Ice cream was so creamy and delicious. Glad I was able to come and try this place! I will def be coming back!
Jeff M
Sorry to disappoint everyone, Main Street Creamery has super average ice cream. THEY DON'T MAKE IT. Read the information on the ice cream tubs in their fridge, it's by Yoders! If you go to any Detweiler's grocery store, you get the exact same ice cream, fresh behind the counter or in the frozen section . . . and it costs half the price. You will find Yoders in grocery stores all over the place. No relation to the Yoder family in the Pinecraft / Amish district in Sarasota btw. Yoder's ice cream has tons of junk ingredients (gums, corn syrup?!!, natural flavers, etc). If you want to try decent ice cream, try Made In Rome Organic Gelato on Siesta Key. I admit it's expensive, but at least they actually make it, there are no junk ingredients like there are in the Main Street Creamery Yoders ice cream.
Isamar Galay
Absolutely loved the ice cream, it was delicious! The prices are fantastic, and the staff couldn’t have been nicer. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this spot!
Curt Hencye
Love it!
Joshua Gilreath
Delicious ice-cream and very friendly. So many flavors to choose from. Staff is very nice and it makes for a great experience. I wish there was more indoor seating for the really hot days but if you don't come during busy hours this is not an issue.
Felicia Chang
Great ice cream shop with lovely flavors and kind staff. Location is right in downtown so convenient to walk around.
Thai A
Amazing!!!!! Friendly environment
Chris Barsoum
Phenomenal
Sarah Scarlett
We were walking by and got sucked in by the amazing waffle cone smell. So many fun and unique flavors while still honoring the traditional choices. Triple peanut butter in a waffle bowl hit the spot. The staff was helpful and friendly as well!
Jennifer Mobley
I'm only here for 1 week with my husband and so I was researching on the best places/shops/stores to go in Sarasota and A LOT said to visit this place as it's one of the best - so we went last night and I'd say IT'S THE BEST ICE CREAM I EVER HAD in my life!!! The staffs were all very helpful in what I could get so THANK YOU!!! You guys are awesome!!!
Bury me with the banana cream pie ice cream plus toasted marshmallow meringue topping please.
Vilma Jordan
While vacationing in the most awesome place in Florida, Sarasota, Bradenton, but just walking , rolled up on this gem. Good old fashioned ice cream, waffle cone, carmel sunday with 4 different nut to choose from... The old fashioned ice cream maker, just like mom use to have. Nice spot.for old fashioned ice cream. MAIN street Creamery! Sarasota Florida. Great location to see the eclectic shops. Perfect location! Great Service with a smile 😃. Good job young people!
Dmitriy Kurudymov
Exceptional service, welcoming interior, perfect place to spend some time. Oh yeah and they have good ice cream. ;)
Heather W
Delicious! Must visit!
Selena Ball
The best ice cream I’ve had in a while! The customer service was amazing! This will definitely be my go to!
Ice cream was so creamy and delicious. Glad I was able to come and try this place! I will def be coming back!
Sorry to disappoint everyone, Main Street Creamery has super average ice cream. THEY DON'T MAKE IT. Read the information on the ice cream tubs in their fridge, it's by Yoders! If you go to any Detweiler's grocery store, you get the exact same ice cream, fresh behind the counter or in the frozen section . . . and it costs half the price. You will find Yoders in grocery stores all over the place. No relation to the Yoder family in the Pinecraft / Amish district in Sarasota btw. Yoder's ice cream has tons of junk ingredients (gums, corn syrup?!!, natural flavers, etc). If you want to try decent ice cream, try Made In Rome Organic Gelato on Siesta Key. I admit it's expensive, but at least they actually make it, there are no junk ingredients like there are in the Main Street Creamery Yoders ice cream.
Absolutely loved the ice cream, it was delicious! The prices are fantastic, and the staff couldn’t have been nicer. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this spot!
Love it!
Delicious ice-cream and very friendly. So many flavors to choose from. Staff is very nice and it makes for a great experience. I wish there was more indoor seating for the really hot days but if you don't come during busy hours this is not an issue.
Great ice cream shop with lovely flavors and kind staff. Location is right in downtown so convenient to walk around.
Amazing!!!!! Friendly environment
Phenomenal
We were walking by and got sucked in by the amazing waffle cone smell. So many fun and unique flavors while still honoring the traditional choices. Triple peanut butter in a waffle bowl hit the spot. The staff was helpful and friendly as well!
I'm only here for 1 week with my husband and so I was researching on the best places/shops/stores to go in Sarasota and A LOT said to visit this place as it's one of the best - so we went last night and I'd say IT'S THE BEST ICE CREAM I EVER HAD in my life!!! The staffs were all very helpful in what I could get so THANK YOU!!! You guys are awesome!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Bury me with the banana cream pie ice cream plus toasted marshmallow meringue topping please.
While vacationing in the most awesome place in Florida, Sarasota, Bradenton, but just walking , rolled up on this gem. Good old fashioned ice cream, waffle cone, carmel sunday with 4 different nut to choose from...
The old fashioned ice cream maker, just like mom use to have. Nice spot.for old fashioned ice cream. MAIN street Creamery! Sarasota Florida. Great location to see the eclectic shops. Perfect location! Great Service with a smile 😃. Good job young people!
Exceptional service, welcoming interior, perfect place to spend some time. Oh yeah and they have good ice cream. ;)
Delicious! Must visit!
The best ice cream I’ve had in a while! The customer service was amazing! This will definitely be my go to!
Loading...