Clayton's Siesta Grille
1256 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota
(941) 349-2800
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Great Italuan waitress. Best salmon!!!
Very crowded and loud place. Maitre d was bored slow and not the friendly sort. Although had reservation he wanted to be placed in outside venue, open booths that we saw but they had not been cleaned. I told him my name and time of reservation then after being seated he came back to request that information again. Obviously very interested in my discussion as that was all of 5 mins. The food was ok but not stellar. The rest was fine.
We went there for our birthdays and our birthdays were acknowledged when we checked in but we were disappointed that sharing a dessert was not offered The wait staff seemed rushed and we had 3 different servers We were over billed for wine and were told it would be taken off but wasn't and we had to ask again It could have been a better experience
We went on New Year's Eve with a reservation and were seated promptly in a packed house. The service was A+++. Water glasses never went unattended. The orders were accurate and came quickly. The drinks were good. The seafood chowder was out of this world, and I strongly recommend it. The food was delicious and the owner stopped by to make sure everything was OK. What more could you ask for? An amazing experience, a memorable evening. 
Our food, Halibut special and Filet, was second to none. Our waitress, Barbara was superb. Then there was the key lime pie… wow!
We've always had the best service at Clayton's on Thanksgiving. The staff and management are wonderful!
We had a lot of allergies and things in our group and everyone was fabulous and accommodating. Thank you!
The food was delicious, service was excellent, we love Clayton‘s and we will continue to patronize this awesome restaurant! 
Lovely service, great food. Heard only Great things about this place but would definitely come back again! Server Jacob was very accommodating, happy to make changes to my dish in order to suit my taste buds. Look forward to returning!
We arrived on time and were seated immediately, however we did not see our waitress for about 15 minutes. We place our drink order which too another 25 to receive! 3 of the 5 drinks were not prepared correctly had to be sent back - again another 15 minutes. We collected our bill and left without eating and remembered why we hadn't been there in over 5 years.
Restaurantji Recommends
Always a great dining experience! Great management, wonderful staff and consistently good food!!
Macadamia crusted grouper was awesome - Mac and cheese was the best though! Whole family loved our dinner - highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macadamia Crusted Grouper, Crusted Grouper, Macadamia Nut
If you want to have a wonderful dinner with family, in a family like atmosphere, Clayton's is the place to be. We had just that, last week, family members from across the state were in town to celebrate my father-in-laws 92nd birthday. As usual the food was fantastic, I had the halibut special and my wife had the always incredible grouper entree. Others at the table enjoyed various other meals. What surprised us the most was Chef James, the hostess and server came over our table to sing happy birthday to my father-in-law. They were friendly and engaging with all of us. We wholeheartedly recommend Clayton's for any occasion, especially 92nd birthdays!;^)
Great special, the fresh halibut. Amazing sides and delicious dark chocolate tort. Two nights in a row!!! Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Fast service.
Quick attentive service and delicious fish. Free bread and herb butter included! Midnight Pass Punch very reminiscent of the Caribbean!
Loading...