Goodfellas Pizza

9615 US-1, Sebastian
(772) 388-0048

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Teresa Dileo

Ored a calzone tonight ,I wanted pepperoni, sausage, green peppers ,, what I got was meat lovers calzone. Not what I asked for ,,never again,,also a few months ago they messed up a pizza ored was supposed to get free one that never happened,,,why have menu or ask cuswhat they want if your going to just cook waht u want

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Large Calzones

B F

Worst pizza i ever had

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Monk Daddy

Ordered the Philly Cheese steak with a side of disappointment. The sandwich tasted like it was flavored with a beef ramen packet. Very unsatisfied. Probably won't go back.

Food: 3

Service: 4

Nick.Tait33

Not open till 10 actually 9 since the hour change. Weird. Open sign on. Won’t be back.

Donna O'Neill

Delivery was fast for a large order on a Saturday night! Pizza and mozzarella moons were good. Do not waste your money on the knots- oil was soaked through them and there was so much garlic they were inedible.

Food: 3

Service: 5

Thomas M

Ordered the Italian feast which was a little odd that it doesn't come with buffalo sauce and then they charged $1.82 extra for the sauce after we ordered $30+ off food and fountain drinks. Italian feast comes with two large pieces of breaded and fried chicken which if I were to judge the restaurant just on the chicken it would be 5 stars 🤩. Pizza was ok, stuffed pizza looked fantastic. Would go again just for that.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Karen Glidden

Ordered 2 pizzas for take out and spent 45.00. Pizzas were way over cooked borderline burnt. Tried calling and seemed to be having phone problems. Earlier when I tried to order on line the order wouldn't go through. Probably won't go back.

Food: 1

Service: 5

Donna Russo

Ordered a large pizza delivered last night. Half pepperoni and half sausage and red roasted peppers. The pizza was better than others in Sebastian except for the sausage. It lacked any flavor but tasted horribly old and just shy of turning bad. I paid $44 and change for a pizza and salad of which half the pizza had to be thrown out because those eating the sausage couldn't stand the bad taste it had. My rating of only two stars would have been better if it hadn't been for the sausage quality.

Sonia Perry

Cold atmosphere, food is 100% terrible no love. Papa John’s can do way better or earls by 1 million percent. Over priced: 3 calzone and a salad 80$ 👀
Very disappointed that I ordered from the Vittorio menu and ended up in that trash hole of good fellas! Worse place for pizza after little Ceasar! 🤦🏻‍♀️

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

RAW Outdoors

Order was placed and drove 25 to 30 minutes there to be told everything would be ready in 20 minutes while there’s no other people in the restaurant that after 20 minutes had to wait another 15 minutes before I saw food and there was one other customer there the entire Time that I was there half the stuff was done and Had to sit while we waited the extra 15 minutes total for the other stuff to be done too

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bob Blair

Food sucks

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Matthew Finstad

I placed an online order and was given a time of delivery. After it was 40 minutes late I called to get an update. I was told it would be a minimum of another hour with no actual time. The business should provide accurate information. If they are that far behind call.

Service: 1

Ale L

Worst place to get Italian in town. Everything was terrible. My spaghetti was so watery! It actually leaked out yet there was STILL a pool of liquid in the container after it leaked. My salad was terrible too. I paid 1.50 for cheddar and 0.75 for egg. I got HALF of an egg and a pinch of clumped up cheese. I ordered a brownie and it was cold, hard, and smelled like vegetable oil. Never ordering here again. Just got to Vic’s or literally anywhere else.

Food: 1

Bill Gault

The pizza was the bomb, a must try when in Vero

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Side House Salad, Pizza

Cindy Allen

Ordered a pie with light cheese, extra sauce, and double sausage. Despite being told there was sauce under the cheese when I opened it to look, there was no sauce at all on the pie. $27.95 for disappointment. Don't go.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...