Guerrero's Bakery and Mexican Restaurant

3557 Webber St, Sarasota
(941) 923-4459

Recent Reviews

Tonya Sandoval

Nasty nasty nasty nothing that has to do with Mexican food drinks food everything nasty change you name the worst place ever A restaurant that don’t care how they do the food they are just a restaurant that what ever food they make they sell care about money not

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sarasota Networks

Great wonderful food, as

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julio Oropeza

I ordered red chilaquiles feels like I ordered red nachos with some melted cheese and never got my meat choice with my

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dylan Riggall

This is the fourth time I have come here and have left happy and full Everytime. Service is great, food is served quickly and delicious as always. You'll definitely be seeing more of me!Ordered the "sopes"

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chimichanga, Mexican Chilaquiles, Chicken Tacos, Beef and Pork Tacos, Enchiladas, Molcajete, Guacamole Cheese, Chips and Salsa, Combination Fajitas, Chile Relleno, Burger, Burritos, Pan Dulce, Ceviche, Tamales, Carne Asada Nachos, Quesadilla with Rice and Beans, Nachos, Fajitas, Chicken Enchiladas with Green Sauce

Sandy Smith

Amazing beef tacos and beef enchiladas with green sauce. The beer was ice cold. Excellent service, delicious food, and reasonable prices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef and Pork Tacos, Enchiladas

Pj T.

Looks like a hole in the wall restaurant but don't let that fool you. Chips and house mango habanero salsa are very good and the food is always hot. Food is usually pretty good. Service is so so and they get our order wrong half the time. Also, they are very stingy with charging for every single item, especially on carry out. It's very frustrating. Wasn't always like this but the last year it's been outrageous .50 cents for lettuce, .50 cents for hot sauce, $1.50 for cheese! etc. every little thing just like Reyna's. And when you do order something it's not even enough for half your meal. We have decided to eat elsewhere, but in a pinch we will still eat here.

Barrison _

The beef tostadas I got tonight were absolutely. Freaking. Delicious. and I usually don't write reviews.

Food: 1

Miriam G.

We had a really nice server. The food looked very pretty. It was a little bit bland, and some of the chicken was a little dry but once I covered it with salsa, it was fixable.

Harry L.

My wife and I stopped in tonight at Guerrero's restaurant as I have been craving tacos well this place is awesome authentic Mexican food so as I looked at the menu the first thing I saw was the Cocktail Decameron and it was on so I ordered it with 2 corn tortilla beef tacos my wife had the plater which was pork tostada,2beef enchiladas a chili Reno that also came with rice and beans the portions were huge they have a salsa with chips the salsa amazing home made chips wow . We had a waitress Tresa outstanding so polite and attentive I have never had Fluan before and they have a chocolate cake under it it was pure heaven she gave us a milk cake on the house OMG . The decor added to the great experience I would recommend this place to anyone can't wait to go back next visit my wife said she will be trying the ceviche myself beef tacos and tamales.

Erica P.

Went for dinner 11/12/23 with 3 others. At 1st glance, the restaurant looked dirty.... it was very humid & smelled like a bathroom. We should have left right then. Food came out lukewarm & extremely bland. 2 of us did not get our beans and rice. The waitress never came back to check on us. We asked someone else for the beans & rice & they never came back with it! This morning 2 of the friends said they felt sick all night after their meal. Super disappointed after seeing the positive reviews. None of us will be back.

Ken Garman

Amazing authentic tacos! And our server Rust took great care of us!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Savannah

I love coming here! They have such good food, and the servers are always so nice especially Rust!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gail B

We were babysitting nearby and our son and daughter-in-law recommended this place so we ordered carryout. I've read some of the bad reviews so first of all this was the BEST Mexican food we've eaten since we moved here 7 years ago. And, coming from a city with a very large Hispanic population, this place is most like the Mexican food we are used to eating. The enchiladas were excellent and the homemade chips and salsa are the Best! Yes, the chips are a little thicker because they are homemade which I like. The sauce was very different and at first glance I wasn't sure if I would like it but Wow! It's flavorful and spicy, very good! Some of the staff may not speak the best English so be sure to check your order. Ours was missing an item so all we did was mention it and they very kindly rushed to add it to our carry-out. I can't wait to try another dish from their extensive menu and I want to visit their grocery across the street!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Enchiladas, Rice and Beans

Emma Shetler

I ordered fajitas. The chicken pieces were ridiculously large. Like they were tender size. Fajitas are traditionally served with sour cream, pico, guacamole, lettuce and shredded cheese. There's no cheese and some sort of mystery sauce came with it. I definitely would have preferred the chicken be a lot smaller pieces. I mean they are just giant. And they weren't seasoned a lot. It was pretty bland and then the rice was really bland as well. It didn't taste like traditional rice. The beans were delicious and so was the guacamole. The service was excellent and fast. I really hope that this is addressed and they fix it or is this just how they make them?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Rob Kroupa

The BEST dip (salsa) I’ve ever had. Fresh nopales (cactus). I recommend Biztec Texano or the Molcajete.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

Guerrero's Bakery and Mexican Restaurant

3557 Webber St, Sarasota, FL 34239
(941) 923-4459