Five Star Pizza - Sarasota

Name: Five Star Pizza - Sarasota
Address: 4290 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota, Florida, 34233, US
Telephone: (941) 371-3333
Price range: $
Rating: 4.1

$ • Pizza, Vegetarian

Hours:
4290 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota
(941) 371-3333

Menu Order Online

About Five Star Pizza - Sarasota

Five Star Pizza is a dependable and consistent pizza restaurant known for offering good, fast, and affordable pies. The food is always hot and fresh, made with care, and there are plenty of vegetarian options available. Customers frequently praise the attentive and considerate service, especially during busy or challenging times like storms. The menu features popular items like wings, and try their pepperoni rolls—these are highly recommended and could help increase the restaurant’s popularity if promoted more. The restaurant has been a favorite since it stays open late, often until 3AM, making it a convenient choice for late-night cravings. The delivery service is fast, even during bad weather, with drivers patient and friendly. Prices are reasonable compared to chain restaurants, and the quality of ingredients is high—many customers note that they do not feel sick after eating, unlike some other pizza places. The crust, especially when paired with garlic butter, is tasty and adds to the overall experience. The kitchen is always clean, and the staff is helpful, often going above and beyond to make sure orders are correct and timely. Whether dining in or taking out, Five Star Pizza remains a reliable spot for satisfying pizza.