Five Star Pizza - Sarasota

4290 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota
(941) 371-3333

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

8 3 Topping Pizza Pepperoni Sausage and Onion
Half Veggie and Half Pineapple Specialty Pizza
Supreme Pizza Gluten Free Pizza
Bacon Double Cheeseburger
X-Large 2 Topping Pizza
Supreme Pizza Toppings
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Everything Pizza
Pepperoni Rolls
Cinnamon Rolls

Menu

Featured items
12" MEDIUM
Add your favorite toppings!
16" LARGE
Add your favorite toppings!
8pc GARLIC ROLLS
CINNAMON ROLLS
18" X-LARGE
Add your favorite toppings!
10pc WINGS
PEPPERONI ROLLS
CHEESY STIX
DELUXE
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Onions
4pc GARLIC ROLLS
20pc WINGS
PEPPERONI POWERHOUSE
Double Pepperoni & Extra Cheese
SPINACH & FETA
Sauced With Our Special Garlic Butter & Topped With Mozzarella, Feta & Spinach

BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
12" MEDIUM
Add your favorite toppings!
16" LARGE
Add your favorite toppings!
18" X-LARGE
Add your favorite toppings!
GLUTEN FREE 12"
Pizza is prepared in a common kitchen with the risk of gluten exposure. Our gluten free pizza is not recommended for customers with CELIAC DISEASE. Customers with gluten allergies/sensitivites should excercise judgement when consuming this pizza!

SPECIALTY PIZZAS
DELUXE
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Onions
EVERYTHING
Bacon, Banana Peppers, Beef, Black Olives, Green Peppers, Ham, Italian Sausage, Jalapeno Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Pepperoni, Pineapple & Tomato
PEPPERONI POWERHOUSE
Double Pepperoni & Extra Cheese
HAWAIIAN
Ham, Pineapple, & Extra Cheese
VEGGIE
Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Black Olives, and Tomatoes
CHICKEN ALFREDO
Sauced With Parmasan Garlic Alfredo And Topped With Mozzarella And Grilled Chicken
ALL THE MEATS
Pepperoni, Ham, Beef, Bacon & Sausage
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Sauced With Frank's Extra Hot Sauce and Topped With Mozzarella & Grilled Chicken
CHICKEN BACON RANCH
Sauced with Buttermilk Ranch And Topped With Mozzarella, Grilled Chicken, and Bacon
BACON DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER
Beef, Bacon, & Extra Cheese
SPINACH & FETA
Sauced With Our Special Garlic Butter & Topped With Mozzarella, Feta & Spinach
PHILLY CHEESE
Loaded With Philly Steak, Onions & Green Peppers
BBQ CHICKEN
Sauced with BBQ Sauce And Topped With Mozzarella & Grilled Chicken

WINGS
10pc WINGS
20pc WINGS
30pc WINGS
50pc WINGS

SIDES
8pc GARLIC ROLLS
CHEESY STIX
PEPPERONI ROLLS
4pc GARLIC ROLLS
CHICKEN TENDER BITES
3 ORDERS PEPPERONI ROLLS

LARGE SALAD
CAESAR
Parmesan cheese
GREEK
Tomatoes, cucumber, onions, black olives, & feta
CHEF SALAD
Ham, cheddar cheese, egg, onions, & tomatoes
CRANBERRY FETA SPINACH SALAD
Cranberries, feta, & almonds
SPINACH SALAD (LARGE)
Bacon, egg, onion, & mushrooms
GARDEN
Tomatoes, onions, & cucumbers

SMALL SALAD
CAESAR SALAD
Parmesan cheese
GREEK SALAD
Tomatoes, cucumber, onions, black olives, & feta
CHEF SALAD
Ham, cheddar cheese, egg, onions, & tomatoes
CRANBERRY FETA SPINACH SALAD
Cranberries, feta, & almonds
GARDEN SALAD
Tomatoes, onions, & cucumbers

DESSERT
CINNAMON ROLLS
BROWNIE
GRANDMAS CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Pack of 2 cookies
GRANDMAS PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES
Pack of 2 cookies

EXTRAS
GARLIC BUTTER
RANCH
MARINARA
CRUSHED RED PEPPER
PARMESAN
ICING
PLATES
NAPKINS
BLUE CHEESE
HOT SAUCE
CUPS
BANANA PEPPERS
MILD SAUCE
SIDE OF ANCHOVIES
HONEY MUSTARD
BBQ SAUCE
JALAPENOS
SIDE OF BUFFALO SAUCE

20oz
PEPSI
DR PEPPER
ROOT BEER
CHERRY PEPSI
ORANGE
SIERRA MIST
AQUAFINA
DIET PEPSI
MOUNTAIN DEW

2 LITERS
DR PEPPER
ORANGE
CHERRY PEPSI
SIERRA MIST
MOUNTAIN DEW
DIET PEPSI
BRISK ICED TEA

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+59 photos
Photo credit: google
+58 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I tell everyone Five Star is the best delivery pizza in the SRQ area. The big chains (dominoes, Pizza Hut even hungry howies) are all awful compared to five star. I also appreciate that 5 star isn’t overly salty like the others!! Amazing pizza keep it up!!
October 2025
Ordered thru uber eats tonight at 2am (thursday morning) whoever made my pizza did a fantastic job super tasty delicious and cooked well done like I asked! I appreciate the late night yummies!! Pizza was made with love!!
September 2025
I ran out to get some soda & my tenant was going to answer the door if the pizza got there before I got back. While gone, my phone rang with out of state number. I didn’t answer. As I’m driving home, I can see the delivery guy pulling out of my driveway & figured the out-of-state number might be him. I called back, it was. He was nice enough to call to tell me that nobody answered the door & I said my tenant was supposed to answer & he said nobody answered...
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Peach's Restaurant - Bee Ridge - 4292 Bee Ridge Rd
Breakfast, American, New American, Vegetarian
Basil's Flame Broiled Chicken - 4300 Bee Ridge Rd
Chicken, American, Chicken Wings
Burger King - 4346 Bee Ridge Rd
Burgers, Fast Food

Five Star Pizza - Sarasota

4290 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota, FL 34233
(941) 371-3333