, which is cooked in a brick oven and comes in a unique "rustic version" that has a different cheese blend, flavor, and texture. Customers describe it as phenomenal and compare it favorably to well-known pizza places from their past, emphasizing the quality of the sauce, cheese, and dough. The pizza is cooked in a hotter oven, resulting in a special flavor and texture that keeps customers returning weekly.

Joey’s is also praised for its cakes, especially a vanilla Birthday Cake that is flavorful, well-made, and reasonably priced. The staff is friendly, helpful, and genuinely caring, providing great recommendations and service. Overall, Joey’s Italian Bakery is a beloved local spot for delicious pastries, authentic pizza, and exceptional customer service.