Amazing Pizza and staff at Grace Pizza. - Supreme Grace is our favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Grace
Bradley Comstock
My family loves Grace Pizza and Shakes. The pizza is delicious, try the pepperoni or supreme, so good! Burrata salad is amazing, and the shakes are literally over the top. Service is really stellar, everything about this place is great!
Everything had good flavor. The margherita pizza was tasty but was soggy. My kids enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. They ran out of ice cream so they weren’t able to make the shakes. We were there during spring break so I understand the challenges.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza
KC M
Fabulous pizza & a quaint restaurant to dine in.Parking: Parking lot is small and spaces are difficult to maneuver, unless you have a small car.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
rboltin1
Had high hopes for this place, but ultimately was disappointed. The best part of the meal was the Grace-roni rolls, which is dough stuffed with pepperoni, mozzarella, ranch, marina, you get the idea. After that it was downhill. The whipped ricotta appetizer was dry, grainy and murdered with red pepper. The Wagyu meatballs were rubbery and tasted like there was a ton of filler in them. Asked for a milkshake menu after we ordered appetizers, but the server never brought it out. As an entree, we ordered the Supreme Grace to share, which has a bit of everything on it. Wanted to love this pizza, but the flavors all just sort of tasted like the same thing. After struggling through half a slice, I realized that the Ranch dressing spiral was probably the culprit. After dinner the server brought the check, and I reminded him about the milkshake menu. He was like “oh yeeaahh. I’ll go grab those”, but seemed a bit sheepish. Came back a few minutes later to let us that he was just informed by the kitchen that they were out of ice cream, and the delivery wouldn’t come in til tomorrow. Now this is 5:30pm mind you, not 9 o’clock at closing. And SHAKES is on the freakin’ sign! Send someone to the GD corner market to get through the shift for christsake! It’s almost as if they they knew all along that they didn’t have ice cream, but waited until everyone on the patio was finished eating to announce it. I politely suggested to the server that they give each table that had already finished dinner some sort of voucher for just ONE complimentary shake for the next day as a customer service gesture, but that advice fell upon deaf ears. Well Grace, here’s the truth. Your food is just so-so, your guest service is terrible, and your $22 shakes?… we’ll never know.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
PCBfisher (PCBfisher)
I’ll start off by saying that the food was really good. The service tonight desperately needed attention. Got seated right away. Waited 20 mins before anybody took our drink order and I had to flag him down. It wasn’t very busy with some empty tables inside.Ordered our food and 15mins later was told that the sandwich I wanted wasn’t available. That’s ok I ordered a different one. Our 2 pizzas showed up in a reasonable amount of time. No one ever came back to check on us or refill our drinks the whole time we were there (1hr 20mins).Pizzas were great but we pretty much finished them and the sandwich never showed up. I told the server that I no longer wanted it and he was apologetic and said he’d give us a discount for waiting and the inconvenience which was nice. When we got the check the sandwich was still on the ticket. He removed it and gave us a free cheese bread.Will be back but I sure hope they have their act together next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Stephanie Strube
Prepare to be wowed by Grace Pizza & Shakes! Their pies are delicious and their milkshakes will make your taste buds dance with joy. We just had an incredible experience that we won't soon forget.
So delicious! Amazing garden salad, pizza and super fun milkshake. So fun!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rita Hammonds
Price was a bit absurd. The margarita pizza was very skimpy for the price. Minimal ingredients. The cheese steak sub also had minimal meat. Will not be back. A range of $10 to $22 for a milk shake is a little over the top.Not a good value. Will not be back. They must depend on one time tourist traffic! 1 pizza, 1 sub and 3 plain milkshakes $78 before tip.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Wendy Hartman
If we could give this a higher rating, we would! Cute little restaurant! Not in a busy area? but near Grayton Beach. We found itDelicious pizza!! Exactly what we were looking for! Server was good too! Loved the pictures on the wall and the saying! We’ll come back!! We took an extra pizza home!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grace Supreme Pizza
Kelli H.
We picked up our order, it wasn't good. Our last visit we ate in the restaurant and not was wonderful. When you get milkshakes to go, they are less than 1/2 the size of the milkshakes they serve in the store but still cost $17-$20. They were good milkshakes but no cookies, nothing special about them at all.
Amanda A
I am a local and have been a regular. I know they are busy but the wait on a Wednesday night for to go was crazy over an hour. Which I understand sometimes there is a wait but the staff member was very rude to me at arrival. Very disappointed. I understand we all have bad days but there’s no reason to be rude to your customers. I normally like the food but if this continues I will not be back.
Amazing Pizza and staff at Grace Pizza. - Supreme Grace is our favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Grace
My family loves Grace Pizza and Shakes. The pizza is delicious, try the pepperoni or supreme, so good! Burrata salad is amazing, and the shakes are literally over the top. Service is really stellar, everything about this place is great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Supreme Grace
Everything had good flavor. The margherita pizza was tasty but was soggy. My kids enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. They ran out of ice cream so they weren’t able to make the shakes. We were there during spring break so I understand the challenges.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza
Fabulous pizza & a quaint restaurant to dine in.Parking: Parking lot is small and spaces are difficult to maneuver, unless you have a small car.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Had high hopes for this place, but ultimately was disappointed. The best part of the meal was the Grace-roni rolls, which is dough stuffed with pepperoni, mozzarella, ranch, marina, you get the idea. After that it was downhill. The whipped ricotta appetizer was dry, grainy and murdered with red pepper. The Wagyu meatballs were rubbery and tasted like there was a ton of filler in them. Asked for a milkshake menu after we ordered appetizers, but the server never brought it out. As an entree, we ordered the Supreme Grace to share, which has a bit of everything on it. Wanted to love this pizza, but the flavors all just sort of tasted like the same thing. After struggling through half a slice, I realized that the Ranch dressing spiral was probably the culprit. After dinner the server brought the check, and I reminded him about the milkshake menu. He was like “oh yeeaahh. I’ll go grab those”, but seemed a bit sheepish. Came back a few minutes later to let us that he was just informed by the kitchen that they were out of ice cream, and the delivery wouldn’t come in til tomorrow. Now this is 5:30pm mind you, not 9 o’clock at closing. And SHAKES is on the freakin’ sign! Send someone to the GD corner market to get through the shift for christsake! It’s almost as if they they knew all along that they didn’t have ice cream, but waited until everyone on the patio was finished eating to announce it. I politely suggested to the server that they give each table that had already finished dinner some sort of voucher for just ONE complimentary shake for the next day as a customer service gesture, but that advice fell upon deaf ears. Well Grace, here’s the truth. Your food is just so-so, your guest service is terrible, and your $22 shakes?… we’ll never know.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
I’ll start off by saying that the food was really good. The service tonight desperately needed attention. Got seated right away. Waited 20 mins before anybody took our drink order and I had to flag him down. It wasn’t very busy with some empty tables inside.Ordered our food and 15mins later was told that the sandwich I wanted wasn’t available. That’s ok I ordered a different one. Our 2 pizzas showed up in a reasonable amount of time. No one ever came back to check on us or refill our drinks the whole time we were there (1hr 20mins).Pizzas were great but we pretty much finished them and the sandwich never showed up. I told the server that I no longer wanted it and he was apologetic and said he’d give us a discount for waiting and the inconvenience which was nice. When we got the check the sandwich was still on the ticket. He removed it and gave us a free cheese bread.Will be back but I sure hope they have their act together next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Prepare to be wowed by Grace Pizza & Shakes! Their pies are delicious and their milkshakes will make your taste buds dance with joy. We just had an incredible experience that we won't soon forget.
So good!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Dip, VJ's Oreo Overload, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grace Supreme Pizza
Very tasty pizza, good wine & service + excellent entertainment!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grace Supreme Pizza
Was looking forward to a new pizza place but I was very disappointed! The pizza had very little taste . ?
Food: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
So delicious! Amazing garden salad, pizza and super fun milkshake. So fun!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Price was a bit absurd. The margarita pizza was very skimpy for the price. Minimal ingredients. The cheese steak sub also had minimal meat. Will not be back. A range of $10 to $22 for a milk shake is a little over the top.Not a good value. Will not be back. They must depend on one time tourist traffic! 1 pizza, 1 sub and 3 plain milkshakes $78 before tip.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
If we could give this a higher rating, we would! Cute little restaurant! Not in a busy area? but near Grayton Beach. We found itDelicious pizza!! Exactly what we were looking for! Server was good too! Loved the pictures on the wall and the saying! We’ll come back!! We took an extra pizza home!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grace Supreme Pizza
We picked up our order, it wasn't good. Our last visit we ate in the restaurant and not was wonderful. When you get milkshakes to go, they are less than 1/2 the size of the milkshakes they serve in the store but still cost $17-$20. They were good milkshakes but no cookies, nothing special about them at all.
I am a local and have been a regular. I know they are busy but the wait on a Wednesday night for to go was crazy over an hour. Which I understand sometimes there is a wait but the staff member was very rude to me at arrival. Very disappointed. I understand we all have bad days but there’s no reason to be rude to your customers. I normally like the food but if this continues I will not be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2