Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria

Always fresh, crispy crust as it should be. My favorite in downtown Sarasota. Try the margherita, it's just perfect. Ordered the sicilian and veggie special today. Owners/staff are always pleasant and happy to serve.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is hands down the best pizza in town, and the service is phenomenal! Highly suggested!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing pizza and very friendly owner! 😊

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Hands down the best pizza in town!! We always get meatballs and fresh mozzarella. Perfect every time. The tiramisu is...I don't have words so here's the proper emoji 🤤

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fresh Mozzarella saves Saturday dinner again. Delicious pizza! The fresh Basil is a wonderful addition. One of the best gluten free options in town, and they’re so generous with toppings. Our favorite takeout. It was consumed before I could take photos 😂

Food: 5

Service: 5

I went there at about 330pm. No one was there. It was empty. I will say the ac did not seem to be working so that is why the 4 stars for atmosphere otherwise the lady at the counter was great and the pizza was really good as well as the mozzarella sticks. I was not a fan of the sauce to dip the mozzarella sticks in but I have never had a sauce that I liked because I like very sweet tomato sauce. That is just me. So I will not rate on the sauce. Overall I would go back for sure. I got the supreme pizza slice and it had big chunks of veggies and meat on it, which is what I like. If you like something that is more finely chopped then that pizza may not be for you. I did not try any of the pasta that they have so I cannot comment on that.

When we were there they weren't busy at all. The owner was very nice. And the meat lovers thin crust pizza was excellent . Every year we come to siesta keys we will b sure to stop for some pizza .

Quality continues to fall off from what it used to be. Weird vibe, too.

One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! very fine, thin crust. Not greasy, not heavy. The texture is just perfect 👌🏻

Great little hole in the wall pizzeria ristorante. My wife and I wanted a quick inexpensive dinner before going back to Central Deltona after a nice little vacation at Lake Manatee State Park. Rocco was very cordial and explained the menu. The people that went to the restaurant felt like regular customers just by the way they addressed Rocco, which tells me that local love to come and eat here. My wife and I had the house salad and a slice of pizza with a soda and it was very satisfying and yummy. This is not a fancy 5 stat ristorante, but a 5 star little hole in the wall with good food, great customer service and a family friendly environment. You feel right at home! 😊

Food felt like it was old or cooked too long...or both... .
Also expected lasagna to be filled to the top but it was halfway filled. I was disappointed.

Little shop, big impact. Went in for the first time and was immediately greeted by staff. Let him know it was my first time to which he responded with recommendations and asked if I wanted to take a seat or to go. Sat down, he came over talked for a bit and took my order. Got a slice and drink. You can tell it's made on the spot! Great stuff! On the way out I spoke to the gentleman some more and he gave me a takeout menu for the road and a gift card! These people treat you right, definitely never getting pizza from anywhere else again.

THE BEST!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Overpriced antipasto salad not at all worth 17.00. Garlic knots tasteless and burnt as was the calamari. The “marinara” sauce was the consistency of tomato juice.

Food: 1

Service: 4

Wow. I placed an order that was supposed to be picked up at 4:05pm. Walked into the restaurant at 4:05pm and there was no one to be found. Door unlocked and all ? So, we called the owner and he was laughing and saying there was “an emergency so we had to leave” and says “they make a million dollars, we will get your 90 dollars back” all while laughing. This is the worst place in town. The owner is so disrespectful. In total, no pizza and still no refund.

Update: We got the refund but the situation was not handled well :/ Truly unfortunate!!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1