Caragiulo's Italian American

69 S Palm Ave, Sarasota
(941) 951-0866

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Wild Mushroom & Fontina with Truffle Garlic Aioli
Additional Side of Focaccia Bread
Spaghetti & Cedar Key Clams
Knife & Fork Shrimp Scampi
Eggplant Parmesan Al Forno
Spaghetti w Meatballs
Calamari Fritto Misto
Angel Hair Arrabiata
Spaghetti and Shrimp
Meatballs Al Forno

Menu

Featured items
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER
pan fried organic chicken breast with marinara + mozzarella + spaghetti
SIDE PASTA
CHEESE PIZZA
with sauce + mozzarella
LASAGNA al FORNO
bolognese + béchamel
'PIZZA MIA'
cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings
SIDE 2 MEATBALLS
SMALL CHOPPED 1989 SALAD
grilled organic chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
WEDDING SOUP
spinach stracciatella + pastina + small meatballs
CHICKEN PICATTA
artichoke + oyster mushroom + caper + lemon-butter + green pea risotto
SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS
our house-made meatballs
CHIARA'S TIRAMISU
lady fingers + espresso + frangelico + mascarpone + cocoa
PASOLINI
pennoni (large penne) + roasted chicken + crumbled sausage + gorgonzola cream + oven-dried tomatoes
DAVINCI
fennel sausage + mushroom + pepperoni
CALZONE
stuffed with ricotta + any 2 toppings
CHICKEN MARSALA
pan roasted organic chicken breast + roasted cippolini + wild mushroom gravy + roasted potatoes
MARGHERITA
san marzano tomatoes + basil + house-made mozzarella
3 - CANNOLI
crispy miniature pastries + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
SMALL CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + fried caper crumbs + Caesar dressing

APPETIZERS
AVOCADO BRUSCHETTA
heirloom tomatoes + burrata + herb salad + radish
FRIED CALAMARI
fried calamari only with Sicilian marinara & Sardinian aioli
ROMAN ARTICHOKES
crispy fried hearts + goat cheese fonduta + truffle-aioli
MEATBALLS AL FORNO
ricotta + san Marzano tomato + mozzarella
CAPRESE BOARD
House-made mozzarella + local tomato + basil + red onion + balsamico
VEGETARIANO BOARD
seasonal grilled vegetable + goat cheese + aged balsamic
CALAMARI FRITTO MISTO
calamari + gardiniera + condimenti
SALUMI e FORMAGGI BOARD
prosciutto di parma + soppresata + pistachio mortadella + giardiniera + parmigiana + gorgonzola dolce + fresh mozzarella + local honeycomb
CHICKEN LIVER PATE
shallot marmellata + balsamic + Tuscan toast
MUSSELS 'NDUJA
fennel sausage crumbles + scallions + n'duja broth + crostini

SOUPS / SALADS
SMALL CHOPPED 1989 SALAD
grilled organic chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
WEDDING SOUP
spinach stracciatella + pastina + small meatballs
SMALL SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
SMALL CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + fried caper crumbs + Caesar dressing
SMALL HOUSE SALAD
carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + cucumber + house vinaigrette
SMALL ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD
goat cheese fondue + orange + shallot vinaigrette + local lettuces + caramelized walnuts
LARGE CHOPPED 1989 SALAD
grilled organic chicken + salami + chickpeas bean + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + parmigiana + creamy dressing
LARGE CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD
romaine + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
SMALL TUSCAN KALE SALAD
whipped ricotta + toasted breadcrumbs + Spanish almonds + dried cherries + lemon-vinaigrette
LARGE SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD
romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + golden raisins + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
LARGE HOUSE SALAD
carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + house vinaigrette

DINNER PASTA
RAVIOLI CACIO E PEPE
spinach + tomato + pecorino romano + cracked pepper
LASAGNA al FORNO
bolognese + béchamel
PASOLINI
pennoni (large penne) + roasted chicken + crumbled sausage + gorgonzola cream + oven-dried tomatoes
SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS
our house-made meatballs
BEEF TORTELLONI a la VODKA
crispy pancetta + stracciatella mozzarella + vodka-tomato crema
PENNONI ROMANA
braised oxtail & portobello ragu + burrata
ANGEL HAIR ARRABIATA
shrimp + mussels + clams + white fish + calamari + stewed san marzano + arancia
SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE + MEATBALL
SPAGHETTI & CEDAR KEY CLAMS
white wine-garlic broth + botarga crumb + parsley + fresno chili
SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE
PASTA MIA
pick your pasta: add your favorite sauce

PIZZA
'PIZZA MIA'
cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings
CHEESE PIZZA
with sauce + mozzarella
MARGHERITA
san marzano tomatoes + basil + house-made mozzarella
FIVE LILY
sweet & red onions + crispy bacon + garlic + charred scallion + chive + smoked mozzarella
WILD MUSHROOM & FONTINA
with truffle garlic aioli
CALZONE
stuffed with ricotta + any 2 toppings
DAVINCI
fennel sausage + mushroom + pepperoni
PEAR & GORGONZOLA
caramelized onions + white balsamic-honey drizzle
AGRO DOLCE
grilled pineapple + capicola + jalapeno + mozzarella
BIANCA ROSSA
white pizza with roasted garlic ricotta + arugula
'JOE da GREEK'
calamata olives + baby spinach + feta + tomatoes
EGGPLANT PARMESAN PIZZA
crispy eggplant + ricotta + basil pesto + fresh mozzarella

ENTREES
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER
pan fried organic chicken breast with marinara + mozzarella + spaghetti
CHICKEN MARSALA
pan roasted organic chicken breast + roasted cippolini + wild mushroom gravy + roasted potatoes
EGGPLANT PARMESAN al FORNO
layered crispy eggplant + plum tomato + ricotta + mozzarella
CHICKEN PICATTA
artichoke + oyster mushroom + caper + lemon-butter + green pea risotto
FILETTO di MANZO
black angus beef tenderloin + bone marrow butter + port glaze + crispy brussels sprouts + truffle risotto
PORK TENDERLOIN MARSALA
cipollini + wild mushroom gravy crispy leeks + gorgonzola polenta
SEARED LOCAL GROUPER
roasted tomato confit + artichoke + spinach + caper butter + risotto cake

SIDES
SIDE PASTA
SIDE 2 MEATBALLS
CACCIO e PEPE FRIES
with cracked pepper + parmigiano + aioli
CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS
with spicey honey
ROASTED CAULIFLOWER
with calabrian aioli + spicy crumbs
CHARRED BROCCOLINI
with lemon + EVOO
SIDE 2 SAUSAGE LINKS
SIDE MIXED VEGETABLES
SIDE SAUTEED SPINACH
SIDE ANCHOVIES
TRUFFLE RISOTTO

DESSERTS
3 - CANNOLI
crispy miniature pastries + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
CHIARA'S TIRAMISU
lady fingers + espresso + frangelico + mascarpone + cocoa
SPUMONI SUNDAE
pistachio + vanilla + amarena cherry gelato + dark rum chocolate brownie + cream
ZEPPOLI & GELATO
crispy zeppoli fritters + espresso gelato + crema inglese
6 - CANNOLI

SOFT DRINKS
DR PEPPER
LEMONADE
DIET PEPSI
GINGERALE
PEPSI
CLUB SODA
RASPBERRY TEA
UNSWEETENED ICED TEA
CAPPUCINO
DECAF CAPPUCINO
SIERRA MIST
HOT TEA
COFFEE
ESPRESSO
DBL ESPRESSO
DECAF ESPRESSO
DBL CAPPUCINO

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
+77 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+76 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

On Sunday 7/28, we gave our name and the rest is history… we were greeted with “Happy 40th Anniversary “ from Petra and Julie and brought to our table. Our daughter, Ashley (who now lives in CT) had been in contact with Julie and surprised us with a bottle of Malbec and a fabulous Charcuterie board to start our delectable, celebratory dinner. My husband ordered his favorite, Chicken Parmesan with a side of rigatoni . It was delicious as usual and a side house side. The rigatoni...
August 2024
We have been going to Caragiulo’s for over 10+ years. Our favorite Italian restaurant. Nothing compares. We have celebrated birthdays, anniversary’s etc. here on many occasions as well. They have become like family to us! Food is excellent. Service is always top tier. Highly recommend.

Dietary restrictions: Always meet our dietary restrictions with no issues.
August 2024
Amazing food. The bread is so addicting! Had no complaints about the service or atmosphere.

Had no problems moving my girlfriend and I to another area of the resturant as we were seated next to an obnoxiously loud party of guests outside.

Thanks Caragiulo's team.
June 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Breaking Wave Coffee - 1310 Main St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
O & A Coffee and Supply Downtown Sarasota - 1316 Main St
Cafe, Coffee Roasteries
Kurtos Chimney Cake & Bread - 1312 Main St
Sandwich Shop, Bakery, Hungarian, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Pet Friendly

Caragiulo's Italian American

69 S Palm Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236
(941) 951-0866