Clayton's Siesta Grille

Great meal at Clayton's. Very friendly staff. Mavis is very sweet and has put a ton of effort into rebuilding after 2024. The place looks great. Kitchen service was fast and food was fantastic. Must have the key lime pie! Will definitely be back!

Crab cake was phenomenal. My steak was cooked perfectly rare and the red snapper was prepared amazing

Food was lack luster at best. The special Red Snapper with was way over priced. The only seasoning on the fish was a bunch of salt making it way too salty. Was over cooked a little bit. The risotto was over cooked mush. Asparagus was not rip did not appear to be fresh. The drinks were even worse. Bar tender was drinking and pouring too heavy. The waiter did a great job however.

Our waitress was great. The food was excellent cocktails are always delicious. Everything was perfect. I definitely will be back. This is my favorite place.

Our server Barbara was pure joy and excellent at taking care of us. Food was excellent and perfectly prepared

Anniversary dinner there. It was perfect. Champagne wine steak Thank you see you again soon!!!

We have been going to Clayton's when we travel to Siesta since it opened but we hadn't gone for a couple of years and decided to go back; so glad we did! It has a casual and friendly ambiance, Mari Anne was wonderful and attentive, and gave us good recommendations. Dinner was delicious! My daughter ordered the steak and said it was tender and flavorful, my mom loved the coconut shrimp, my grouper was flaky and tasty, and the key lime pie was just right. Can't wait to go back next year.

Wife ordered fish tacos 8 out of 10 score 10 being best She ordered Miller lite draft and they were out I ordered a gold magarita and it was terrible didn't drink it Ordered a hamburger medium and it was raw and seeping blood worst I have ever experienced Fries were good

We came to Clayton’s as a group of 20 to celebrate an engagement. Freddie was an amazing server, the food was great and the staff were excellent. We will definitely be back!

What a wonderful our family had! Food was cooked to our specifications and tasted amazing. We totally enjoyed our meal and experience.

First time here and loved the ambiance. A laid back feel with excellent dinner options. Our server, Fred, was the best! It was for my Birthday and he had the whole restaurant sing Happy Birthday to me. I was kind of surprised he did this but it was a pleasant surprise. Thank you!

Clayton's is our “local”. Been going there for years, and never disappointed. Friendly staff, attentive service, and great food.

Excellent dinner which is often hard to come by. Chef ran out of the Corvina but substituted Grouper which we enjoyed very much. As a resident of Siesta Key for almost 20 years and now a visitor, I can say it is a very authentic experience and one of the very best dining options on the Key or even in Sarasota. You won't be disappointed. Enjoy!

We were all empty plates (party of 6). We has 2 short ribs, 1 special halibut, 2 filets, 1 salmon! The were able to accommodate gluten free! Crème brule, and chocolate cake were awesome! Great service and we keep coming back!

Great experience from start to finish! Our waiter was excellent! Very personable. Everything we ordered was delicious.