Jersey Mike's Subs

2031 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota
(941) 706-2183

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ellen Bartlett

Marion, Cam , Jimmy and Curley. Great team! Friendly and efficient. They make my day better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

sean menor

They finally have chicken salad subs again, I’m very pleased!!! The chicken salad mixture is nice and normal….no weird additions and very tasty!! Update! I visited again today and the Chicken Salad wasn’t on the menu!!! But I asked and the guy said they still have it for the time being… but it will be going away soon…… so sad but happy that I was able to order it today, they were very nice about it!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Whitewashed Tomb

I visited this Jersey Mike’s on a Saturday afternoon with my wife and children, and unfortunately, it was one of the worst customer service experiences I have ever had at this chain. We eat at Jersey Mike’s regularly and have always had positive experiences elsewhere, but this location was the complete opposite.

The issue began when my seven-year-old son politely tried to place his order. Instead of taking the order directly from him, the employee behind the counter (the woman pictured above) turned to me and, without looking at him, dismissively asked, “What’s he saying?” Her tone was demeaning and made my son feel ignored — as if he wasn’t even worth being acknowledged. I was stunned, and calmly clarified that he had ordered a kids’ turkey sub.

From there, things only got worse. While still cutting meat for the first sandwich, she demanded that I place my order, my wife’s order, and the rest of my children’s orders all at once — five sandwiches, each with modifications. I politely asked if she was sure she could keep them straight, and she curtly replied that she wouldn’t have asked if she couldn’t remember. Unsurprisingly, she struggled to keep track of everything, became visibly irritated, and spoke to us with open hostility.

When I mentioned again that I did not appreciate the way she had spoken to my son, she flat-out called me a liar. At that point, the interaction turned confrontational, and she told us, “Well, you can just leave if you don’t like it.” We did exactly that — walked out without our food, shaken by how needlessly rude and aggressive she had been.

It was clear this employee did not want to be there and resented the very customers she was supposed to serve. No one expects perfection, especially when short-staffed, but what is unacceptable is blatant disrespect — particularly toward a child — and escalating to calling a customer dishonest instead of resolving concerns professionally.

I strongly encourage management to review how this store is staffed and to address this employee’s conduct. A brand built on hospitality and friendliness cannot afford to have representatives who treat guests like an inconvenience.

Service: 1

j vanhook

Great sandwiches

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beachy

They raised prices again recently, A lunch, Small sandwich, chips and a drink is now over $17, not worth it anymore for the price, Subway is not as good in taste, but for half the price you can get double the amount of food if you use the app, The Mike's app will give you a free sandwich after like 15 trips with shore points, not worth it anymore, Sad - There is a potbelly just down the street too that is cheaper

Scott Williams

Fairly typical Jersey Mike's. Not much on-site parking. Food was decent but inside wasn't the cleanest.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Bella Brownies

Everytime I come here, without fail, my sandwich is always perfect and delicious idk how you guys do it. Every place has its bad day like sometimes my sandwich would be too wet or they forget stuff. But not you guys. My sandwich is ALWAYS MIRACULOUS AND IMMACULATE I’m typing this with sauce still on my fingers bc I have to let you guys know how good your sandwiches are. Also, orders are always ready the time it says. Thank you guys for the delicious subs without fail

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Klingner aka BigDaddy

Great staff great subs

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zuzana Shaw Novakova

Great staff and tasty sandwiches

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Windsor Walker

It's always great when at this location! Jessica and her team handle business!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Littrell

Long line due to the online orders that seem to take priority over the people standing in from of you.. could've been much cleaner atmosphere ..
food was good

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Ramin Sami

Jessica was absolutely best. You don't see customer service like this anymore

Say Sysouvanh

Man I can’t enough great things about this place! I was turned on by the Philly cheesesteak and that’s my go to all the time! The staff are very friendly nice and always greet you and even though ver the phone they are super nice!! I love and recommend this place !! Great job guys on a job well done!!👍 🍾🔥🙏💯👍❤️

James Gibson

Staff friendly, sandwich looked so goood it was a shame to eat it. Fast service

Elisa Elisa

I ordered a club wrap with double meat, but when I got back to my office, I realized it didn’t have the extra meat I paid for. On top of that, there were maybe six small crumbles of bacon — definitely not what I expected for the price.

Loading...