Clarabell Cookies

6564 Superior Ave, Sarasota
(941) 923-1742

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Gluten-Free Walnut Chocolate Chip
Cocoa Caliente Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Double Dark Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Classic Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Horizon Whole Milk
Oatmeal Raisin
Snickerdoodle

Drinks
Organic Chocolate Milk (with straw!)
Organic Horizon Chocolate Milk (with straw!)
Organic Lowfat Milk (with straw!)
Organic Horizon Lowfat Milk (with straw!)
Organic Whole Milk (with straw!)
Horizon Organic Whole Milk

Cookies
Classic Chocolate Chip (Pack)
A premium chocolate chip cookie packed with Madagascar vanilla, chocolate chips, and a hint of pink Himalayan sea salt. Salty-sweet, with a thick, soft center. to Clarabell? Try this first-it's called "Classic" for a reason.
Snickerdoodle (Pack)
This premium, old-fashioned butter cookie is puffy, chewy, and fragrant. It's rolled in cinnamon and sugar for a delicious crunch.
Double Dark Chocolate Chip (Pack)
A premium chocolate cookie packed with natural cocoa and chocolate chips. Chocoholics, rejoice. The texture is thick and fudgy, like brownie batter in cookie form.
Peanut Butter (Pack)
This premium, soft peanut butter cookie is packed with all-natural peanut butter and rolled in super fine sugar for a delicious crunch. Our softest cookie, it's a peanut butter lover's dream.
Oatmeal Raisin (Pack)
A premium, chewy oatmeal cookie packed with juicy raisins and sweet cinnamon. Golden on the outside, with a perfectly tender center.
Walnut Chocolate Chip
A premium chocolate chip cookie packed with buttery walnuts and chocolate chips. Rich nutty flavor, generous chunks of walnut, and a soft center make this a fan favorite.

Cookie Packs
Choose any 6 Combination
Pick your 6 favorite cookies
Choose any 12 Combination
Pick your 12 favorite cookies

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+38 photos
Photo credit: google
+37 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Such a sweet, sweet shop! The owners are lovely and the cookies are so yummy, they are made fresh and you can tell. The chocolate is high quality and recipes are tried and tested until perfect :) It’s nice to walk in and see a smiling face instead of a screen, like at the competition (better prices too). Definitely recommend checking them out and supporting a small, family, business!!
January 2026
I LOVE Clarabell Cookies! It truly is the premier cookie destination. The cookies are made with high-quality, natural ingredients and are soft, moist, and totally delicious. Clara is the absolute sweetest, and I love seeing her whenever I visit Sarasota. I can't wait to come back!
December 2025
Yesterday, I walked into Clarabell Cookies because it reminded me of my favorite cookie shop in NYC. They had a sample cookie called a Cinnamon Roll that I had to try and I have been off sugar for MONTHS and let me tell you...it was worth it!!! It BLEW ME away it was KNOCK YOUR SOCKS off good!!! So many options so many reasons to return...I bought a Cinnamon Roll for my mom. She absolutely LOVED it! And let me tell you the people there were so nice!!! A must try! And she has the...
December 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Solorzano’s Pizzeria Gulf Gate / Siesta Key - 6574 Superior Ave
Pizza, Salad, Vegan
Sarasota Catering Company - 6544 Superior Ave
Caterers
Dolce Italia - Authentic Italian Restaurant - 6551 Gateway Ave
Italian

Clarabell Cookies

6564 Superior Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231
(941) 923-1742