Main Street Creamery

1359 Main St, Sarasota
(941) 361-2046

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Banana Pudding with Chocolate Peanut Butter Sauce
Cookie Dough and Siesta Ice Cream
Cotton Candy Mocha Almond Fudge
Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Cone
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Soft-Serve Birthday Cake
Toasted Marshmallow
Toasted Coconut
Cookie Monster
Brownie Sundae

Menu

Ice Cream
PINT - CHOCOLATE
Velvety rich chocolate ice cream!
PINT - BUTTER PECAN
A classic favorite! Warm and nutty butter pecan flavored ice cream mixed with roasted pecans!
PINT - BIRTHDAY CAKE
Cake batter flavored ice cream with real pieces of birthday cake, sprinkles, and a blue icing ribbon!
PINT - BANANA CRUNCH
Creamy banana ice cream with chocolate flakes and walnuts mixed in!
PINT - CARIBBEAN RUM RAISIN
Sweet and creamy rum raisin flavored ice cream with plump raisins!
PINT - CHOCOLATE FUDGE BROWNIE
Rich chocolate ice cream with a chocolate swirl and brownie bites!
PINT - COOKIE MONSTER
Blue vanilla ice cream with pieces of chocolate sandwich cookies and bites of cookie dough!
PINT - COOKIES-N-CREAM
A classic favorite! Delicious vanilla ice cream with pieces of chocolate sandwich cookies!
PINT - ESPRESSO CHIP
Creamy espresso flavored ice cream with chocolatey espresso flakes!
PINT - KEY LIME PIE
Delicious key lime flavored ice cream with graham cracker pieces!
PINT - MINT CHIP
A classic favorite! Mint flavored ice cream with chocolate flakes mixed in.
PINT - MUD SLIDE
Velvety chocolate ice cream with hints of coffee and a stream of chocolate, mixed with brownie bites, chocolate flakes, and pieces of chocolate sandwich cookies!
PINT - SEA SALT CARAMEL SWIRL
Experience the delightful blend of sea salt and caramel in a creamy swirl. Autogenerated by DoorDash.
PINT - STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
Rich cheesecake flavored ice cream with bites of cheesecake and a sweet strawberry swirl!
PINT - TOASTED COCONUT
The island of paradise! Toasted coconut flavored ice cream with toasted coconut flakes!
PINT - TOFFEE BUTTER
Our version of the classic Butter Brickle! Sweet buttery ice cream with a hint of salt, with chocolate-coated toffee pieces!
PINT - TRIPLE PEANUT BUTTER
Peanut butter ice cream with a peanut butter swirl and peanut butter pieces!
PINT - VANILLA
The original! Creamy and delicious.
PINT - VANILLA (NO SUGAR ADDED)
Delicious vanilla flavored ice cream without added sugar.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+39 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+38 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Always love coming here! Quality of ice cream and diversity of flavors is outstanding! Staff is super helpful and friendly. Don’t skimp on scoops. Line moves quick because plenty of staff. Pricing reasonable. Will be back again and again!
April 2025
Me and my family rate ice cream places everywhere we go. There’s 5 of us and each of us rates the place out of 10 which means the total is out of 50. Every time we’ve gone to Florida we’ve gone to Main Street creamery and it’s gotten 50/50 every time. 10 points of that 50 were from my mom who cannot have any gluten or dairy which tells you that they REALLY know what they’re doing when it comes to ice cream. She says it’s the best ice cream she’s ever had. We love...
April 2025
Great employees. Don't let the long lines scare you there's a reason as this is hands down some of the best ice cream on the planet. The kids are still talking about it. There are so many flavors it makes it hard to decide. If I'm anywhere near Sarasota, I will visit Main Street Creamery. You're the best! Paul
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

The Fat Rabbit Pub - 1359 Main St
Bar, Seafood, Chicken Wings
Cafe Amici Downtown - 1371 Main St
Italian, Seafood, Wine Bar, Vegetarian
El Melvin Cocina Mexicana - 1355 Main St
Mexican, Pet Friendly

Main Street Creamery

1359 Main St, Sarasota, FL 34236
(941) 361-2046