I feel like It’s impossible to find this kind of pizza anywhere in FL that I’ve tried so far ! It’s the best NY style
Interpreters ITS
The best mushroom pizza ever. I love many of their pizzas but my favorite is the mushroom. Always cooked to perfection .
Gregory Sanes
There pizza is absolutely amazing! Definitely worth it is you want real pizza. Im not really a fan of ordering at a counter but that's how they roll. This was a quick visit with my girls, the Greek salad was really good. They would have gotten 5 stars from me but they really need to clean the AC vents in the ceiling. That are long over due for a wipe/cleaning.
Tara Gamero
Best pizza in town! Friendly staff too! We will definitely be back!
KellyAnn Butler-Fusco
I really gave Serafinas my best try (many food orders) and had hopes as they are fellow NY'ers. This meatball hero was inedible. 1st it was made wrong, thats ok, but then I get it home and its on some bizarre over flour-y bread which was awful. It had a ton of grease and grease in place of sauce. I took 3 bites and that's it. This was my last attempt. Sorry Chris & the gang....had to be honest, it was awful. So bummed.
bryan bratt
I love this place! Pizza has little to no flop and crust is soo crispy and takes me back to my childhood pizza spot with every slice.
Dawgsin FL
First time I've ever received a mushroom pizza with canned mushrooms. It was gross. We tossed it.
Cheese pizza was great.
Pepperoni was a little greasy.
We will find a different place in the future.
Michael Huff
Best Pizza around! Never disappointed.
Michael H
Absolutely the best Pizza and Italian Hero around! Thank You, Vinny, Cathy and staff, 10 stars!!
Michael Rourke
Best pizza in Jax area; opinion from a former Queens, New Yorker.
I am from ny and this true ny pizza
Its the best i have had in Jax
True sicilian pizza
U will not be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Beierle
Just wanted to say how great this place is and how lucky we are to have such an amazing pizza joint right here in our neighborhood. I just got back from a 6 hour roadtrip with the family tonight( Tuesday) and I was craving good pizza so naturally had to stop by but it was late (845pm) and they closed at 9. I called up and told them what I wanted and they had it ready to go when I got there. Not only that but they even threw in a few extra slices for free!! The girls working the counter were great and their customer service was top notch! Thank you all so much for another awesome pizza experience!
Judith. Tholl
From the moment we stepped in, the atmosphere was perfect—cozy, welcoming, and filled with the mouthwatering scent of fresh pizza straight from the oven. The staff greeted us warmly, and the vibe was just right for a casual, yet special evening.
We started with their famous garlic knots, which were absolutely divine—soft, buttery, and perfectly seasoned. Both were incredible! The crust was the ideal mix of crispy and chewy, and the flavors of the fresh toppings came together beautifully.
Kyle and I both agreed it was one of the best meals we’ve had in a long time. The delicious food, inviting ambiance, and genuine hospitality made for a perfect date night.
Serafina's Pizzeria catered our Ladies Guild Christmas Party at Our Lady of Good Counsel Church. From deciding the menu with Vinny to delivery, from Jeff, it was all fabulous. Also,thank you Dante for helping us with a gluten free dish. Looking forward to more parties with your great food.
I feel like It’s impossible to find this kind of pizza anywhere in FL that I’ve tried so far ! It’s the best NY style
The best mushroom pizza ever.
I love many of their pizzas but my favorite is the mushroom. Always cooked to perfection .
There pizza is absolutely amazing! Definitely worth it is you want real pizza. Im not really a fan of ordering at a counter but that's how they roll. This was a quick visit with my girls, the Greek salad was really good. They would have gotten 5 stars from me but they really need to clean the AC vents in the ceiling. That are long over due for a wipe/cleaning.
Best pizza in town! Friendly staff too! We will definitely be back!
I really gave Serafinas my best try (many food orders) and had hopes as they are fellow NY'ers. This meatball hero was inedible. 1st it was made wrong, thats ok, but then I get it home and its on some bizarre over flour-y bread which was awful. It had a ton of grease and grease in place of sauce. I took 3 bites and that's it. This was my last attempt. Sorry Chris & the gang....had to be honest, it was awful. So bummed.
I love this place! Pizza has little to no flop and crust is soo crispy and takes me back to my childhood pizza spot with every slice.
First time I've ever received a mushroom pizza with canned mushrooms. It was gross. We tossed it.
Cheese pizza was great.
Pepperoni was a little greasy.
We will find a different place in the future.
Best Pizza around! Never disappointed.
Absolutely the best Pizza and Italian Hero around! Thank You, Vinny, Cathy and staff, 10 stars!!
Best pizza in Jax area; opinion from a former Queens, New Yorker.
Restaurantji Recommends
I am from ny and this true ny pizza Its the best i have had in Jax True sicilian pizza U will not be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just wanted to say how great this place is and how lucky we are to have such an amazing pizza joint right here in our neighborhood. I just got back from a 6 hour roadtrip with the family tonight( Tuesday) and I was craving good pizza so naturally had to stop by but it was late (845pm) and they closed at 9. I called up and told them what I wanted and they had it ready to go when I got there. Not only that but they even threw in a few extra slices for free!! The girls working the counter were great and their customer service was top notch! Thank you all so much for another awesome pizza experience!
From the moment we stepped in, the atmosphere was perfect—cozy, welcoming, and filled with the mouthwatering scent of fresh pizza straight from the oven. The staff greeted us warmly, and the vibe was just right for a casual, yet special evening.
We started with their famous garlic knots, which were absolutely divine—soft, buttery, and perfectly seasoned. Both were incredible! The crust was the ideal mix of crispy and chewy, and the flavors of the fresh toppings came together beautifully.
Kyle and I both agreed it was one of the best meals we’ve had in a long time. The delicious food, inviting ambiance, and genuine hospitality made for a perfect date night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Regular Cheese Pizza
Serafina's Pizzeria catered our Ladies Guild Christmas Party at Our Lady of Good Counsel Church. From deciding the menu with Vinny to delivery, from Jeff, it was all fabulous. Also,thank you Dante for helping us with a gluten free dish. Looking forward to more parties with your great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Chicken Parm, Salad
Hands down the best garlic knots I’ve ever tried! Loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Loading...