Compared to other ice cream shops in Sanibel, Love Boat is reasonably priced and you get a lot of ice cream. The small is like a large anywhere else and the flavors are creative, fun, and delicious! 🍨
Logan Dunn
We’ve tried every ice cream shop on the island this trip and this is now the best ice cream on the island BY FAR. Delicious and interesting flavors. You have to sample oatmeal cream pie, coconut almond fudge, and banana cream pie
Lee Yeaton
Lots of flavors to choose from, the shakes are my favorite. Seating inside and out. Always a good spot for some ice cream.
David Burnham
Great ice cream, good service, reasonable price
Jake Barr
Simply the best ice cream on the island. We went there 3 times a week for a month!!
Sharat Chandra
One of the best Ice cream we had in recent times in Florida. The cheesecake flavors are the best.
Shane Tucker
My wife prefers The Shack for custard but this is my fav ice cream stop in Sanibel. There is a huge selection and the give huge portions.
Bruno Monaco
Delicious ice cream, very well made, impossible to try just one, you have to add all 6 flavors and remember what was ordered, service was good, full of tourists and sometimes there are seasonal flavors, so it's worth visiting more than one turn
terri betts
I love this shop and always stop here when on Sanibel but they are all closed up right now.
Paul
Had their Salty Jack ice cream at the Sanibel Island location in 2021. All there flavors are great. But hooked on Salty Jack. Hoping the store is reopened after hurricane Ian. Google shows store is temporarily closed.
Long line out the door. Not worth the wait IMO. There’s a great little ice cream shop right across McGregor Blvd. 36 flavors. No line. Good ice cream. Go there instead
Joe Watson (Joe Cool)
WOW!!! Amazing ? I read reviews of this place and many others, and decided that this was the place to try. I am sooo glad that I did. The ice cream was spectacular ?. It was in a shopping plaza on Sanibel Island ? and it was constantly busy. We thoroughly enjoyed the taste and experience. Wonderful dessert ?, you will NOT be disappointed. It was a little pricey, until we saw the amount that they dished out for us. We highly recommend ?
N9273VAlindas
You would think it is kind of pricy until you see the size of the scoops and try the flavors. great place to go.
Kevin Courtney
Really good ice cream, large portions.
NJItalian
Portions were huge! A small was large to us! Prices were great too. Loved the Elvis flavor as well as pistachio. Will go back.
Compared to other ice cream shops in Sanibel, Love Boat is reasonably priced and you get a lot of ice cream. The small is like a large anywhere else and the flavors are creative, fun, and delicious! 🍨
We’ve tried every ice cream shop on the island this trip and this is now the best ice cream on the island BY FAR. Delicious and interesting flavors. You have to sample oatmeal cream pie, coconut almond fudge, and banana cream pie
Lots of flavors to choose from, the shakes are my favorite. Seating inside and out. Always a good spot for some ice cream.
Great ice cream, good service, reasonable price
Simply the best ice cream on the island. We went there 3 times a week for a month!!
One of the best Ice cream we had in recent times in Florida. The cheesecake flavors are the best.
My wife prefers The Shack for custard but this is my fav ice cream stop in Sanibel. There is a huge selection and the give huge portions.
Delicious ice cream, very well made, impossible to try just one, you have to add all 6 flavors and remember what was ordered, service was good, full of tourists and sometimes there are seasonal flavors, so it's worth visiting more than one turn
I love this shop and always stop here when on Sanibel but they are all closed up right now.
Had their Salty Jack ice cream at the Sanibel Island location in 2021. All there flavors are great. But hooked on Salty Jack. Hoping the store is reopened after hurricane Ian. Google shows store is temporarily closed.
Restaurantji Recommends
Long line out the door. Not worth the wait IMO. There’s a great little ice cream shop right across McGregor Blvd. 36 flavors. No line. Good ice cream. Go there instead
WOW!!! Amazing ? I read reviews of this place and many others, and decided that this was the place to try. I am sooo glad that I did. The ice cream was spectacular ?. It was in a shopping plaza on Sanibel Island ? and it was constantly busy. We thoroughly enjoyed the taste and experience. Wonderful dessert ?, you will NOT be disappointed. It was a little pricey, until we saw the amount that they dished out for us. We highly recommend ?
You would think it is kind of pricy until you see the size of the scoops and try the flavors. great place to go.
Really good ice cream, large portions.
Portions were huge! A small was large to us! Prices were great too. Loved the Elvis flavor as well as pistachio. Will go back.
Loading...