Excellent pizza and wings. Great service. It is counter service but the person that took our order was happy to make recommendations and answer questions. The food which was served in a timely manner was beautifully presented and cooked perfectly. We had the salt and sugar pizza, cheese pizza and spicy sweet chili wings. I recommend this spot!
Amanda A.
Pizzas are LARGE! A little overpriced in our opinion. We've ordered once but haven't again because of this. Quick and convenient though!
Kim Cohn
The staff was super nice and friendly. The pizza was great and Ilike how you can make it your own (however it was slightly greasy for me) and the cheese bread was also awesome. The atmosphere throughout the restaurant was AMAZING. I've never seen anything like it!
Vanessa S.
Great little location for pizza! Yum yum! The salt n sugar pizza was outstanding! I highly recommend this place! Oh don't forget to order the cheesy bread to add to your meal!
Tim Paradiso
And we get food from here all the time and it’s hands-down, the best pizza in the Sanford/Lake Mary area! Their pasta and chicken wings are also fantastic. Great family owned restaurant. I would highly recommend!I wish I had something negative to say just so I could get a funny response from the owner. Lol
ricky chin
We do our weekly pizza night here. Best pizza and burgers in the area with fresh higher quality/healthier ingredients. Always great customer service and friendly staff. Also, try some of their homemade tiramisu, crepes, and chocolate mousse. You wont be disappointed! Give this place a try if you havent already and you may be converted to regulars as well!
Brad P.
Really good pizza. Small place but cozy. I really enjoyed the experience and liked the pizza. I will definitely be back.
Amy S.
We've lived in the area for about a year and a half and I have wanted to try this restaurant because of the fabulous Yelp reviews I've read, but this place really let my husband and me down. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a Nutella crepe. The pizza was awful. It was extremely greasy and didn't taste fresh. The cheese was hard. We each ate one piece and the rest went in the trash. Unfortunately, we found ourselves cooking an hour or so later because our dinner was in no way filling. There's only ever been one other pizza I've had in my life that was worse than this pizza. I saw where the owner responded to someone else who left a review very similar to my experience with the pizza and left low stars as well. The owner responded that it was because the pizza was best eaten in the restaurant fresh from the oven. That seemed more like an excuse to me because I've been eating pizza for decades at home that has either been picked up or delivered from the restaurant and the pizzas have all been fine. I'd also just like to add before the owner chimes in that we were there when it was ready. So it wasn't sitting on top of the oven for 5+ minutes. The crepe was good. Not the best I've ever had, but good. Not good enough for me to return here just for a crepe and pay $5 for it. I can make one just as good at home and it doesn't cost $5. I really hate to dis local places and I was really wanting to love this restaurant But it is what it is. *shrug* EDITING to respond to owners comment for my above review: As I mentioned in the review, I suspected the owner was going to comment making an excuse and I was right. However, I didn't know he was going to call me a liar. He is the liar. He claims we picked up the pizza and crepe over an hour after we placed the order. No. That is a lie. We arrived 3 minutes after the order was placed - I have a time-stamped text message from my husband when he arrived at the restaurant and another time-stamped text from him when he left and was on the way home. I also have the time written in my logbook of when I took insulin less than 60 seconds from him walking in the door with the food. So if we go by the time the owner stated the the order was ready (I have no way to verify that), and considering we only live 5 minutes away, the pizza had just came out of the oven 8 minutes before it was in my home. Because I was excited about trying this restaurant, we immediately opened the box and we box immediately went, "ewwwww." They say you eat with your eyes first and this was one of the most unappetizing things I've seen. Also, since the owner is not only a liar, but also apparently cannot read, let me say this again: I NEVER SAID YOUR CREPE WAS BAD. I SAID IT WAS GOOD, BUT NOT THE BEST I'D EVER HAD. Since we're discussing the crepe though... it was warm and not soggy or whatever the owner mentioned. It was fine. I said IT WASN'T GOOD ENOUGH FOR ME TO RETURN AND PAY $5 FOR IT - especially since I'll never return for your pizza. Now I'm taking away the initial 2 stars and only leaving one star because I will never do business with someone who treats their customers this way. I didn't like your food. The end. You know what that means? DO BETTER. Do better every time for every customer. Because you had to be such an asinine j**** your review got worse. Also... did the owner call me fat by telling me I needed to eat a salad rather than pepperoni?? WTF was that all about? Way to fat shame your customer, buddy! And my husband and I are pretty sure we figured out the pizza deal.... The pizza had probably sat there for over an hour and the person who ordered it didn't come to pick it up, so since we were brand new customer he figured he could just pawn the shitty pizza off on us. You know dude, you screwed the pooch big time on this one and I hope you enjoy this lovely review that I've written just for you. I invite you to respond with another dumbass comment, but just know, I won't be replying ag
Nifertiry R.
The service is wonderful and the food is incredible. My family and I ordered a pizza chicken wings and a chicken sandwich. Everything was delious. Decided to take dessert home and the Terramisu was divine.
Samantha A.
If you are looking for the real definition of cooking with love this is the spot!! The food is delicious the pizza homemade sauce really good and the chicken sandwich best I've had with homemade fries!!! All in all family place really good food and the owner is awesome!!! Go check them out you wont be disappointed!!
Excellent! Stopped here while in town for a doctor's appointment and my son was craving pizza. Found this place on Yelp. Glad we did. The place is small but the food is great. The restaurant was very clean and had a cool industrial vibe. Ordered the Redneck Pizza for my son and I had the chicken burger (sandwich). Both did not disappoint. Very fresh and top quality ingredients. The staff is very friendly and inviting. This place hit the spot.
R G.
We ordered 4 fabulous pizzas to go. Not only were they delicious, they were delivered in time without any snags. We highly recommend this restaurant!!
Mayra D. Lopez-Duprey
One of the best pizzas I’ve had so far!! I recommend this place. Can’t wait to try more items in their menu.
Barton Hill
My family visited Tiger Loves Pizza for the first time this evening. My wife actually found it on Next Door. We drove 30 min to eat there, so we were hoping it would be great. IT DID NOT DISSAPPOINT. We were greeted by the friendly owner and he asked us if we had been there before. We said no and he explained that they also had pasta available, that wasn't on the menu. We decided to go with the pizza, eventhough the burgers looked amazing. While my wife was in the bathroom with our kiddos, I stood waiting for them. The owner offered for me to sit at one of the tables and gave me a nice big glass bottle of water while I waited. While my wife was in the bathroom, our daughter lost her tooth! Julian was so nice and told her about the little mouse that comes when you lose a tooth. He said next time we came, to ask for him and he would give her the present. He was so nice and great with our curious little girls. Let's talk about the pizza!! It did not disappoint! It was super flavorful and the cheese was super cheesy and so fresh. The crust was nice and crisp, and complemented perfectly by the delicious tomato sauce. The atmosphere of the restaurant was awesome!!!All in all, this is a great place that is family friendly, with great pizza. We will definitely be back. Thanks guys!
Sterling Abell
Absolutely perfect last minute decision. Google said they closed at 9 pm and it was 8:57 when I called and the owner was just as nice as could be and told me no problem about coming after 9. I asked for extra pepperoni and extra cheese and light sauce and he nailed. Hands down wonderful pizza highly recommended!!!
Excellent pizza and wings. Great service. It is counter service but the person that took our order was happy to make recommendations and answer questions. The food which was served in a timely manner was beautifully presented and cooked perfectly. We had the salt and sugar pizza, cheese pizza and spicy sweet chili wings. I recommend this spot!
Pizzas are LARGE! A little overpriced in our opinion. We've ordered once but haven't again because of this. Quick and convenient though!
The staff was super nice and friendly. The pizza was great and Ilike how you can make it your own (however it was slightly greasy for me) and the cheese bread was also awesome. The atmosphere throughout the restaurant was AMAZING. I've never seen anything like it!
Great little location for pizza! Yum yum! The salt n sugar pizza was outstanding! I highly recommend this place! Oh don't forget to order the cheesy bread to add to your meal!
And we get food from here all the time and it’s hands-down, the best pizza in the Sanford/Lake Mary area! Their pasta and chicken wings are also fantastic. Great family owned restaurant. I would highly recommend!I wish I had something negative to say just so I could get a funny response from the owner. Lol
We do our weekly pizza night here. Best pizza and burgers in the area with fresh higher quality/healthier ingredients. Always great customer service and friendly staff. Also, try some of their homemade tiramisu, crepes, and chocolate mousse. You wont be disappointed! Give this place a try if you havent already and you may be converted to regulars as well!
Really good pizza. Small place but cozy. I really enjoyed the experience and liked the pizza. I will definitely be back.
We've lived in the area for about a year and a half and I have wanted to try this restaurant because of the fabulous Yelp reviews I've read, but this place really let my husband and me down. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a Nutella crepe. The pizza was awful. It was extremely greasy and didn't taste fresh. The cheese was hard. We each ate one piece and the rest went in the trash. Unfortunately, we found ourselves cooking an hour or so later because our dinner was in no way filling. There's only ever been one other pizza I've had in my life that was worse than this pizza. I saw where the owner responded to someone else who left a review very similar to my experience with the pizza and left low stars as well. The owner responded that it was because the pizza was best eaten in the restaurant fresh from the oven. That seemed more like an excuse to me because I've been eating pizza for decades at home that has either been picked up or delivered from the restaurant and the pizzas have all been fine. I'd also just like to add before the owner chimes in that we were there when it was ready. So it wasn't sitting on top of the oven for 5+ minutes. The crepe was good. Not the best I've ever had, but good. Not good enough for me to return here just for a crepe and pay $5 for it. I can make one just as good at home and it doesn't cost $5. I really hate to dis local places and I was really wanting to love this restaurant But it is what it is. *shrug* EDITING to respond to owners comment for my above review: As I mentioned in the review, I suspected the owner was going to comment making an excuse and I was right. However, I didn't know he was going to call me a liar. He is the liar. He claims we picked up the pizza and crepe over an hour after we placed the order. No. That is a lie. We arrived 3 minutes after the order was placed - I have a time-stamped text message from my husband when he arrived at the restaurant and another time-stamped text from him when he left and was on the way home. I also have the time written in my logbook of when I took insulin less than 60 seconds from him walking in the door with the food. So if we go by the time the owner stated the the order was ready (I have no way to verify that), and considering we only live 5 minutes away, the pizza had just came out of the oven 8 minutes before it was in my home. Because I was excited about trying this restaurant, we immediately opened the box and we box immediately went, "ewwwww." They say you eat with your eyes first and this was one of the most unappetizing things I've seen. Also, since the owner is not only a liar, but also apparently cannot read, let me say this again: I NEVER SAID YOUR CREPE WAS BAD. I SAID IT WAS GOOD, BUT NOT THE BEST I'D EVER HAD. Since we're discussing the crepe though... it was warm and not soggy or whatever the owner mentioned. It was fine. I said IT WASN'T GOOD ENOUGH FOR ME TO RETURN AND PAY $5 FOR IT - especially since I'll never return for your pizza. Now I'm taking away the initial 2 stars and only leaving one star because I will never do business with someone who treats their customers this way. I didn't like your food. The end. You know what that means? DO BETTER. Do better every time for every customer. Because you had to be such an asinine j**** your review got worse. Also... did the owner call me fat by telling me I needed to eat a salad rather than pepperoni?? WTF was that all about? Way to fat shame your customer, buddy! And my husband and I are pretty sure we figured out the pizza deal.... The pizza had probably sat there for over an hour and the person who ordered it didn't come to pick it up, so since we were brand new customer he figured he could just pawn the shitty pizza off on us. You know dude, you screwed the pooch big time on this one and I hope you enjoy this lovely review that I've written just for you. I invite you to respond with another dumbass comment, but just know, I won't be replying ag
The service is wonderful and the food is incredible. My family and I ordered a pizza chicken wings and a chicken sandwich. Everything was delious. Decided to take dessert home and the Terramisu was divine.
If you are looking for the real definition of cooking with love this is the spot!! The food is delicious the pizza homemade sauce really good and the chicken sandwich best I've had with homemade fries!!! All in all family place really good food and the owner is awesome!!! Go check them out you wont be disappointed!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent! Stopped here while in town for a doctor's appointment and my son was craving pizza. Found this place on Yelp. Glad we did. The place is small but the food is great. The restaurant was very clean and had a cool industrial vibe. Ordered the Redneck Pizza for my son and I had the chicken burger (sandwich). Both did not disappoint. Very fresh and top quality ingredients. The staff is very friendly and inviting. This place hit the spot.
We ordered 4 fabulous pizzas to go. Not only were they delicious, they were delivered in time without any snags. We highly recommend this restaurant!!
One of the best pizzas I’ve had so far!! I recommend this place. Can’t wait to try more items in their menu.
My family visited Tiger Loves Pizza for the first time this evening. My wife actually found it on Next Door. We drove 30 min to eat there, so we were hoping it would be great. IT DID NOT DISSAPPOINT. We were greeted by the friendly owner and he asked us if we had been there before. We said no and he explained that they also had pasta available, that wasn't on the menu. We decided to go with the pizza, eventhough the burgers looked amazing. While my wife was in the bathroom with our kiddos, I stood waiting for them. The owner offered for me to sit at one of the tables and gave me a nice big glass bottle of water while I waited. While my wife was in the bathroom, our daughter lost her tooth! Julian was so nice and told her about the little mouse that comes when you lose a tooth. He said next time we came, to ask for him and he would give her the present. He was so nice and great with our curious little girls. Let's talk about the pizza!! It did not disappoint! It was super flavorful and the cheese was super cheesy and so fresh. The crust was nice and crisp, and complemented perfectly by the delicious tomato sauce. The atmosphere of the restaurant was awesome!!!All in all, this is a great place that is family friendly, with great pizza. We will definitely be back. Thanks guys!
Absolutely perfect last minute decision. Google said they closed at 9 pm and it was 8:57 when I called and the owner was just as nice as could be and told me no problem about coming after 9. I asked for extra pepperoni and extra cheese and light sauce and he nailed. Hands down wonderful pizza highly recommended!!!