Catering by Clayton

One of the best meals that I have had in a long time. The staff and atmosphere was amazing, the drinks were unique and the food (macadamia crusted grouper) was cooked to perfection.

From the moment we stepped in the door we could feel the vibe of this place. Delicious food and drinks, wonderful staff and great environment. It was elevated but not stuffy. Will return- highly recommend!

Original and creative menu with perfectly prepared food. I recommend the fresh catch special. So delicious, I went back the next night. Don't miss this wonderful restaurant. Great cocktails too!!!

as always, Claytons was outstanding. The drink list is fantastic and had the PJ Butter Pecan Martini which blew me away. Burger was delicious the plantains amazing. one of us had the Scallops and Gnocchi and we know why that is the number one dish at Claytons. So good. if you have not gone, get yourself a table, sit back and enjoy the drinks, food and friendship you will find there

Mavis the owner is extremely nice and accommodating....she is slowly introducing new menu items that are excellent. Fred, our server, is outstanding....probably the best on the Key.

This is my first time returning to Clayton's since their new ownership. I was delighted to see that their Macadamia Nut Grouper is as good as ever! My friend loved the salmon teriyaki and our server couldn't have been more attentive or more personable! So happy to see they're still the place to beat here!

Great place for a great dinner. Something for everyone. Wife loved the filet, friends said the same for the grouper sandwich and my Short Ribs were a home run! Our crab cake appetizer was excellent as well. Put Clayton's on your must go to list.

Such a great experience at this gem of a restaurant. The food was amazing, service was outstanding and drinks were tasty and strong! Or server Fred made us feel like family as soon as we stepped in the door. His recommendations were spot on and the food delivered quickly, beautifully presented and absolutely delicious. Can't wait to return to this restaurant when I'm back in Sarasota!

Such a great experience at this gem of a restaurant. The food was amazing, service was outstanding and drinks were tasty and strong! Or server Fred made us feel like family as soon as we stepped in the door. His recommendations were spot on and the food delivered quickly, beautifully presented and absolutely delicious. Can't wait to return to this restaurant when I'm back in Sarasota!

This is our second visit after the ownership changed and they have made some improvements since the last visit. Everything except the salad was great Service was fast and attentive I will be back next month

Fantastic hidden restaurant in the Sarasota area if you're looking for a well prepared, flavorful chef designed meal with homemade desserts you can't go wrong here make a reservation

A bit off the beaten path but well worth it. Clayton's has been here for years. New owner but same level of amazing taste. The drinks are great! Chowder soup was tasty and the daily soup- cream of asparagus was amazing. Grouper was out of this world! Scallops/Gnocchi was delicious. Key Lime for dessert. Highly recommend this restaurant. The chef and staff are great!

We have ALWAYS loved Clayton's! When we heard it changed hands we were unsure what to expect. Well, Mavis, has continued the tradition of fantastic food in a friendly atmosphere! And boy, that homemade butter is to die for! We will absolutely be back again and again!!!

We love Clayton's! The food and service are top notch. The new owner always takes time for all of the customers. Visiting all of the patrons and clearing tables. They added the coconut shrimp appetizer back and it is delicious. My prime rib was amazing. I typically order the braise short rib. It is an absolute must try. Their risotto options are the bomb. My favorite is with peas. We come to SK 4-5x a year. Clayton's is a must go to. Easy to make reservations on line and we have never had a bad meal in our 7 years of coming here. I highly recommend it. It's on the island. You don't have to worry about the bridge traffic and only a few minute drive from our condo on Turtle Beach.

Claytons is a real gem. Located conveniently by the South Bridge on Siesta. I had the grouper... delicious. Wife had the chicken... also delocious. Steak and shrimp was also amazing. Great service. Overall, just a great experience. We will be back.