Jake's Ice Cream on Siesta Key

Delicious! I was impressed with the unique variety of flavors.

We chose Jake's due to their 4.9 stars on Google. They did not disappoint! The service was very friendly and the ice cream cones were excellent. Highly recommend! :-)

Best cookie dough ice cream I’ve ever had. Definitely tasted homemade. Worth the hot walk we made there and back for sure.

Amazing ice cream- the flavor is simple yet delicious. One of the best ice cream places in Sarasota and for a pretty good price.

Best ice cream in Sarasota/Siesta key.

Incredible malted vanilla milk shakes. (My favorite thing here)

My favorite ice cream is Turtle Beach. Lots of amazing interesting flavors and classics.

Delicious,decadent ice cream!

I have gone here for over a year and I’m a loyal customer to cookies and cream 10/10

Amazing ice cream by amazing people! Made in-house in his own shop. Described the making of each ice cream as we received samples! Definitely recommend this place for some of the best ice cream you’ll ever have in your life.

Tried their orange cream ice cream and it was great. Staff were chill and so friendly!

Best ice cream EVER! Go get some!

Fantastic. Friendly service. Generous portions. Will come back.

Jake's ice cream is a homemade ice cream experience. The ingredients are fresh and not mass ordered. Thought goes into every flavor and there is continual refinement. The staff is warm and friendly. The ice cream is yummy and every bite leaves you wanting more. Butter pecan to cherry are my faves, but the orange is awesome and refreshing.

Jake’s ice cream is delicious. While there was a line it went by very fast. The flavors are delectable, the strawberry is one of the best I’ve tasted in my life.

Good product, service and an excellent location. If you recall visiting an ice cream shop as a kid after a day at the beach, this place will easily take you back there with flavors that appeal to all ages to boot.

Only caveat is the waffle cones aren't hand-made as advertised. This is a bit of a letdown as I've been looking for places that do fresh made waffle cones for a good while.

Yummy homemade ice cream with unique flavors. If you plan to eat your ice cream outside ask for a larger cup than you plan on getting, such as a single scoop in a two scoop cup. We learned our lesson at another ice cream shop. The single scoop cups are small and filled with a huge single scoop. If you want any room for melt, which is bound to happen in the Florida heat you'll need the extra space in the cup to avoid an overflowing mess. We were able to walk to the location from our condo, but if you need to drive there is free parking for customers.