Big Water Fish Market

6639 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota
(941) 554-8101

Recent Reviews

James Stanton

Excellent good and service. Not fancy fish market with tables but amazing fresh fish and cold beer. Highly recommend if you're in Siesta Key

Mark Sublette

Go now…Don’t wait! Can you tell I love this place. Grouper OG and grouper Reuben were amazing. Very generous fish slabs! See photos. Service was fabulous as well. This was my 3rd visit. All good.

Jeanne Salvaggio

Great meals in a casual setting near the beach. It was so good, we went back a few days later and bought fresh cod and shrimp to cook for ourselves. It was delicious!

Lauren Borovicka

Great little place, our server Bubbles was personable and helpful. Delicious food at fair prices. Delicious fries I snuck off my kid’s plate, I really enjoyed the cucumber and tomato side which was recommended from the friendly table next to us. Seating is cozy, and there is a 3% credit card fee so bring cash if that will bother you. All of us enjoyed our meals.

Caleb Oliver

Hogfish was tasty and Clam Chowder was legendary. Fresh and authentic. Gives off a "todays catch" vibe.

Steven Vaughn

What a COOL place!Signage is a bit hard to see from the road, and the exterior appears sketchy --- BUT the interior is eclectic, AND the food is delicious!!!!We had a great time and loved this place. It will be on the list of places we visit the next time we are in the area.

Becky M.

Enjoyed dinner at this small restaurant and fish market. Loved the scallops and crab cake sandwich. The hush puppies were excellent. Friendly service too!

Edward Klasky

Stopped in to order something to go and got the Grouper Oscar with crab and then their special Grouper Oscar with Lobster with a half pound of peel and eat shrimp. Two huge pieces of grouper cooked perfectly and loaded with crab and lobster. BOOM! people were eating at counters outside in the walkway. That is always a good sign. Shrimp were cooked in garlic and old bay seasoning and will look forward to those leftovers for happy hour tomorrow. Cheers and Thanks for a great meal.

Diane Gozza

Great food! Fabulous, friendly service. Tuna Poke is excellent. Grouper Oscar is fabulous. Great place. Highly recommend.

Mike Eddington

OMG! The grouper sandwich! And the crab cakes! Highly highly recommend! The staff was absolutely great as well

R Kain

Really good grilled grouper & $4 wine on half price wine night.Busy place but worth eating there or getting their carryout.

Ethan Capodicasa

This hidden gem is a must in Siesta! Had the Grouper Oscar, fried grouper bites, and the steam pot— so fresh and a great laid back atmosphere

Robert Y.

Had two mahi fish tacos. So fresh and tasty! In honor of my grandmother who was from Key Largo, had to finish up with a great Key Lime pie. ALMOST as good as gram's but still very satisfying. Nice friendly staff and very dog friendly to my Cavi. Can't go wrong here!

Doug M.

Great job everyone - focused and fresh- keep it coming! See you all next year!! All of them we had - File, Grouper, Hog - excellently prepared!!

Nicole Mosher

While visiting Florida, we caught some beautiful red snapper. We were directed to Big Water by our Captain and WOW!!! They cooked up our fish at a very reasonable price and it was so very delicious. We had it fried and blackened!

Load More