Your Pie Pizza

90 Durbin Pavilion Dr STE-101 Suite 101, St Johns
(904) 295-3749

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert Gamble

We have been to Your Pies in other areas, this one left us disappointed. We had to check our order to make sure we didnt accidentally ask for low sauce and cheese. You could see the bottoms of the pizzas because there were so little toppings on all of them.

All of the pies had the vaguest impression of cheese, and the sauce was so thin that it had all but evaporated in the oven. The only way we knew they didnt forget either was because it was reddish and slightly white. No strings of cheese when you pulled the slices apart or bit into them. Sad sad pizza.

We ate them because everyone was hungry, but if it wasnt for a birthday we would have returned them for a refund.

Unless your thing is round sad bread, do not go here. Try the grocery store's frozen section for something better than this place. Your family will be happier.

Food: 1

Crosby nelson II

Aden seemed like a nice fellow but he answer the phone mid making my pizza then goes back to putting toppings on my pizza and never changed his gloves. I was shocked on top of that they didn’t have any wings in stock. Please train employees not to do that again.

ami pinero

They refuse to take orders by phone. They say it's a company policy but the app is trash so the only way to pick up is to go in and wait. This is very inconvenient especially for me who I am a caregiver and usually can't be away for long. Change the policy or I won't be back.

Dawn Cook

Super yummy, and quick pizza stop!!!
I live nearby and had never tried it. After trying, I’ve returned twice this week!
You go through the toppings like subway and create your pizza. Yummy offerings! They also have gelato for after!
Seriously tasty, my a new go to! Love it! Staff was great, too!
Definitely worth a stop!

James Aversion

Please tell me how this is edible, litterly looks like a lunchable pizza . I spent 43$ on my order for my drink to arrived spilled all over my icecream and pizzas and for the pizza to look like it’s been sitting out for days . And cold as a rock . I want my money back

Steve \u0026 Melissa McAdams

Great Pie and people

Joel Sterling

This was my first time. The food was amazing, especially since you are the creator. Service was outstanding. The atmosphere is relaxed. Overall, it was a great experience. I will be back for more!

Khushbu Patel

I love your pizza place 😋 😍

Anthony Carter

We like to see those employees Happy because it is a direct reflection of Leadership! My girlfriend and I came here our first time and it was packed.
We both got Personal Pizzas and went through without any issues. I’m leaving this review because I love pizza and beer and the overall experience was 10/10

E Rivera

Food was disappointing. The pasta was all marinara and barely any of the cheeses I ordered with it. Flavorless. I don’t recall it being this bad.

sierrq godoy

Wouldn’t get the gluten free pizza ever

Daniel Shorstein

Tasty pizza! The gelato was a little melted but not too bad. They forgot the hot honey on our pizzas and said they don’t really have a good system to remember to put them on, so it would be nice if they came up with a better way to remember which pizzas get hot honey afterward the oven. Other than that it was a good experience.

John Ruddy

Was ok, it's what u get for a fast local pizza.

Bradley S

Helpful and nice staff

Angel Distro

There are 3 young kids treat us really well.... took really good care and mad best pizza...

Loading...