Jersey Mike's Subs

3820 S Tuttle Ave, Sarasota
(941) 822-0519

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Yokie P.

Bacon was Raw not cooked

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

David Hinze

Very good sandwiches and friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DeadBones Brook

Fella at the counter greeted us as we walked in. Told him it was our first time in. He told us to ask questions or for recommendations. Very friendly. Social customers. Robert is awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Ricky Lopez

The best Italian subs; always fresh cold cuts, and out of this world customer service.
Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Spangle Taylor

We really enjoy coming here. I'm giving a one star until they get someone to professionally clean their bathrooms. We like to come here but every time we come here and I have to go wash my hands. I want to vomit at the smell. They just need someone to come in here, do a good cleaning, use some bleach. And then make sure that it stays that way. There's a drain and ladies bathroom that is just filthy and smelly. But other than that the employees are super nice. Everything else is decent. Food is great! Next time I come here I want to go in the bathroom and actually want to wash my hands! And there are some water leaks You may want to take care of being this as a food establishment that hate to think there's mold hanging out of the ceilings.

Cassie Iturrino

Food is always good. Rolls are super soft. Service is hit or miss depending on who is working.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

brenden coviello

and this is the result of the Blackstone acquisition. got the phily, barely any meat, onions, or peppers. guess thats how Blackstone wants to increase profits. was not like this before. they lost a customer. this place is now the same as subway.

Food: 1

Pauly Paul

honest review the staff is very polite and the food is good but they had me pay for my sub before the bread was even cut..the lady kept asking if I want it mikes way ..I was like I just want to tell you when the bread is cut and the meat is put on that sounded odd to her lol ..very odd sub experience not to mention the guy was asking which size bag should the giant size sub go in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

Joseph Klingner aka BigDaddy

Delicious awesome employees

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beverly Webb

Let me start by saying Wow. I am absolutely floored by the level of customer service provided in this location. My daughter is very picky, but has some how come to love the club sub from Jersey Mikes and refuses to get a sandwich from anywhere else. In particular she loves this location. Generally, every store we visit provides a great food experience, but there is something or should I say someone this location has, that others don’t. This gentleman’s name is Todd. Todd provides exemplary service. He recognizes my daughter and to a T remembers her exact order, and even got her to try a different bread. If this man doesn’t run this store he SHOULD. I cannot say enough positive words about what I experienced as I watched him interact with our whole family. Thank you Todd, for going above and beyond. Thank you for being a shining example of what it means to make a difference in somebodies day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittany Andrews

I made an order thru uber eats & had to fix a few problems called the store Robert the assistant manager got me right he was really nice & patient we need more people like him..keep that attitude Robert you made my day

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wicked treasures Sarasota

these guys are good here always friendly and food is always as expected never any issues we are here alot to

Todd Guberman

Very unhappy when I ordered something different one time The 17 Philly I paid 15 dollars for a sloppy mess I'll spare you the photo out of respect because I do like this place most of the time but this is a F minus for this philly cheese steak. Soggy sloppy mess.

Carolyn P

Jersey Mikes is our go to sub stop. However, the last two orders we’ve place have been very lacking in substance. The amount of roast beef on my sub has definitely been reduced and the total price of $24 including tip for two 9” subs is way too much for less of a sandwich than it used to be. Will be rethinking our future sub purchases.

Lyn San Pietro

Delicious 😋 Great staff!

Loading...