Big Olaf Creamery, Sarasota: Delicious Ice Cream, Best for Takeaway! Big Olaf Creamery in Sarasota is a popular spot, and for good reason: the ice cream was great! They offer a fantastic selection of flavors, and each scoop was rich, creamy, and exactly what you crave from a classic ice cream parlor.
However, there are a few things to keep in mind for your visit. It can get a little crowded, especially during peak times, and the seating area is quite restricted. If you're looking for a leisurely sit-down experience, you might find it a bit tight. Also, be prepared that they only take cash, so make sure you have some on hand before you go.
Despite these minor points, if you want your ice cream to go, this is definitely the place! The quality of the ice cream makes any small inconvenience worth it. Grab your favorite flavor (or two!), enjoy a stroll, and savor a truly delicious treat from Big Olaf Creamery. We'll certainly be back for more scoops to go!
Andre Tel
CASH ONLY, ATM available inside. The place needs a major remodel to bring it back from the 70s. But my issue is not the vibe but the ice-cream itself. I dont think they have a big turnaround despite selling some of the best ice-cream.
Wub App
Ice portions and prices much too big.
Alyse Gowgiel
Dairy free options! Chocolate mousse and strawberry. One was so good that I went back the next day to try the other. š
A. M.
The ice cream was delicious and the owner was so incredibly sweet and funny. We loved meeting him and will definitely be back the next time we're in the area.
Danita Brunk
Great ice cream. Be prepared to pay a bit more than normal. But they make their own waffle cones so that's a plus
Dan MacKinnon
Any place that serves yoders ice cream is awesome! Great location and nice staff
Emily Garland
The owner served us, he is super sweet and helpful! The Ice cream is homemade and very good! It is cash only but they have an atm inside. Much rather support a local family business than the chain restaurants!
Lori Ulloa
Quality ice cream and great service! Great local creamery!
Frank Del
Best ice cream on the circle. A little off the beaten path but worth the walk. It's behind the bank parking at the west end of the circle towards Lido... Bring cash cause that's all they accept... š§ On site.
Iāve been coming here for decades. Best ice cream and service on the circle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Lois āBB travelsā McDonald
Our family of 8 was thrilled with the excellent service! Happy to find an ice cream shop on St. Armandās circle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Consumer Review
Absolutely the creamiest ice cream I have had in a long time and I am not a huge ice cream lover! Cookie Monster and White Chocolate raspberry were delicious. Both my kids got it and no one shared :( Definitely a place to visit here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bennett Freeman
As we drove onto St Armands Key tonight, the damage left by Hurricane MIlton was apparent. We were immediately concerned about one of our regular go-to spots - Big Olaf Creamery. Happily, the lights were on and BOC is open for business! Per usual, the ice cream is great, service is fast and friendly, and the pricing surprisingly reasonable. Ice cream usually lifts one's spirits, but never more than tonight after viewing so many businesses left dark.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine Ramsing
Cute old fashioned ice cream shop. Same owners for over 40 years. Great ice cream and a good price. And I always like to support smaller businesses!
Big Olaf Creamery, Sarasota: Delicious Ice Cream, Best for Takeaway!
Big Olaf Creamery in Sarasota is a popular spot, and for good reason: the ice cream was great! They offer a fantastic selection of flavors, and each scoop was rich, creamy, and exactly what you crave from a classic ice cream parlor.
However, there are a few things to keep in mind for your visit. It can get a little crowded, especially during peak times, and the seating area is quite restricted. If you're looking for a leisurely sit-down experience, you might find it a bit tight. Also, be prepared that they only take cash, so make sure you have some on hand before you go.
Despite these minor points, if you want your ice cream to go, this is definitely the place! The quality of the ice cream makes any small inconvenience worth it. Grab your favorite flavor (or two!), enjoy a stroll, and savor a truly delicious treat from Big Olaf Creamery. We'll certainly be back for more scoops to go!
CASH ONLY, ATM available inside. The place needs a major remodel to bring it back from the 70s. But my issue is not the vibe but the ice-cream itself. I dont think they have a big turnaround despite selling some of the best ice-cream.
Ice portions and prices much too big.
Dairy free options! Chocolate mousse and strawberry. One was so good that I went back the next day to try the other. š
The ice cream was delicious and the owner was so incredibly sweet and funny. We loved meeting him and will definitely be back the next time we're in the area.
Great ice cream. Be prepared to pay a bit more than normal. But they make their own waffle cones so that's a plus
Any place that serves yoders ice cream is awesome! Great location and nice staff
The owner served us, he is super sweet and helpful! The Ice cream is homemade and very good! It is cash only but they have an atm inside. Much rather support a local family business than the chain restaurants!
Quality ice cream and great service! Great local creamery!
Best ice cream on the circle. A little off the beaten path but worth the walk. It's behind the bank parking at the west end of the circle towards Lido... Bring cash cause that's all they accept... š§ On site.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Iāve been coming here for decades. Best ice cream and service on the circle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Our family of 8 was thrilled with the excellent service! Happy to find an ice cream shop on St. Armandās circle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Absolutely the creamiest ice cream I have had in a long time and I am not a huge ice cream lover! Cookie Monster and White Chocolate raspberry were delicious. Both my kids got it and no one shared :( Definitely a place to visit here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
As we drove onto St Armands Key tonight, the damage left by Hurricane MIlton was apparent. We were immediately concerned about one of our regular go-to spots - Big Olaf Creamery. Happily, the lights were on and BOC is open for business! Per usual, the ice cream is great, service is fast and friendly, and the pricing surprisingly reasonable. Ice cream usually lifts one's spirits, but never more than tonight after viewing so many businesses left dark.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cute old fashioned ice cream shop. Same owners for over 40 years. Great ice cream and a good price. And I always like to support smaller businesses!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...