The Cookie Cottage
335 Gillespie Ave, Sarasota
(941) 552-6914
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Couldn't be happier! First off the cookies tasted amazing, but they looked beautiful too! Being able to customize so much was so great! They were the perfect edition to the party and everyone loved them! Highly recommend this place! Worth every penny!
We love decorating cookies here! Everytime we go, the owner is so sweet!
The Cookie Cottage isn’t just for cookies! We ordered 75 pig cupcakes for a Pig Roast. Not only were they absolutely adorable but they were delicious too. A great price as well. Absolutely delighted!
Everyone LOVED them!🩵
We had our daughters birthday there today. It was amazing!!!! Everything was delicious, clean, and organized. Great job Cathy, thank you for having us today!
Amazing experience! Cathy was awesome, accommodating, and made everything so easy and seamless. I ordered take-home cookie decorating kits for my sister's bridal shower and everything was perfect. We had a ton of fun decorating them & they were very tasty. I highly recommend The Cookie Cottage!
It is SO cozy and beautiful space! ✨ But most of all – the warmest owner, Cathy. 💛 We celebrated Alisa’s 11th birthday here, and it was absolutely amazing! The kids had so much fun baking and decorating Hawaiian-style cookies, painting fans, and decorating cupcakes. 🏝️🍪🎨 Cathy also told us about her summer camp – we will definitely come back and bring our friends! 😊 See you soon! 🌟
It is SO cozy and beautiful space! ✨ But most of all – the warmest owner, Cathy. 💛
We celebrated Alisa’s 11th birthday here, and it was absolutely amazing! The kids had so much fun baking and decorating Hawaiian-style cookies, painting fans, and decorating cupcakes. 🏝️🍪🎨
Cathy also told us about her summer camp – we will definitely come back and bring our friends! 😊
See you soon! 🌟
All around great experience! Cathy was so nice and easy to work with! The cookies were seriously the best tasting decorative cookies I’ve ever had! So pretty and equally tasty! I look forward to ordering more in the future!
Cathy not only bake delicious cookies but is a true artist in decorating. Her attention to detail is superb. Cathy made White Coat cookies for my niece's Dental White Coat Ceremony. What a big hit at our luncheon when the cookies were placed on display. Each cookie was individually wrapped in cellophane and made the perfect party favor for all. Cathy delivers 100% of quality in taste and design.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
SO SO cute!! Just took my daughter to a 7th bday party and it was SO cute! They decorated cookies and aprons and cupcakes. The lady running it was very nice and patient. Definitely recommend for artistic kiddos who love sweets!!!
Kid-friendliness: Such a fun place for kids bday parties or anything like that. Would be really fun around the holidays I’m sure!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had my daughter’s bday party here with 10 girls. Kathy was so amazing she even found the theme my daughter wanted- Axolotyls! The kids had the most amazing time and enjoyed baking and making their cookies. I highly recommend the cookie cottage! Kathy takes all the stress away so moms can actually enjoy their child’s special day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Affordable! Very generous and kind staff. Good prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful cookies, we ordered for a showerAnd they tasted wonderful and were loved by all the guestShe does an outstanding
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had a great time decorating Christmas cookies!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...