Der Dutchman
$ • Family, Bakery, American
Hours:
3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota
(941) 955-8007
About Der Dutchman
Customers' Favorites
Der Dutchman Reviews
Share your opinion about Der Dutchman
Der Dutchman in Sarasota is a gem. The food is hearty, fresh, and consistently delicious — especially the fried chicken and homemade pies. The buffet is always well stocked, and the bakery items are worth taking home. Staff are friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere feels warm and family-oriented. Highly recommend for anyone wanting a traditional Amish-style meal in Sarasota.
We hired Der Dutchman to cater our wedding on 5/17/25. While the food was great, the service, communication, and professionalism were extremely disappointing.
On our wedding day, guests had no water — in 90-degree heat. The top tier of our wedding cake (which should’ve been saved for our anniversary) was never set aside. Staff began clearing tables and removing centerpieces at 8:30 PM, even though our sendoff wasn’t until 10 PM and guests were still seated and enjoying...read full review
The food was AWFUL. Bland, tasteless and mush. My party of 5 only stayed for 15 minutes, asked for the bill & left.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Sarasota Also Viewed
Der Dutchman is a popular restaurant known for its delicious homemade comfort food and warm, inviting atmosphere. The restaurant offers a traditional Amish store setting that adds to its charming ambiance. The bakery and gift shop on-site are highly praised, with the bakery's desserts, including pies, described as heavenly.
The service at Der Dutchman is consistently friendly and welcoming, even when the restaurant is busy. Guests often comment on the fast and accommodating service, especially during special occasions. The buffet is always well-stocked with a variety of options, ensuring that the food is fresh and at the right temperature.
Many customers have praised the quality of the homemade dishes, including the fried chicken, blueberry cobbler, and noodles. The buffet is a popular choice, with guests enjoying the wide selection of hot, freshly prepared meals. The peaceful and relaxing environment at Der Dutchman makes it a great choice for a weekend outing, especially for large groups or family celebrations.
Overall, Der Dutchman provides a high-quality, homemade dining experience in a warm and inviting setting, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.