Andy’s was great, but out of nowhere they up and closed. They moved to another location over 45 minutes away so just like that we’re done. It would have been nice if they were loyal to their fans by telling us they were closing and moving but they didn’t.
Les Callahan
Pretty damn good custard
TayBrew
Delicious triple chocolate concretable! Drive through is atrociously slow!
Catherine Mary Tijerina
Definitely will go again.
Jesse Shimondle
So good must try
Heather S
This my family and I's favorite stop for a sweet treat. Great customer service, can see the staff hard at work. Thank you!
Chuck Sparks
Drove by Saturday 10/4/25 and it's CLOSED. Looks PERMANENTLY CLOSED.
Bought frozen ice cream across the street and saved $ 5.00.
Shannon Vandehey
Custard is amazing every time I visit. I think all workers handling a cone should wear gloves. I lost my desire to eat mine this time due to that.
Beach Chica
Way overpriced, like ridiculously overpriced. Dessert was good, but I have had better for a lower cost.
Erika Cordill
Yum!! If you love Key Lime you have to get their Key Lime Concrete 🤩
I visit FL every year for 2 weeks and coming to Andy’s is a tradition. The custard is always amazing and I love the variety on the menu. I went yesterday and Gracie helped me. She was very nice! I was surprised to see she had a tip cup at the drive thru because every other time I’ve been there, I was always told that they were not allowed to accept tips. If tipping is allowed now, please add the option when paying with cards. That’s the only reason I’m giving 3 stars because I didn’t have any cash and I would love to have left her a tip along with the others who did.
Jacky Llerena
5 stars for custardy goodness. 2 stars for the intrusion of cars on outdoor seating.
This is such a quirky establishment with its 90s vibe front patio area for outdoor seating. I so enjoyed the Choco Espresso Shake (substituted vanilla for chocolate custard). It was so creamy I almost melted alongside it. The only downside is the drive-thru that has cars literally pass a couple feet from you. It doesn't bode well in terms of exhaust, heat, and noise. I found it funny they used bike parking posts as a safety precaution for the pedestrian crossing. But hey, they have bike parking!
sydney cyrus
Ice cream was good, but I had a bad interaction with the cashier. I wanted to know if they had a peanut butter pint and they ignored me the first time, then went I asked again thinking maybe they didn’t hear me they were very rude. I said I had a $5 reward and tried to hand my Andy’s card but they told me “You should have told me earlier, I already ran the payment”. I probably won’t be coming back to this location for a while
Andy’s was great, but out of nowhere they up and closed. They moved to another location over 45 minutes away so just like that we’re done. It would have been nice if they were loyal to their fans by telling us they were closing and moving but they didn’t.
Pretty damn good custard
Delicious triple chocolate concretable! Drive through is atrociously slow!
Definitely will go again.
So good must try
This my family and I's favorite stop for a sweet treat. Great customer service, can see the staff hard at work. Thank you!
Drove by Saturday 10/4/25 and it's CLOSED. Looks PERMANENTLY CLOSED.
Bought frozen ice cream across the street and saved $ 5.00.
Custard is amazing every time I visit. I think all workers handling a cone should wear gloves. I lost my desire to eat mine this time due to that.
Way overpriced, like ridiculously overpriced. Dessert was good, but I have had better for a lower cost.
Yum!! If you love Key Lime you have to get their Key Lime Concrete 🤩
Restaurantji Recommends
Great treat
I visit FL every year for 2 weeks and coming to Andy’s is a tradition. The custard is always amazing and I love the variety on the menu. I went yesterday and Gracie helped me. She was very nice! I was surprised to see she had a tip cup at the drive thru because every other time I’ve been there, I was always told that they were not allowed to accept tips. If tipping is allowed now, please add the option when paying with cards. That’s the only reason I’m giving 3 stars because I didn’t have any cash and I would love to have left her a tip along with the others who did.
5 stars for custardy goodness. 2 stars for the intrusion of cars on outdoor seating.
This is such a quirky establishment with its 90s vibe front patio area for outdoor seating. I so enjoyed the Choco Espresso Shake (substituted vanilla for chocolate custard). It was so creamy I almost melted alongside it. The only downside is the drive-thru that has cars literally pass a couple feet from you. It doesn't bode well in terms of exhaust, heat, and noise. I found it funny they used bike parking posts as a safety precaution for the pedestrian crossing. But hey, they have bike parking!
Ice cream was good, but I had a bad interaction with the cashier. I wanted to know if they had a peanut butter pint and they ignored me the first time, then went I asked again thinking maybe they didn’t hear me they were very rude. I said I had a $5 reward and tried to hand my Andy’s card but they told me “You should have told me earlier, I already ran the payment”. I probably won’t be coming back to this location for a while
They make a great specialty mix.
Loading...