Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub

The philly is amazing, worth to stop by when cruising 30A!

What a bad night. Bar service terrible. Waited forever for our first drink. Then we couldn't get the bartender for an hour for a second. We just walk out. He never gave us a bill , a waived him 10 times and he wouldn't come.... won't be back. Locals hare...

I ordered the marinated grilled chicken sandwich to go. The piece of chicken was so much smaller than the bun. Onion rings weren’t crispy at all. Service to pick up was eh. Also the chicken was super chewy 😞 I’m a local and wanted to try it out. Wasn’t worth 20$ that’s for sure.

True local place among its pricey neibors. Reubin sandwich is excellent. Large selection of beers on tap. Friendly staff

This place was a horrible experience for our family. Staff was completely rude and overwhelmed. There was only one person working the restaurant, we got drinks that were about 6oz and were completely filled with ice, no refills. Over paying prices. Worker was miscommunicated. We had to wait about 45 minutes for our order. Trying to get are check it took about 20-30minutes, plus waiting at the bar.

This was a terrible experience for me and my family. It took extremely long to get our check, waited FOREVER! Pizza tasted like cardboard… the drinks were tiny. Waitress was mean to us and tried to get us to pay for things that we had took off our order. So expensive for food that tasted like it was freezer pizza. Do not recommend this place if your in the area.

We got the philly, Reuben, and kids grilled cheese for carry out. They were delicious! Staff was super nice.

Tatianna the bartender is a really cool person and a joy to talk to. She really makes this place special

The waitress/bartender was terribly rude for no reason. Waited on people at the bar fine. Then never came back to see if we needed anything. Once as she passed I asked for a drink and she sat it on the counter like I was supposed to know it was mine, get up, and get it myself. I guess I was supposed to get my daughter a refill behind the counter as well?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Great fish n chips. Bartender on Xmas eve was very good she was cheery and busy. Buddy had corn beef n cabbage.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Corned Beef and Cabbage, Fish and Chips

Blacked blue cheese burger was fantastic with tater tots
Philly cheese steak awesome too!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

The French dip was absolutely delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Been coming here for 5+ years. Easily my favorite dive bar in town. Seen several changes in staff and always been treated above expectations. Between Sarah, Nate and numerous previous bartenders they’ve always taken excellent care of me which I appreciate as a local and regular. Food is always superb coming later at night to eat after working. Mid 20’s and getting ID’d by new bartenders is great I love to see new staff doing a diligent and thorough job! I believe Lessie, anna, and Frankie are new and provide excellent service. So happy to see my favorite spot staying consistent despite new faces and nothing more I could ask for. Will be back many times over!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am a local and this is the third time I’ve visited and the same bartender was rude. There are not many activities or venues to take our children on a rainy day, so we chose McTighes to have lunch and play arcade games. The manager did come out and apologize for the bartenders behavior and told us she was not feeling well, but this is not the first time and others patrons I know have expressed their experience with her being unfriendly as well. We did not stay for lunch due to the employees behavior and will only dine again when she is not working. I will not be treated unfairly in an establishment where I’m spending my hard earned income.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Honestly extremely disappointed because this was my favorite dive bar in area. I’m a local in Blue Mountain beach and was treated very rudely by lexi (one of the bartenders). I was charged for two of the wrong drinks and she was very unhelpful when I just wanted to reorder a different drink. I spoke to the manager and although he said he would cover the two drinks due to her poor service and knowledge of the drink menu, I was charged $30 for two shots. I don’t like leaving negative reviews, especially for local businesses, but I felt that specific situation warranted a warning to any locals or tourists looking to experience some fun night life. Very disappointed and will not be coming back- STAY AWAY!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1