The Fat Donkey
1461 Main St, Sarasota
(941) 260-9531
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
10/10 would recommend if you are in Siesta Key Florida. I would recommend this place
Service was great. Ice cream was delicious. If you need a cool treat, this is the spot
It’s a cool place for a nice pit stop or place to have a cool treat on a hot day
i really liked kurt
Kurt and Mateus were exactly what my family needed to end the night with a wonderful 😊 I've cream 🍦!! Pleasant attitudes
If you're looking for an unforgettable treat, look no further! This place serves the best ice cream I have ever tasted. Seriously, it's a game-changer! Beyond the deliciousness, the service was just amazing – welcoming and super efficient. From stepping in to getting my scoop, it was fast, seamless, and an overall incredibly great experience. Can't wait to go back!
Such a weird set up: you order and pay, THEN wait 30 minutes for your ice cream order; it's regular ice cream, nothing special, just expensive. The watermelon sorbet was tasty, the cookie dough was cookie dough, and the strawberry shake was liquid. I feel bad for the kids who work there, they need adult supervision. Good location and it's open until 11 (pretty late for a place around here that doesn't sell alcohol).
Yall BE HATING its amazing and thas was one scoop. And not expensive. I'm from Hawaii and for this I'm impressed
Huge !!! Gluten free and dairy free options!!! 8 dollars each for this huge ice cream sandwich with fresh gluten free cookies and dairy free ice cream
Google says they close at 11pm and if you get there at 10:30, the kids working there will be rude and tell you “we are closed” almost yelling at you. They had a really bad attitude and treated customers rude just to get rid of the final customers and leave.
Door remains open, and they will keep denying customers non stop.
Their ice cream is extremely basic and nothing special.
Restaurantji Recommends
f you’re in the area and craving something sweet, it’ll do in a pinch. But if you’re willing to walk a few blocks, Main Street Creamery is absolutely worth the detour—superior flavor, texture, and overall experience.
This place is amazing!! They have a Cherry ice cream that is the best! There can be long lines, but they move quick and service is usually very good!
Below average ice cream. It was more icy than creamy. I got the chocolate malt ice cream, which promised malt balls, but there wasn’t a single one in sight in the ice cream. It tasted like a cheap Hershey’s chocolate syrup was mixed in. Gets three stars for its flavor variety.
Said they closed at 11pm went in at 10 and staff said they were closed even though the door was open and sign said open and they still had ice cream. I just wanted some ice cream.
Ice cream was okay. But the place smelt like urine. Probably soundly go back.
Loading...